The article by Sudbø and colleagues (April 1 issue)
1 advances the understanding of dysplastic oral leukoplakia, but the suggestion that surgical removal is ineffective in preventing oral carcinoma is highly debatable. There is agreement that advanced dysplasia appears to be incurable in many patients, and recurrences are common. Although the adjacent epithelium appears to be normal on clinical and microscopical examination, it most likely is altered genetically and destined to become dysplastic within a few cell generations. The study cohort was evaluated every six months, and many lesions were followed without biopsy if the clinical presentation did not change. Of the 26 aneuploid leukoplakias that evolved into carcinoma, 20 were clinical stage III or worse. Since it would be most unusual for clinically normal epithelium to evolve to cancer of stage III or higher during a six-month period, many of these carcinomas most likely arose in patients whose leukoplakias were treated by “watchful waiting.” Until new effective treatments and preventive therapies are developed, these data strongly support early and repeated surgical removal of dysplastic oral leukoplakia and show the terrible toll that results from watchful waiting.