20 January 2022 in IEEE Transactions on Engineering Management
The evaluation of innovation capability (IC) plays a key role in an age of keen competition driven by modern technologies, since it enables organizations to review their innovation management process and to adjust their corresponding innovation policies. Moreover, the IC evaluation is, in fact, a multicriteria process with high uncertainty, since the market environments and competitors’ performance are both in a dynamic environment. Therefore, the evaluation of IC under uncertainty is vital to organizations. This study proposes a new integrated method for the evaluation of IC in banking organizations by combining the analytic hierarchy process (AHP) and the evidential reasoning (ER) approach in terms of the Dempster–Shafer theory of evidence. Three Vietnamese banks were used as a case study to demonstrate the applicability and validity of the proposed method. Experts in banking-related fields were invited to determine the relative importance weights of critical innovation management practices (CIMPs) and their sub-CIMPs using the AHP and to score the maturity levels of sub-CIMPs at the evaluated banks. The ER approach was then applied to generate aggregated assessments representing the ICs of banks that were finally used for their ranking in terms of IC.
4 July 2023 in IEEE Access
In the era of fierce competition under the evolution of advanced technologies, service innovation plays a decisive role in the survival of organizations. The service innovation evaluation problem becomes necessary for organizations to review their innovation performances for making according policies to develop innovative services to satisfy customer needs. This paper addresses the problem by developing a new methodology for evaluation of service innovation in banking organizations from the customer perspective. As service innovation is typically characterised by multiple indicators that are qualitative in nature with their performance being assessed subjectively by customers, we first formulate the evaluation problem of service innovation using customer surveys as that of multi-criteria decision making under uncertainty and then develop an evaluation model based on the evidential reasoning approach by means of Dempster-Shafer theory of evidence for solving it. We conducted an empirical study of three banks in Vietnam to illustrate the effectiveness and applicability of the proposed methodology. It has been shown that the evaluation outcome could provide banks with their competitive advantages compared with competitors in terms of service innovation.