11 January 2019 in Proceedings of the IEEE
Codes of ethics provide a critical foundation for an organization to define the tenets that best reflect their values. These codes provide a touchstone for employees to follow that establishes trust between an organization and their customers and key stakeholders. The rapid acceleration of autonomous and intelligent systems (A/IS) has created an imperative for technologists to complement these codes with new methodologies focused on the widespread implementation of ethical considerations in all levels of design and manufacture. This paper describes IEEE's work in this arena, including the IEEE Global Initiative on Ethics of Autonomous and Intelligent Systems, the IEEE TechEthics program, the IEEE P7000 Standards Series focused on A/IS issues, Digital Inclusion through Trust and Agency, and the ongoing work of the IEEE Society on Social Implications of Technology. This paper also includes a table of approximately 50 activities within the IEEE related to ethics.
30 January 2023 in IEEE Transactions on Technology and Society
Since 2016 a significant program of work has been initiated by the U.S. Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency (DARPA) under the title of explainable artificial intelligence (XAI). This program is seen as important for AI adoption, in this case to include the needs of warfighters to effectively collaborate with AI “partners.” Technology adoption is often promoted based on beliefs, which bears little relationship to the benefit a technology will provide. These beliefs include “progress”, technology superiority, and technology as cornucopia. The XAI program has widely promoted a new belief: that AI is in general explainable. As AI systems often have concealed or black box characteristics, the problem of explainability is significant. This paper argues that due to their complexity, AI systems should be approached in a way similar to the way the scientific method is used to approach natural phenomena. One approach encouraged by DARPA, model induction, is based on post-hoc reasoning. Such inductive reasoning is consistent with the scientific method. However, that method has a history of controls that are applied to create confidence in an uncertain, inductive, outcome. The paper proposes some controls consistent with a philosophical examination of black boxes. As AI systems are being used to determine who should have access to scarce resources and who should be punished and in what way, the claim that AI can be explained is important. Widespread recent experimentation with ChatGPT has also highlighted the challenges and expectations of AI systems.
13 December 2024 in IEEE Transactions on Technology and Society
This article synthesizes the insights gained through presentations and discussions at the 2023 IEEE Workshop on Norbert Wiener in the 21st Century (21CW2023), which focused on “The Future of Work in the Age of Automation.” Hosted at Purdue University, this interdisciplinary convening of technologists, social scientists, and humanists explored the impacts of automation on labor, drawing on Wiener’s legacy of insights as a backdrop to examine the technologically mediated future we face in coming decades. The workshop presented a rare opportunity to reflect critically on these issues at a pivotal moment in human and technological history, and to elicit underappreciated dimensions. Areas of focus include: the qualitative and quantitative losses associated with automation and AI, the impacts automation has for questions about the meaningfulness of work, the challenges we face related to uncertainty and lack of predictability in technological advancement, and the opportunities that exist for centering human values and agency in these conversations. While acknowledging many items for concern in the context of automation in the future of work, such as the domination of economic narratives, a potential loss of qualitative texture, and the neglect of certain issues key to human identity, the authors conclude by offering optimistic visions—or calls—for redefining value and labor, preserving human agency, and embracing creative problem-solving.
1 January 2009 in International Journal of Web Portals
The Internet promised a lot for enterprises from 1995. The Internet’s ubiquity offered inter-company connectivity (previously provided to corporations by Electronic Data Interchange) for businesses of every size. The business-to-business (B2B) trading exchange concept emerged, 10,000 B2B exchanges were anticipated. Early Internet investment then struck an unexpected hurdle: the Internet didn’t inherently support many of the key requirements for business transactions (such as reliability, confidentiality, integrity, authentication of parties). These requirements added to the cost and complexity of Internet investment. The dot.com stock market crash affected all Internet-related initiatives. But while the B2B exchanges disappeared, other initiatives more aligned to user needs and the Internet’s architecture continued to grow. These included the enterprise portal, which supports the traditional single-business-centred customer relationship model, in contrast to the business disruptive B2B exchange model.
26 April 2022 in Law in Context. A Socio-legal Journal
Artificial intelligence is an alluring technology which companies and governments hope to benefit from. In many circumstances a condition of its use is that humans can understand an explanation of why the action of an AI system took place. This has encouraged the development of a field of “explainable artificial intelligence”, or XAI. Much of the work in this field has been encouraged by the US Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency (DARPA), through its XAI program initiated in 2016. This paper argues that an underacknowledged challenge of XAI is that unlike most traditional technology, many AI systems contain inherent uncertainty. These systems are widely described as “black boxes”, and can be described only through their behavior, a technique described in the literature as post-hoc, rather than through an understanding of their functioning. Explaining such systems is akin to explaining the functioning of the natural world, rather than explaining the functioning of a known technology. While extensive work has been undertaken to explain the behavior of black box AI systems, there are limitations to the certainty that a post-hoc method can bring. Recognizing this is an important part of understanding the limitations of post-hoc reasoning in the use of advanced AI systems. Far simpler technologies have been seen to cause significant social damage: the UK Post Office Horizon system, and the Australian federal government Robodebt program. Coming to advanced AI system examples, two recent prestigious reports on AI systems and law display an unreasoned enthusiasm for AI explainability. AI researchers should be acknowledging that many advanced AI systems remain black boxes, that post-hoc explanations of these are inferences describing how the AI system may function, not how it does function, and the application of these technologies should be managed accordingly. Otherwise, the search for explanations may simply become a reason to believe.