10 January 2022 in Computers & Operations Research
1 January 2023 in SSRN Electronic Journal
Fairness is a key concern in humanitarian logistics (HL), naturally arising in almost all applications as scarce resources are allocated to multiple entities under various constraints. Yet, addressing it within mathematical modelling and optimization frameworks requires quantifying these equity concerns, which is challenging, as the method to do so depends on the policy maker preferences as well as the dynamics of the specific problem addressed. This leads to a vast amount of different approaches being used to consider equity in humanitarian decision making. In this paper, we provide a critical review of the studies in the HL domain that embody fairness. We provide a structured categorization of the existing works as well as a generic modelling framework to make allocation, routing and inventory decisions in a multi-period environment. The framework encapsulates the common aspects of the models used in the reviewed works in the sense that it reduces to them under specific conditions. We demonstrate that even when a simple variant of the model is solved with different equity functions, the resulting allocations are strikingly different, indicating that the policy makers should be aware of the effect of the function choice on the results. We then discuss different ways of considering equity in these models as well as alternative approaches that could be used but have not been explored yet.