Joel L. Pick

Joel L. Pick

Auto-generated profile, based on publicly available information

Joel L. Pick

University of Edinburgh

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

12Years (2015-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
1 November 2018 in Methods in Ecology and Evolution
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
JPJoel L. Pick
Joel L. Pick
SNShinichi Nakagawa
Shinichi Nakagawa
DNDaniel W. A. Noble
Daniel W. A. Noble
Research synthesis, such as comparative and meta‐analyses, requires the extraction of effect sizes from primary literature, which are commonly calculated from descriptive statistics. However, the exact values of such statistics are commonly hidden in figures. Extracting descriptive statistics from figures can be a slow process that is not easily reproducible. Additionally, current software lacks an ability to incorporate important metadata (e.g. sample sizes, treatment/variable names) about experiments and is not integrated with other software to streamline analysis pipelines. Here we present the r package metaDigitise which extracts descriptive statistics such as means, standard deviations and correlations from four plot types: (a) mean/error plots (e.g. bar graphs with standard errors), (b) box plots, (c) scatter plots and (d) histograms. metaDigitise is user‐friendly and easy to learn as it interactively guides the user through the data extraction process. Notably, it enables large‐scale extraction by automatically loading image files, letting the user stop processing, edit and add to the resulting data‐frame at any point. Digitised data can be easily re‐plotted and checked, facilitating reproducible data extraction from plots with little inter‐observer bias. We hope that by making the process of figure extraction more flexible and easy to conduct, it will improve the transparency and quality of meta‐analyses in the future.

3 April 2023 in Nature Communications
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
SNShinichi Nakagawa
Shinichi Nakagawa
EIEdward R. Ivimey-Cook
Edward R. Ivimey-Cook
MGMatthew J. Grainger
Matthew J. Grainger
RORose E. O’dea
Rose E. O’dea
SBSamantha Burke
Samantha Burke
MLMalgorzata Lagisz
Malgorzata Lagisz
Contributor Roles Taxonomy (CRediT) has recently changed how author contributions are acknowledged. To extend and complement CRediT, we propose MeRIT, a new way of writing the Methods section using the author’s initials to further clarify contributor roles for reproducibility and replicability. Lack of information on authors’ contribution to specific aspects of a study hampers reproducibility and replicability. Here, the authors propose a new, easily implemented reporting system to clarify contributor roles in the Methods section of an article.

1 December 2016 in The American Naturalist
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
JPJoel L. Pick
Joel L. Pick
CEChristina Ebneter
Christina Ebneter
PHPascale Hutter
Pascale Hutter
BTBarbara Tschirren
Barbara Tschirren
Organizational processes during prenatal development can have long-term effects on an individual’s phenotype. Because these early developmental stages are sensitive to environmental influences, mothers are in a unique position to alter their offspring’s phenotype by differentially allocating resources to their developing young. However, such prenatal maternal effects are difficult to disentangle from other forms of parental care, additive genetic effects, and/or other forms of maternal inheritance, hampering our understanding of their evolutionary consequences. Here we used divergent selection lines for high and low prenatal maternal investment and their reciprocal line crosses in a precocial bird—the Japanese quail (Coturnix japonica)—to quantify the relative importance of genes and prenatal maternal effects in shaping offspring phenotype. Maternal but not paternal origin strongly affected offspring body size and survival throughout development. Although the effects of maternal egg investment faded over time, they were large at key life stages. Additionally, there was evidence for other forms of maternal inheritance affecting offspring phenotype at later stages of development. Our study is among the first to successfully disentangle prenatal maternal effects from all other sources of confounding variation and highlights the important role of prenatal maternal provisioning in shaping offspring traits closely linked to fitness.

7 September 2023 in Methods in Ecology and Evolution
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
JPJoel L. Pick
Joel L. Pick
CKClaudia Kasper
Claudia Kasper
HAHassen Allegue
Hassen Allegue
NDNiels J. Dingemanse
Niels J. Dingemanse
NDNed A. Dochtermann
Ned A. Dochtermann
YAYimen G. Araya‐Ajoy
Yimen G. Araya‐Ajoy
Assessing the biological relevance of variance components estimated using Markov chain Monte Carlo (MCMC)‐based mixed‐effects models is not straightforward. Variance estimates are constrained to be greater than zero and their posterior distributions are often asymmetric. Different measures of central tendency for these distributions can therefore vary widely, and credible intervals cannot overlap zero, making it difficult to assess the size and statistical support for among‐group variance. Statistical support is often assessed through visual inspection of the whole posterior distribution and so relies on subjective decisions for interpretation. We use simulations to demonstrate the difficulties of summarizing the posterior distributions of variance estimates from MCMC‐based models. We then describe different methods for generating the expected null distribution (i.e. a distribution of effect sizes that would be obtained if there was no among‐group variance) that can be used to aid in the interpretation of variance estimates. Through comparing commonly used summary statistics of posterior distributions of variance components, we show that the posterior median is predominantly the least biased. We further show how null distributions can be used to derive ap‐value that provides complementary information to the commonly presented measures of central tendency and uncertainty. Finally, we show how thesep‐values facilitate the implementation of power analyses within an MCMC framework. The use of null distributions for variance components can aid study design and the interpretation of results from MCMC‐based models. We hope that this manuscript will make empiricists using mixed models think more carefully about their results, what descriptive statistics they present and what inference they can make.

1 October 2023 in Journal of Evolutionary Biology
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
EIEdward R. Ivimey-Cook
Edward R. Ivimey-Cook
JPJoel L. Pick
Joel L. Pick
KBKevin R. Bairos-Novak
Kevin R. Bairos-Novak
ACAntica Culina
Antica Culina
EGElliot Gould
Elliot Gould
SWSaras M. Windecker
Saras M. Windecker
Code review increases reliability and improves reproducibility of research. As such, code review is an inevitable step in software development and is common in fields such as computer science. However, despite its importance, code review is noticeably lacking in ecology and evolutionary biology. This is problematic as it facilitates the propagation of coding errors and a reduction in reproducibility and reliability of published results. To address this, we provide a detailed commentary on how to effectively review code, how to set up your project to enable this form of review and detail its possible implementation at several stages throughout the research process. This guide serves as a primer for code review, and adoption of the principles and advice here will go a long way in promoting more open, reliable, and transparent ecology and evolutionary biology. Abstract Code review is the process of either informally (as part of a group, as colleagues) or formally (as part of the peer review process) checking and evaluating each other's code and is a critical method of reducing errors and increasing research reproducibility and reliability. In this paper, we provide a detailed commentary on how to effectively review code (including introducing the four Rs), how to set up your project to enable this form of review and detail its possibleimplementation at several stages throughout the research process.

9 November 2017 in BMC Biology
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
SNShinichi Nakagawa
Shinichi Nakagawa
FKFonti Kar
Fonti Kar
RORose E. O’dEa
Rose E. O’dEa
JPJoel L. Pick
Joel L. Pick
MLMalgorzata Lagisz
Malgorzata Lagisz
Many trait measurements are size-dependent, and while we often divide these traits by size before fitting statistical models to control for the effect of size, this approach does not account for allometry and the intermediate outcome problem. We describe these problems and outline potential solutions.