Software protection researchers often struggle with the evaluation of MATE software protections and attacks. Evaluations often are incomplete and not representative of the practice. This can in part be explained by a lack of standardized, generally applicable models, tools, and methodologies for evaluating how reverse engineering attack strategies are executed. The framework of related components proposed in this paper is an attempt to provide exactly that. It includes a meta-model and supporting tools for modeling the knowledge that reverse engineers acquire as they execute their strategies, a meta-model to estimate the required effort of those strategies, and tools to capture strategic activities from data streams collected during human reverse engineering experiments. Their use is demonstrated on three example reverse engineering strategies.
We identified several weaknesses in the state-of-the-art cryptographic key extraction algorithm, K-Hunt. It cannot handle code in which key loading and use are spread apart, has problems with modes such as AES CBC that use small data buffers of constant size, and with complex apps in which functionality handles both the key and data. K-Hunt++ overcomes those weaknesses. We demonstrate it on two apps that trigger them and present an ablation study and qualitative analysis of its robustness in the face of obfuscation.