17 February 2025 in Digital Experiences in Mathematics Education
This study presents a scoping survey examining the integration of ChatGPT in mathematics education, highlighting its benefits, challenges, and implications for teaching and learning. The survey identifies key themes, including ChatGPT’s ability to assist in understanding mathematical concepts, lesson planning, assessment design, personalized learning, and fostering collaboration. While the tool demonstrates potential in enhancing self-regulated learning, providing real-time feedback, and supporting critical thinking, challenges such as its occasional inaccuracies, ethical concerns, and the risk of over-reliance on AI are also noted. The review emphasizes the importance of human oversight and ethical considerations in leveraging ChatGPT for inclusive and dynamic mathematics education. It concludes that, with thoughtful integration, ChatGPT can serve as a transformative resource, fostering both individualized and collaborative learning experiences while reshaping the learner–tool relationship in educational contexts.
29 May 2018 in ZDM – Mathematics Education
Contrary to the opinion that formative and summative assessment approaches are not compatible, this article presents a theoretically grounded way in which different forms of assessment can be combined and integrated in university mathematics teacher education. Two mixed-assessment approaches are demonstrated through the analysis of a case study involving a practice-based seminar accompanying a school internship. First, a formative eportfolio assessment was combined with a summative panel survey to assess the learning opportunities of mathematics pre-service teachers. Second, the formative eportfolio approach was integrated with a summative oral course examination to make statements about the learning processes and learning outcomes of the pre-service teachers. Our analyses conclude that combining and integrating the two forms of assessment present the possibility of evaluating different aspects of the pre-service teachers’ perceptions of opportunities to learn. Benefits, validation aspects and limitations of the two approaches of combining and integrating assessment forms are discussed.
9 May 2024 in Frontiers in Education
The use of and research on the large language model (LLM) Generative Pretrained Transformer (GPT) is growing steadily, especially in mathematics education. As students and teachers worldwide increasingly use this AI model for teaching and learning mathematics, the question of the quality of the generated output becomes important. Consequently, this study evaluates AI-supported mathematical problem solving with different GPT versions when the LLM is subjected to prompt techniques. To assess the mathematics educational quality (content related and process related) of the LLM’s output, we facilitated four prompt techniques and investigated their effects in model validations (N = 1,080) using three mathematical problem-based tasks. Subsequently, human raters scored the mathematics educational quality of AI output. The results showed that the content-related quality of AI-supported problem solving was not significantly affected by using various prompt techniques across GPT versions. However, certain prompt techniques, particular Chain-of-Thought and Ask-me-Anything, notably improved process-related quality.
23 June 2018 in ZDM – Mathematics Education
In educational contexts, assessments may be designed to target students, preservice teachers, or teachers, either as individuals or as representatives of a group, and for a multitude of purposes. One key aim of assessment in mathematics education is to provide evidence that can be used to make decisions about or improve mathematics education, which then raises questions about which aspects of mathematical competence should be assessed—as well as how and for what purpose. This review paper addresses three related themes: (1) issues related to the assessment process and to the development of assessments that can validly assess mathematical competence in all its complexity; (2) issues related to educational policy and policy-making based on assessment data, in particular the reciprocal relationship between assessment and policy; and (3) issues related to equity, such as gender issues or the achievement gap between majority and minority students. Awareness of the relation between assessment, teaching, and learning is shown throughout the paper. Strong relationships between the three focus areas are found, that impact assessment validity and call for further development of assessment practices in mathematics education.
10 July 2017 in Zeitschrift für Erziehungswissenschaft
Pädagogisches und fachdidaktisches Wissen gelten als zentrale kognitive Elemente professioneller Kompetenz von Lehrkräften. Der Erwerb entsprechenden Wissens soll daher möglichst schon im Lehramtsstudium erfolgen. Wie allerdings pädagogisches Wissen und fachdidaktisches Wissen zueinander in Verbindung stehen bzw. voneinander abgegrenzt werden können, ist konzeptionell wie empirisch noch weitgehend ungeklärt. Vor diesem Hintergrund bearbeitet der vorliegende Beitrag mithilfe standardisierter Wissenstests und auf der Basis von 889 Lehramtsstudierenden der Fächer Deutsch, Englisch und Mathematik von zwei Volluniversitäten die beiden folgenden Fragen: (1) Lässt sich pädagogisches Wissen von Studierenden empirisch von ihrem deutsch-, englisch- und mathematikdidaktischen Wissen trennen? (2) Bestehen Unterschiede im fachdidaktischen Wissen in Abhängigkeit von ihrem Ausbildungsstadium (Bachelor vs. Master) und können diese zusätzlich durch spezifische Lerngelegenheiten in der Fachdidaktik erklärt werden (im Gegensatz zum pädagogischen Wissen)? Die Ergebnisse zeigen zum einen, dass sich pädagogisches Wissen und fachdidaktisches Wissen wie erwartet empirisch trennen lassen. Dies gilt für jede der drei Domänen (Konstruktvalidität), wobei pädagogisches Wissen mit mathematikdidaktischem niedriger korreliert als mit deutsch- bzw. englischdidaktischem Wissen (bei Kontrolle von Hintergrund- und Eingangsmerkmalen der Studierenden und Merkmalen ihrer Lerngelegenheiten). Zum anderen indizieren Kohorten-Vergleiche von Bachelor- und Master-Studierenden ein besseres Abschneiden letzterer in allen Domänen für das fachdidaktische und pädagogische Wissen (curriculare Validität). Deutschdidaktisches und englischdidaktisches Wissen lassen sich darüber hinaus stärker als mathematikdidaktisches Wissen durch fachdidaktische Lerngelegenheiten erklären (konvergente Validität) und vom pädagogischen Wissen abgrenzen (diskriminante Validität). Implikationen für aktuell stattfindende Maßnahmen der Qualitätssicherung in der universitären Lehrerbildung werden diskutiert. General pedagogical knowledge (GPK) and pedagogical content knowledge (PCK) are central cognitive elements in the professional competence of teachers. Thus initial teacher education aims at the acquisition of this relevant knowledge. However, the question how GPK and PCK are related to each other or can be separated from each other has not yet been answered, neither conceptually nor empirically. Against this background, this article focuses on two research questions on the basis of standardized knowledge tests administered to 889 pre-service teachers of German, English and Mathematics from two large universities: (1) Can GPK empirically be separated from PCK of German, English, and Mathematics? (2) Are there differences in pre-service teachers’ PCK test scores depending on their stage of training (Bachelor versus Master) and can PCK test scores additionally be explained by specific learning opportunities in the area of PCK (when compared with GPK test scores)? On the one hand, findings show that GPK and PCK can empirically be separated. This is true for all three domains (construct validity), whereby the correlation between GPK and Mathematics PCK is lower than the correlations between GPK and German PCK and English PCK (when controlled for background and entry characteristics of students and their learning opportunities). On the other hand, a comparison between cohorts of Bachelor and Master student teachers provides evidence that the more advanced Master students outperform the Bachelor students in all knowledge tests (curricular validity). In addition, German PCK and English PCK (better than Mathematics PCK) can be explained by subject-specific learning opportunities (convergent validity) and be demarcated from GPK (discriminant validity). Implications for current initiatives of quality assurance in initial teacher education are discussed.
4 October 2012 in ZDM – Mathematics Education