1 January 2022 in STEM Education
Traditional lectures are commonly understood to be a teacher-centered mode of instruction where the main aim is a provision of explanations by an educator to the students. Recent literature in higher education overwhelmingly depicts this mode of instruction as inferior compared to the desired student-centered models based on active learning techniques. First, using a four-quadrant model of educational environments, we address common confusion related to a conflation of two prevalent dichotomies by focusing on two key dimensions: (1) the extent to which students are prompted to engage actively and (2) the extent to which expert explanations are provided. Second, using a case study, we describe an evolution of tertiary mathematics education, showing how traditional instruction can still play a valuable role, provided it is suitably embedded in a student-centered course design. We support our argument by analyzing the teaching practice and learning environment in a third-year abstract algebra course through the lens of Stanislas Dehaene's theoretical framework for effective teaching and learning. The framework, comprising 'four pillars of learning', is based on a state-of-the-art conception of how learning can be facilitated according to cognitive science, educational psychology and neuroscience findings. In the case study, we illustrate how, over time, the unit design and the teaching approach have evolved into a learning environment that aligns with the four pillars of learning. We conclude that traditional lectures can and do evolve to optimize learning environments and that the erection of the dichotomy 'traditional instruction versus active learning' is no longer relevant.
1 March 2023 in Educational Studies in Mathematics
A concept map is a visualisation of a group of related concepts with their relationships identified by directed arrows, which can be viewed as an externalisation of a schema encoded in a learner’s long-term memory. Concept maps have become popular learning tools in various educational settings. However, the existing research has not fully explored the effectiveness of concept mapping as a learning tool nor analysed its utility as an assessment tool in mathematics. This study reports on the implementation and evaluation of a novel assessment, concept mapping, in a university mathematics course (N = 219). We investigated relationships between concept mapping performance and two major outcome variables: academic achievement and assessment self-efficacy (a two-factor measure comprising Comprehension and Execution and Emotional Regulation). Hierarchical multiple regression showed that concept mapping performance explains a statistically significant amount of variance in both the final exam scores and the Emotional Regulation factor of assessment self-efficacy after accounting for other conventional coursework assessments. The explained variance in the final exam suggests that concept mapping used as an assessment tool can detect and evaluate learners’ distinct capabilities that are not discerned by conventional assessments. Hence, concept mapping’s potential to assess conceptual understanding warrants further investigations. Moreover, the association with the emotional regulation efficacy measure suggests that concept mapping as a learning activity involves more positivity about the ability to succeed in facing challenges than a typical assignment. This potentially indicates more perseverance and effortful learning while actively engaged in meaning-making and the type of relational reasoning elicited by concept mapping.
10 July 2021 in Australasian Journal of Educational Technology
The rapid inclusion of online assessment in higher education has left a void in investigating the relationship this form of assessment has with student emotions. This study examines the influence of frequent online assessment on student emotions in a university setting using a mixed-methods approach. Students' emotions in an online quiz and a traditional classroom test in a second-year mathematics course (n = 91) were analysed using both quantitative and qualitative approaches, through the lens of the control-value theory. The study used an adaptation of the Achievement Emotions Questionnaire (AEQ) to collect data on reported student emotions in both assessments, as well as qualitative data on student’s views of the frequent online assessment. Students reported higher levels of positive emotions and lower levels of negative emotions in an online quiz compared to the test, and we attempted to identify sources of these differences. The findings are discussed together with implications for habitualisation of assessment emotions. Practically grounded generalisations are outlined as opportunities for disrupting negative emotions and reaffirming positive emotions, which are suitable for implementation in higher education on a broad scale. Implications for practice or policy: For educators designing tertiary assessment aimed at promoting positive and reducing negative emotions, we advise incorporating features that students perceive as allowing them greater control over obtaining success. Specifically, we advise incorporating frequent low stakes online quizzes into tertiary courses. These present opportunities for students to habitualise positive assessment-related emotions, which correlate with performance and constructs such as self-efficacy. The Achievement Emotions Questionnaires (AEQ) can be adapted to investigate achievement emotions in different forms of assessment.
1 August 2006 in Topology and its Applications
29 September 2020 in Higher Education Research & Development
This study involved an intervention designed to examine whether employability prospects for STEM students studying mathematics could be improved. It incorporated use of non-routine problem solving in second-year mathematics courses at two New Zealand universities. From a theoretical standpoint, we conceptualised a novel construct called lateral thinking self-efficacy, which is defined as a learner’s confidence in their ability to solve non-routine problems. It relates to the creative thinking ability needed for solving innovative real-life problems in the work place, and hence is pertinent in transfer of mathematical learning to novel domains. The findings suggest that the attitude profiles of students with high and low lateral thinking self-efficacy differ significantly with respect to three dimensions spanning their affective domain. Further, a significant difference between genders with regard to lateral thinking self-efficacy was observed, with a significantly greater proportion of confident males than females, although there was no significant association between gender and non-routine problem-solving performance. These results raise questions about equity with regard to employability prospects for females in STEM companies and have implications for the underrepresentation of women in STEM fields.
15 February 2021 in Mathematics Education Research Journal