Surgical intervention induces profound and dynamic alterations in the body’s immune reactivity. The postoperative period is typically characterized by an early hyperinflammatory response, followed by compensatory immunosuppression; however, in some cases, a maladaptive condition known as persistent inflammation, immunosuppression, and catabolism syndrome may develop. These immune disturbances are associated with an increased risk of infectious complications, impaired tissue repair, organ dysfunction, and potential tumor progression. Modulation of surgery-induced changes in immune responsiveness may represent a promising strategy for improving surgical outcomes. The aim of this review is to analyze and synthesize current literature on the mechanisms and key determinants of postoperative immunomodulation. The review discusses the complex mechanisms underlying the initiation and progression of postoperative systemic hyperinflammation, as well as the triggers and pathways involved in compensatory anti-inflammatory response syndrome. Particular attention is given to the temporal dynamics and phase-dependent nature of postoperative immunomodulation. Key determinants shaping the intensity and trajectory of post-surgical immune responses are examined, including surgical factors such as the extent and duration of tissue injury, as well as anesthetic techniques and agents. In addition, patient-specific factors influencing postoperative immune modulation, such as age, sex, and preoperative immune status, are analyzed in detail. Overall, the early postoperative period represents an underutilized window of therapeutic opportunity for improving surgical outcomes. However, its effective clinical exploitation requires a deeper understanding of the mechanisms underlying post-surgical immunomodulation, as well as the development and implementation of highly sensitive, dynamic biomarkers for continuous, real-time monitoring. Such advances would enable truly personalized, phase-adapted therapeutic strategies tailored to the patient’s evolving immune state.