SUMMARY: Krafla is an active volcanic field and a high-temperature geothermal system in northeast Iceland. As part of a program to produce more energy from higher temperature wells, the IDDP-1 well was drilled in 2009 to reach supercritical fluid conditions below the Krafla geothermal field. However, drilling ended prematurely when the well unexpectedly encountered rhyolite magma at a depth of 2.1 km. In this paper we re-examine the magnetotelluric (MT) data that were used to model the electrical resistivity structure at Krafla. We present a new 3-D resistivity model that differs from previous inversions due to (1) using the full impedance tensor data and (2) a finely discretized mesh with horizontal cell dimensions of 100 m by 100 m. We obtained similar resistivity models from using two different prior models: a uniform half-space, and a previously published 1-D resistivity model. Our model contains a near-surface resistive layer of unaltered basalt and a low resistivity layer of hydrothermal alteration (C1). A resistive region (R1) at 1 to 2 km depth corresponds to chlorite-epidote alteration minerals that are stable at temperatures of about 220 to 500 °C. A low resistivity feature (C2) coincides with the Hveragil fault system, a zone of increased permeability allowing interaction of aquifer fluids with magmatic fluids and gases. Our model contains a large, low resistivity zone (C3) below the northern half of the Krafla volcanic field that domes upward to a depth of about 1.6 km b.s.l. C3 is partially coincident with reported low S-wave velocity zones which could be due to partial melt or aqueous fluids. The low resistivity could also be attributed to dehydration and decomposition of chlorite and epidote that occurs above 500 °C. As opposed to previously published resistivity models, our resistivity model shows that IDDP-1 encountered rhyolite magma near the upper edge of C3, where it intersects C2. In order to assess the sensitivity of the MT data to melt at the bottom of IDDP-1, we added hypothetical magma bodies with resistivities of 0.1 to 30 Ωm to our resistivity model and compared the synthetic MT data to the original inversion response. We used two methods to compare the MT data fit: (1) the change in r.m.s. misfit and (2) an asymptotic p-value obtained from the Kolmogorov–Smirnov (K–S) statistical test on the two sets of data residuals. We determined that the MT data can only detect sills that are unrealistically large (2.25 km3) with very low resistivities (0.1 or 0.3 Ωm). Smaller magma bodies (0.125 and 1 km3) were not detected; thus the MT data are not sensitive to small rhyolite magma bodies near the bottom of IDDP-1. Our tests gave similar results when evaluating the changes in r.m.s. misfit and the K–S test p-values, but the K–S test is a more objective method than appraising a relative change in r.m.s. misfit. Our resistivity model and resolution tests are consistent with the idea of rhyolite melt forming by re-melting of hydrothermally altered basalt on the edges of a deeper magma body.
22 August 2021 in Journal of Geophysical Research: Solid Earth
Electrical anisotropy is increasingly recognized as an important aspect of the resistivity models required to explain magnetotelluric (MT) observations. However, a limited number of practical MT inversion algorithms that can consider anisotropy have been published to date. To address this problem, we have developed a three‐dimensional (3‐D) MT inversion algorithm that recovers a 3‐D resistivity model that considers arbitrary electrical anisotropy. The inversion uses the same inversion algorithm as the widely used ModEM inversion algorithm, and a novel forward modeling algorithm to consider the anisotropic Earth. The algorithm was tested on both synthetic and field MT data. Inversions considered both a completely general anisotropy tensor with six components and approximations with less parameters. Synthetic inversions show that the two horizontal components of resistivity and the anisotropy strike can be well recovered, while the vertical component of resistivity is poorly resolved, primarily because current flow in MTs is dominantly horizontal. The synthetic examples confirm the limitation of the axial anisotropic inversion technique when applied to MT data produced by a resistivity model with arbitrary anisotropy. The synthetic inversions also showed that inversion of data from an isotropic model will not result in an artificially anisotropic model. Compared to the isotropic inversion model of the real MT data, the anisotropic model clearly shows some features that are consistent with the mapped geology. As expected, the results showed that a given data set can be fit by a range of models, with an inherent trade‐off from 3‐D heterogeneity to 3‐D anisotropy. This uncertainty can be reduced with the use of prior information in the inversion.
Estimating the effect of geomagnetic disturbances on power grid infrastructure is an important problem since they can induce damaging currents in electric power transmission lines. In this study, an array of magnetotelluric (MT) impedance measurements in Alberta and southeastern British Columbia are used to estimate the geoelectric field resulting from a magnetic storm on September 8, 2017. The resulting geoelectric field is compared to the geoelectric field modeled using the more common method that uses a piecewise‐continuous 1‐D conductivity model. The 1‐D model assumes horizontal layers, which result in orthogonal induced electric fields while the measured MT impedance data can account for fully 3‐D conductivity structure. The geoelectric field derived from measured MT impedance data is partially polarized in southern Alberta, and the geoelectric field magnitude is largest in northeastern Alberta where the resistive Canadian Shield outcrops. The induced voltage in the Alberta transmission network is estimated to be ∼120 V larger in northeastern Alberta when using the measured MT impedances compared to the piecewise‐continuous 1‐D model. Estimated voltages on transmission lines oriented NW‐SE in southern Alberta are 10%–20% larger when using the MT impedances due to the polarized geoelectric field. As shown with forward modeling tests, the polarization is due to a feature in the lower crust (20–30 km depth) called the Southern Alberta British Columbia conductor that is associated with a Proterozoic tectonic suture zone. This forms an important link between ancient tectonic processes and modern‐day geoelectric hazards that cannot be modeled with a 1‐D analysis.
We have evaluated results from a study combining airborne z-axis tipper electromagnetic (ZTEM) and ground-based magnetotelluric (MT) data to image an epithermal system in British Columbia. The spatially coincident use of these two methods allowed for a direct comparison of both data sets in the overlapping frequency band and showed that both measurements were consistent. Inversion of just the ZTEM data suffered from the lack of electric field amplitude information, which could be provided by the MT data. Three-dimensional inversion modeling of the two individual data sets was performed. Models of electrical resistivity derived from both data sets were consistent and could be correlated with the geological and structural setting of the mineralization. Gold is associated with disseminated pyrite and marcasite in quartz-sericite-altered felsic volcanic rocks and intrusions, especially near the contact with mafic volcanic rocks and a late diorite intrusion. The quartz-sericite alteration yields a conductivity anomaly, relative to the more resistive mafic country rocks. Although ZTEM and MT do not possess the resolution of the geologic model derived from borehole data, our model agrees well with a regional assessment of the deposit.
16 November 2020 in Journal of Geophysical Research: Solid Earth
Imaging silicic systems using geophysics is challenging because many interrelated factors (e.g., temperature, melt fraction, melt composition, geometry) can contribute to the measured geophysical anomaly. Joint interpretation of models from multiple geophysical methods can better constrain interpretations of the subsurface structure. Previously published resistivity and shear wave velocity (Vs) models, derived separately from magnetotelluric (MT) and surface wave seismic data, respectively, have been used to model the restless Laguna del Maule Volcanic Field, central Chile. The Vs model contains a 450 km3 low‐velocity zone (LVZ) interpreted as a region with an average melt fraction of 5–6%. The resistivity model contains a conductor (C3) interpreted as a region with a melt fraction >35%. The spatial extents of the LVZ and C3 overlap, but the geometries and interpretations of these features are different. To resolve these discrepancies, this study investigates the resolution of the MT data using hypothesis testing and constrained MT inversions. It is shown that the MT data are best fit with discrete conductors embedded within the larger LVZ. The differences between the MT and seismic models reflect resolution differences between the two data sets as well as varying sensitivities to physical properties. The MT data are sensitive to smaller volumes of extractable mush that contain well‐connected crystal‐poor melt (C3). The seismic data have lower spatial resolution but image the full extent of the poorly connected crystal‐rich magma storage system. The combined images suggest that the LdMVF magma plumbing system is thermally heterogeneous with coexisting zones of warm and cold storage.