31 October 2023 in International Journal of Mental Health Nursing
Coercion in mental healthcare is ubiquitous and affects the physical health, recovery and psychological and emotional well‐being of those who experience it. Numerous studies have explored different issues related to coercion, and the present umbrella review aims to gather, evaluate and synthesise the evidence found across systematic reviews. The protocol, registered in the International Prospective Register of Systematic Reviews (PROSPERO registration number: CRD42020196713), included 46 systematic reviews and meta‐analyses of primary studies whose main theme was coercion and which were obtained from databases (Medline/PubMed, PsycINFO, EMBASE and CINAHL) and repositories of systematic reviews following the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic reviews and Meta‐Analyses guidelines. All the reviews were subjected to independent assessment of quality and risk of bias and were grouped in two categories: (1) evidence on specific coercive measures (including Community Treatment Orders, forced treatment, involuntary admissions, seclusion and restriction and informal coercion), taking into account their prevalence, related factors, effectiveness, harmful effects and alternatives to reduce their use; and (2) experiences, perceptions and attitudes concerning coercion of professionals, mental health service users and their caregivers or relatives. This umbrella review can be useful to professionals and users in addressing the wide variety of aspects encompassed by coercion and the implications for professionals' daily clinical practice in mental health units. This research received funding from two competitive calls.
27 March 2023 in Journal of Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing
Accessible Summary: What is known on the subject?: Coercive measures represent an ethical conflict because they limit the person's freedom, compromising their personal autonomy, self‐determination and fundamental rights. The reduction of the use of coercive measures implies not only regulations and mental health systems, but also cultural aspects, such as societal beliefs, attitudes, and values. There is evidence about the professionals' views on coercion in acute mental health care units and community settings, but they remain unexplored in inpatient rehabilitation units. What the paper adds to existing knowledge?: The knowledge about coercion varied from not knowing at all the meaning of the word, to a proper description of the phenomenon. Coercive measures are considered a necessary evil or normalized in mental health care and considered implicit to daily practice. What are the implications for practice?: The perceptions and attitudes towards coercion might be influenced by the knowledge about the phenomenon. Training of mental health nursing staff in non‐coercive practice could help professionals to detect, be conscious towards, and question coercive measures, thus orienting them to the effective implementation of interventions or programmes with evidenced effectiveness to reduce them. Introduction: Creating a therapeutic and safe milieu with the minimum coercive measures requires knowing professionals' perceptions and attitudes towards coercion, but they remain unexplored in medium and long‐stay inpatient psychiatric rehabilitation units.Aim: To explore the knowledge, perception and experience of coercion among nursing staff at a rehabilitation medium‐stay mental health unit (MSMHU) in Eastern Spain.Method: Qualitative phenomenological study including 28 face‐to‐face, semi‐structured interviews based on a script. Data were analysed using content analysis.Results: Two main themes were found: (1) therapeutic relationship and treatment in the MSMHU, which included three subthemes: qualities of the professionals for building the therapeutic relationship; perceptions about the persons admitted to the MSMHU; views of the therapeutic relationship and treatment in the MSMHU; (2) Coercion at the MSMHU, comprising five subthemes: professional knowledge; general aspects; emotional impact of coercion; opinions; alternatives.Discussion: Coercive measures are often normalized in mental health care and considered implicit to daily practice. A proportion of participants who did not know what coercion is.Implications for Practice: Knowledge about coercion might influence attitudes towards coercion. Mental health nursing staff could benefit from formal training in non‐coercive practice, facilitating the operative implementation of effective interventions or programmes.
27 October 2024 in Journal of Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing
Introduction: Coercion influences mental health services users' experience of care and can hinder their recovery process, so it is essential to understand how it is perceived in rehabilitation settings oriented towards recovery.Aim: To describe and measure users' experience of coercion and explore their perception of the treatment received in an inpatient medium‐stay psychiatric rehabilitation unit (IMSPRU).Method: This study, in which 75 service users participated, used a mixed methods approach. Twenty participants were administered a semistructured interview and completed quantitative measures for coercion and 55 additional service users completed the quantitative measurements only. The perception of coercion was measured using the Coercion Experience Scale.Results: The content analysis of qualitative data resulted in two main themes: treatment received and experience of coercion in the IMSPRU. The participants made a distinction between good treatment and mistreatment or unfair treatment. Experience of coercion in the IMSPRU included the feeling of freedom or lack thereof in the unit, forms of formal and informal coercion, and the positive or negative impact of rules on the unit. The quantitative data revealed a low perception of formal coercion among the users.Discussion: Individuals had different views of what it meant to be treated well, but all agreed on the importance of communication and the need to feel respected. Informal coercion was the most frequent type of coercion identified, but users were often unaware of its existence.Implications for Practice: Knowledge of how IMSPRU users experience the treatment received from nursing staff and how they perceive coercive situations will help to lay the foundations of a system of care oriented towards good treatment and noncoercive practices.
30 September 2021 in Revista Española de Enfermería de Salud Mental
Resumen Objetivo: El objetivo principal de esta revisión fue examinar la evidencia científica publicada hasta la fecha sobre la implementación de salas sensoriales/confort en unidades psiquiátricas. Método: Se realizó una revisión bibliográfica en las bases de datos PubMed, CINAHL, CUIDEN, Scopus y EMBASE empleando la siguiente estrategia de búsqueda: (relaxation room OR sensory room OR comfort room) AND (mental healthORmental illnessORpsychiatr*). Finalmente, se incluyeron un total de 15 artículos. Resultados: Los principales objetivos de las salas sensoriales son proporcionar un ambiente terapéutico de apoyo, mejorar la calidad de la experiencia dentro del ambiente de la sala y apoyar a las personas a la regulación emocional durante períodos de angustia y crisis. Algunos de los aspectos positivos del uso de estas salas son el aumento del bienestar general de los usuarios/as y la reducción de las medidas coercitivas ante un episodio de agitación. Conclusiones: Aunque el uso de las salas sensoriales en psiquiatría es algo novedoso y necesita más investigación sobre su efectividad, la escasa literatura muestra que las “salas de confort” son una herramienta eficaz para fomentar la independencia de la granmayoría de los usuarios/as en su regulación emocional. Palabras clave: confort, relajación, sala sensorial y salud mental. Abstract Objective: The main objective of this review was to examine the scientific evidence published to date on the implementation of sensory/comfort rooms in psychiatric units. Method: A bibliographic review was carried out in the Pubmed, CINAHL, CUIDEN, Scopus and EMBASE databases using the following search strategy: (relaxation room OR sensory room OR comfort room) AND (mental health OR mental illnessORpsychiatrist *). Finally, a total of 15 articles were included. Results: The main objectives of the sensory rooms are: to provide a supportive therapeutic environment, to improve the quality of the experience within the environment of the room and to support people in emotional regulation during periods of distress and crisis. Some of the positive aspects of the use of these rooms are the increase in the general well-being of the users and the reduction of coercive measures in the event of an episode of agitation. Conclusions: Although the use of sensory rooms in psychiatry is something new and needs more research on its effectiveness, the limited literature shows that “comfort rooms” are an effective tool to promote the independence of the vast majority of users in their emotional regulation. Keywords: comfort, relaxation, sensory roomand mental health.