Arabica coffee ( Coffea arabica L.) is one of the top commercial commodities worldwide. The effectiveness of the selection of the coffee‐soaking treatment is significant in determining the best treatment for all traits tested. This study aimed to (1) evaluate the variation in soaking treatments on the tested traits, (2) identify the strengths and weaknesses of each treatment and determine the optimal treatment using the multitrait genotype‐ideotype distance index (MGIDI). The experiment was conducted in the Weeds Laboratory, Faculty of Agriculture, Universitas Padjadjaran. The treatment uses four times of soaking (F) (0,12,24,36) hours combined with two kinds of harvesting techniques (selective K1 and strip picking K2). The results showed significant differences across all tested traits at the p < 0.01 level, except for length after drying (LAD) ( p < 0.05). Treatments selective picking + 12 h of soaking time and selective picking + 24 h of soaking time contributed to the related properties, namely weight before drying, weight after drying, length before drying (LBD), width before drying (WBD), thickness before drying (TBD), LAD, width after drying (WAD), thickness after drying (TAD), and water content before drying (WCBD). On the other hand, strip picking + 36 h of soaking time, strip picking + 24 h of soaking time, and strip picking + 12 h of soaking time have strengths related to the last bean weight (LBW) and water content after drying (WCAD). The MGIDI identified selective picking + 36 h of soaking time (F3K1V1) as the best treatment across the 11 quality traits tested, while control strip picking + no soaking time (KRV1) was rated the least effective. This study highlights the utility of factor analysis within the MGIDI as an efficient tool for assessing the strengths and weaknesses of coffee‐soaking treatments across multiple traits.