Disasters, such as a school shooting or a global pandemic, harm psychological health and necessitate recovery. To complement adult-led disaster recovery and trauma-specific approaches, we propose a Youth-Led Resilience Promotion (YLRP) framework focusing on: (a) multitiered change, (b) resilience goals, (c) a promotion mindset, (d) youth strengths, (e) prosocial behaviors, and (f) capacity building through partnerships. The YLRP framework guided the development of a YLRP program in the aftermath of the Chardon High School shooting in Chardon, OH, which is detailed in a case study. As part of a Community-Academic Partnership, 20 college student trainers delivered a multitiered, multicomponent resilience promotion intervention: universal resilience promotion to 1,070 high school students; targeted resilience promotion to 200 student leaders through workshops; and indicated resilience promotion to 30 student leaders through mentoring. Student leaders formed a youth-led, afterschool club to advance relational resilience through prosocial strategies. Lessons learned from implementing the YLRP program for 6 years (2012-2017) are provided to guide YLRP program developers and program implementers. A youth-led program equipping youth leaders to engage in prosocial strategies may contribute to the psychological resilience and recovery of students after a school shooting, the coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic, and other potentially traumatic events. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2022 APA, all rights reserved).
Social problems and harmful behaviors can be prevented or mitigated when active bystanders intervene to help. As a result, prevention bystander intervention programs aim to prevent problems related to safety (e.g., sexual violence), health (e.g., injury or death), and justice (e.g., racial discrimination). In contrast, promotion bystander intervention programs aim to promote aspirations and desirable behaviors. This reality led us to develop an integrative Upstanding for Promotion-Prevention (UPP) program based on the decision-making steps of a revised bystander intervention model (i.e., notice an opportunity; interpret the situation; assume responsibility; select a promotion or prevention strategy; take action: Latané & Darley, 1970; McCarty, Arnold, Booker, Pacqué, & Liskey, 2021). Program participants experience a promotion track or prevention track to impact either the promoting pathway by changing assets or the protecting pathway by addressing risks and protective factors. The UPP program offers a motivation science approach to encourage upstanders to promote benefit and prevent harm in schools and on college campuses, within workplaces, online, and throughout communities. Ultimately, existing prevention bystander programs could adopt promotion elements to address safety through peace promotion and violence prevention, health through health promotion and disease prevention, and justice through antiracism promotion and racism prevention.
2 October 2023 in Journal of Prevention & Intervention in the Community
Bullying victimization remains a pressing concern to the health and development of U.S. adolescents. Victims of bullying face threats to their safety and education. Hence, interventions are needed to prevent bullying and equip others to intervene in bullying situations. Prior research has examined preventive interventions with little consideration of promotion-tailored, peace-encouraging, interventions. Further, there is a need to test whether people's motives toward preventive and promotive actions may fit with certain intervention tracks. Here, we tested an upstander approach consisting of a universal assembly presentation with promotion-oriented education (Promote Caring) and prevention-oriented education (Say Something), as well as a tailored 150-minute workshop (Upstanding for Promotion-Prevention). High school students (n = 388; 53.9% girls) participated in the study with a control group (n = 335) and intervention group who self-selected to experience upstanding for peace promotion (n = 15) or upstanding for bullying prevention (n = 35). Students in the prevention-tailored track reported stronger safety beliefs (violence prevention beliefs and care promotion beliefs) than students in the control group and endorsed using more defending actions than control-group students. Students' gain, non-gain, and loss motivations moderated ties between upstanding track involvement and post-test safety beliefs, barriers to upstanding, and defending behaviors.
The bystander intervention paradigm consists of upstanders preventing, mitigating, or responding to harm. The bystander intervention model (BIM) captures the decision-making process of bystanders: 1) notice harm; 2) interpret the situation; 3) assume responsibility; 4) select a strategy; and 5) take action (Latané & Darley, 1970). BIM has been applied to situations of safety (e.g., sexual assault, violence, cyber/bullying) and health (e.g., physical health, mental health). However, these bystander prevention opportunities do not reflect the full range of bystander opportunities, including promotion opportunities whereby upstanders can affirm desirable, safety-promoting or health-promoting behaviors. In this theoretical article, we adapt the prevention-oriented BIM by introducing promotion-oriented concepts associated with the intervention scope of promotion science, promotive focus of motivation science, and positive reinforcement of behavioral science. We propose the upstanding for promotion-prevention (UPP) model whereby promotion and prevention upstanders: 1) notice a promotion or a prevention opportunity; 2) interpret the situational degree of benefit or degree of harm; 3) assume responsibility as an ideal opportunity to enhance benefit or an obligation to stop harm; 4) select a promotion or prevention strategy; and 5) take action as an upstander using promotive or preventive prosocial bystander behavior. Additionally, we provide examples of UPP applications for safety (peace promotion – bullying prevention in schools) and health (health promotion – disease prevention in communities). Ultimately, we aim to advance a paradigm shift toward promotion upstanding, implicating bystander typologies, programs, and practices.
Our objective was to expand insights about supports and stressors shaping high school students’ adjustment. Using an ecological framework, we considered how indicators of the school climate, different cohorts and group memberships, and meaning making from students could each be informative of students’ high school adjustment. We used a concurrent embedded mixed methods design to capture students’ appraisals of the school climate and recollected challenges at school. We recruited students from an Ohio, USA high school and conducted a quantitative survey about the school climate (i.e., support, structure, schoolwide behaviors) from students ages 13 to 18 years (n = 1,157, 51.6% girls; 51.2% White; 25.9% Black). Students also provided open-ended responses about recent school challenges. We investigated the content of these responses for themes about typical happenings with peers and faculty, about resources and policies around the school, and about personal concerns students held. Students’ whose survey reports emphasized more prosocial prevalence, lower bullying prevalence, and better school structure and support also reported greater feelings of belonging with and satisfaction at school. Notably, more junior students and girls were less likely to endorse these patterns, hinting at greater challenges given grade level and gender. Students’ open-ended responses about school challenges often emphasized concerns about the school structure and responsiveness from others: concerns about bullying and fighting; frustrations with faculty decisions and policy; and worries about peer pressure and social conflicts. Students also spoke to concerns of discrimination and marginalization as part of open-ended responses. Findings highlighted the importance of a highly structured and responsive school climate for students. Findings also highlighted targets for better anticipating and intervening with what could be heightened challenges for groups of students with diminished status in the school.
Objective: Disasters, such as a school shooting or a global pandemic, harm psychological health and necessitate recovery. To complement adult-led disaster recovery and trauma-specific approaches, we propose a Youth-Led Resilience Promotion (YLRP) framework focusing on: 1) multi-tiered change, 2) resilience goals, 3) a promotion mindset, 4) youth strengths, 5) prosocial behaviors, and 6) capacity building through partnerships. The YLRP framework guided the development of a YLRP program in the aftermath of the Chardon High School shooting in Chardon, Ohio, which is detailed in a case study. Method: As part of a Community-Academic Partnership, twenty college student trainers delivered a multi-tiered, multicomponent resilience promotion intervention: universal resilience promotion to 1,070 high school students; targeted resilience promotion to 200 student leaders through workshops; and indicated resilience promotion to 30 student leaders through mentoring. Results: Student leaders formed a youth-led, after-school club to advance relational resilience through prosocial strategies. Lessons learned from implementing the YLRP program for six years (2012 – 2017) are provided to guide YLRP program developers and program implementers. Conclusion: A youth-led program equipping youth leaders to engage in prosocial strategies may contribute to the psychological resilience and recovery of students after a school shooting, the COVID-19 pandemic, and other potentially traumatic events.