Background Clinical reasoning ability is an important factor in a physician's competence and thus should be taught and tested in medical schools. Medical schools generally use objective structured clinical examinations (OSCE) to measure the clinical competency of medical students. However, it is unknown whether OSCE can also evaluate clinical reasoning ability. In this study, the authors investigated whether OSCE scores reflected students' clinical reasoning abilities. Methods Sixty-five fourth-year medical students participated in this study. Medical students completed the OSCE with 4 cases using standardized patients. For assessment of clinical reasoning, students were asked to list differential diagnoses and the findings that were compatible or not compatible with each diagnosis. The OSCE score (score of patient encounter), diagnostic accuracy score, clinical reasoning score, clinical knowledge score and grade point average (GPA) were obtained for each student, and correlation analysis was performed. Results Clinical reasoning score was significantly correlated with diagnostic accuracy and GPA (correlation coefficient = 0.258 and 0.380; P = 0.038 and 0.002, respectively) but not with OSCE score or clinical knowledge score (correlation coefficient = 0.137 and 0.242; P = 0.276 and 0.052, respectively). Total OSCE score was not significantly correlated with clinical knowledge test score, clinical reasoning score, diagnostic accuracy score or GPA. Conclusions OSCE score from patient encounters did not reflect the clinical reasoning abilities of the medical students in this study. The evaluation of medical students' clinical reasoning abilities through OSCE should be strengthened.
1 January 1987 in The Korean Journal of Parasitology
Objective structured clinical examinations (OSCEs) will be introduced in the Medical Licensing Examination in Korea next year. To evaluate the competency of new medical graduates, a written examination is not sufficient to test the clinical skills and attitudes of medical school graduates. The Korean Society of Medical Education and National Health Personnel Licensing Examination Board have been preparing for OSCEs to be included in the licensing examination for a number of years, following the declaration by the Minister of Health and Welfare, of the Korean Government. One center in Seoul will provide two identical sets of stations. The OSCE will have 12 stations. Six short stations will test procedural techniques and skills, and six long stations will feature standardized patients. The test items for the short stations and the clinical presentations of the long stations will be made available to applicants. However, the checklists will not be made available. It is hoped that the OSCE will raise the standard of competencies of new medical doctors and change clinical education in the medical schools.