Correlations of nighttime atmospheric methane (CH4) and 222radon (222Rn) observations in Heidelberg, Germany, were evaluated with the radon tracer method (RTM) to estimate the trend of annual nocturnal CH4 emissions from 1996–2020 in the footprint of the station. After an initial 30 % decrease in emissions from 1996 to 2004, there was no further systematic trend but small inter-annual variations were observed thereafter. This is in accordance with the trend of total emissions until 2010 reported by the EDGARv6.0 inventory for the surroundings of Heidelberg and provides a fully independent top-down verification of the bottom-up inventory changes. We show that the reliability of total nocturnal CH4 emission estimates with the RTM critically depends on the accuracy and representativeness of the 222Rn exhalation rates estimated from soils in the footprint of the site. Simply using 222Rn fluxes as estimated by Karstens et al. (2015) could lead to biases in the estimated greenhouse gas (GHG) fluxes as large as a factor of 2. RTM-based GHG flux estimates also depend on the parameters chosen for the nighttime correlations of CH4 and 222Rn, such as the nighttime period for regressions and the R2 cut-off value for the goodness of the fit. Quantitative comparison of total RTM-based top-down flux estimates with bottom-up emission inventories requires representative high-resolution footprint modelling, particularly in polluted areas where CH4 emissions show large heterogeneity. Even then, RTM-based estimates are likely biased low if point sources play a significant role in the station footprint as their emissions may not be fully captured by the RTM method, for example, if stack emissions are injected above the top of the nocturnal inversion layer or if point-source emissions from the surface are not well mixed into the footprint of the measurement site. Long-term representative 222Rn flux observations in the footprint of a station are indispensable in order to apply the RTM method for reliable quantitative flux estimations of GHG emissions from atmospheric observations.
Measuring the 14C C depletion in atmospheric CO2 compared with a clean-air reference is the most direct way to estimate the recently added CO2 contribution from fossil fuel (ff) combustion (ΔffCO2) in ambient air. However, as 14CO2 measurements cannot be conducted continuously nor remotely, there are only very sparse 14C-based ΔffCO2 estimates available. Continuously measured tracers, like carbon monoxide (CO), that are co-emitted with ffCO2 can be used as proxies for ΔffCO2, provided that the ΔCO ΔffCO2 ratios can be determined correctly (here, ΔCO refers to the CO excess compared with a clean-air reference). In the present study, we use almost 350 14CO2 measurements from flask samples collected between 2019 and 2020 at the urban site Heidelberg, Germany, and corresponding analyses from more than 50 afternoon flasks collected between September 2020 and March 2021 at the rural ICOS site Observatoire pérenne de l'environnement (OPE), France, to calculate average 14C-based ΔCO ΔffCO2 ratios for those sites. For this, we constructed a clean-air reference from the 14CO2 and CO measurements of Mace Head, Ireland. By dividing the hourly ΔCO excess observations by the averaged flask ratio, we calculate continuous proxy-based ΔffCO2 records. The mean bias between the proxy-based ΔffCO2 and the direct 14C-based ΔffCO2 estimates from the flasks is – with 0.31 ± 3.94 ppm for the urban site Heidelberg and −0.06 ± 1.49 ppm for the rural site OPE – only ca. 3 % at both sites. The root-mean-square deviation (RMSD) between proxy-based ΔffCO2 and 14C-based ΔffCO2 is about 4 ppm for Heidelberg and 1.5 ppm for OPE. While this uncertainty can be explained by observational uncertainties alone at OPE, about half of the uncertainty is caused by the neglected variability in the ΔCO ΔffCO2 ratios at Heidelberg. We further show that modeled ratios based on a bottom-up European emission inventory would lead to substantial biases in the ΔCO-based ΔffCO2 estimates for both Heidelberg and OPE. This highlights the need for an ongoing observational calibration and/or validation of inventory-based ratios if they are to be applied for large-scale ΔCO-based ΔffCO2 estimates, e.g., from satellites.
22 December 2023 in Atmospheric Chemistry and Physics
Atmospheric measurements of the ratio and the CO2 mole fraction (combined into the conceptual tracer “Atmospheric Potential Oxygen”, APO) over continents have been proposed as a constraint on CO2 emissions from fossil-fuel burning. Here we assess the suitability of such APO data to constrain anthropogenic CO2 emissions in western Europe, with particular focus on their decadal trends. We use an inversion of atmospheric transport to estimate spatially and temporally explicit scaling factors on a bottom-up fossil-fuel emissions inventory. Based on the small number of currently available observational records, our CO2 emissions estimates show relatively large apparent year-to-year variations, exceeding the expected uncertainty of the bottom-up inventory and precluding the calculation of statistically significant trends. We were not able to trace the apparent year-to-year variations back to particular properties of the APO data. Inversion of synthetic APO data, however, confirms that data information content and degrees of freedom are sufficient to successfully correct a counterfactual prior. Larger sets of measurement stations, such as the recently started APO observations from the Integrated Carbon Observation System (ICOS) European research infrastructure, improve the constraint and may ameliorate possible problems with local signals or with measurement or model errors at the stations. We further tested the impact of uncertainties in the O2:CO2 stoichiometries of fossil-fuel burning and land biospheric exchange and found they are not fundamental obstacles to estimating decadal trends in fossil-fuel CO2 emissions, though further work on fossil-fuel O2:CO2 stoichiometries seems necessary.
Atmospheric measurements of the short-lived radioactive noble gas radon-222 (222Rn) have many applications. Its concentrations are driven by atmospheric mixing as well as seasonal variations, which follow the seasonality of 222Rn exhalation from continental soils, with lower values during the wet winter and spring months compared to more dry summer conditions. Hence, it can be used as a tracer to distinguish marine from continental air masses or for transport model validation. The Heidelberg Radon Monitor (HRM) is a static filter detector measuring atmospheric 214polonium (214Po), which is a progeny of 222Rn. These measurements can be used to infer atmospheric 222Rn activity concentrations if the radioactive disequilibrium between 214Po and 222Rn at the measurement site is known. In this study, 214Po activity concentrations measured with the HRM at eight stations in the Integrated Carbon Observation System (ICOS) Germany network are presented, along with guidelines for evaluating these data to estimate atmospheric 222Rn activity concentrations. In addition to the established line loss and disequilibrium corrections applied when sampling through long tubing or from air intake heights close to the ground, respectively, an upper limit for relative humidity (RH) is suggested, where secular equilibrium can still be assumed. At higher RH, aerosol scavenging effects can cause disequilibrium between 214Po and 222Rn. Using comparison with the model this threshold is determined to be at about 98 % RH and was applied uniformly at all measurement sites. A clear diurnal cycle of 222Rn is observed at all German tower stations during the summer and autumn months as is a seasonal cycle with a maximum during summer and autumn months. Overall, our results demonstrate that the 214Po-based 222Rn measurements with the HRM are reliable if the equilibrium conditions between 214Po and 222Rn can be ensured, i.e., for air intake heights above 80–90 during conditions with RH<98 %. The corrected and ready-to-use dataset of 10-year radon activity concentrations from the eight ICOS stations is published alongside this paper (https://doi.org/10.18160/Q2M8-B1HJ, Fischer et al., 2024 ).
14 October 2025 in Atmospheric Chemistry and Physics
The radioactive noble gas radon (222Rn) is a suitable tracer for atmospheric transport and mixing processes that can be used to evaluate and calibrate atmospheric transport models or to estimate greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions using the so-called radon tracer method (RTM). However, these applications require reliable estimates of the 222Rn fluxes from the soil. This study evaluates two process-based 222Rn flux maps in central Europe in 2021 using the flux results from a 1-year 222Rn inversion. The maps are based on different soil moisture reanalysis products (GLDAS-Noah and ERA5-Land), which are used to describe the diffusive 222Rn transport in the soil. The 222Rn inversion was conducted using the CarboScope-Regional inversion system and observational data from 17 atmospheric sites in central Europe in 2021. We observe that, in particular, the ERA5-Land-based 222Rn flux map underestimates the data-driven fluxes from the inversion. Our inversion yields ca. 20 % (GLDAS-Noah) to almost 100 % (ERA5-Land) larger 222Rn fluxes than the respective process-based prior fluxes within a domain covering Germany. Also, the temporal variability seems to be underestimated by the process-based flux maps. Using a flat (uniform) prior inversion, we found a significant anti-correlation of −0.6 (and −0.8) between the posterior 222Rn flux and the GLDAS-Noah (and ERA5-Land) soil moisture time series, indicating that soil moisture is an important driver for the temporal variability in the 222Rn fluxes. To investigate the robustness of our flux estimates, we run the inversion with three different transport models (STILT, FLEXPART, NAME). The respective annual mean flux results agree within ca. 10 %.
Atmospheric measurements of the short-lived radioactive noble gas 222Radon (222Rn) have many applications. Its concentrations are driven by atmospheric mixing as well as seasonal variations, which follow the seasonality of 222Rn exhalation from continental soils with lower values during the wet winter and spring months compared to more dry summer conditions. Hence, it can be used as tracer to distinguish marine from continental air masses or for transport model validation. The Heidelberg Radon Monitor (HRM) is a static filter detector measuring atmospheric 214Polonium (214Po), which is a progeny of 222Rn. These measurements can be used to infer atmospheric 222Rn activity concentrations if the radioactive disequilibrium between 214Po and 222Rn at the measurement site is known. In this study, 214Po activity concentrations measured with the HRM at 8 stations in the ICOS Germany network are presented, along with guidelines for evaluating these data to estimate atmospheric 222Rn activity concentrations. In addition to the established line-loss and disequilibrium corrections applied when sampling through long tubing or from air intake heights close to the ground, respectively, an upper limit for relative humidity (RH) is suggested, where secular equilibrium can still be assumed. At higher RH, aerosol scavenging effects can cause disequilibrium between 214Po and 222Rn. Using comparison with the model this threshold is determined to be at about 98 % RH. A clear diurnal cycle of 222Rn is observed at all German tower stations during the summer and autumn months as well as seasonal cycle with maximum during summer and autumn months. Overall, our results demonstrate that the 214Po-based 222Rn measurements with the HRM are reliable if the equilibrium conditions between 214Po and 222Rn can be ensured, i.e. for air intake heights above 80–90 m a.g.l. at stations located in flat areas during conditions with RH < 98 %.