25 August 2014 in Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation
Systematic evaluation of the accuracy of exchange-correlation functionals is essential to guide scientists in their choice of an optimal method for a given problem when using density functional theory. In this work, accuracy of one Generalized Gradient Approximation (GGA) functional, three meta-GGA functionals, one Nonseparable Gradient Approximation (NGA) functional, one meta-NGA, and three hybrid GGA functionals was evaluated for calculations of the closest interatomic distances, cohesive energies, and bulk moduli of all 3d, 4d, and 5d bulk transition metals that have face centered cubic (fcc), hexagonal closed packed (hcp), or body centered cubic (bcc) structures (a total of 27 cases). Our results show that including the extra elements of kinetic energy density and Hartree–Fock exchange energy density into gradient approximation density functionals does not usually improve them. Nevertheless, the accuracies of the Tao–Perdew–Staroverov–Scuseria (TPSS) and M06-L meta-GGAs and the MN12-L meta-NGA approach the accuracy of the Perdew−Burke−Ernzerhof (PBE) GGA, so usage of these functionals may be advisable for systems containing both solid-state transition metals and molecular species. The N12 NGA functional is also shown to be almost as accurate as PBE for bulk transition metals, and thus it could be a good choice for studies of catalysis given its proven good performance for molecular species.
1 March 2013 in Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation
14 February 2017 in The Journal of Physical Chemistry C
The so-called CO/Pt(111) puzzle, the experimentally demonstrated preference of CO to adsorb on the top site on the Pt(111) surface rather than the 3-fold hollow sites predicted by standard density functional theory (DFT) methods, was alleged to be solved by properly leveling the CO frontier molecular orbitals. However, the subtle energy difference between the top and hollow sites is of the same order of magnitude as the possible contribution of dispersive forces to this interaction. Herein, the role of dispersion in this system has been investigated by considering the PBE, PBEsol, RevPBE, RPBE, and SOGGA11 generalized gradient approximation (GGA) based exchange–correlation functionals; nonseparable functionals such as N12; and the TPSS and M06-L meta-GGA-type functionals, together with D2, D3, D3BJ, and MBD dispersion corrections. The results reinforce the recommendation of using M06-L for a correct description of CO adsorption-site preference even if including dispersion leads to a change of site and a noticeable overestimation of the adsorption energy indicating the presence of error-compensation effects. The present results also highlight the fact that dispersion contributes in bridging the preference gap between the top and hollow sites when other functionals are used. Dispersive forces play a role in site preference for CO on Pt(111), and it is likely that a similar situation is encountered for other late transition metals. Therefore, dispersion must be considered to reach a completely unbiased description of CO adsorption on metals. Nevertheless, including dispersion leads to adsorption energy values that overestimate the experimental value, indicating the limitations of the existing, widely used density functionals.
24 June 2013 in The Journal of Chemical Physics
Graphene-metal contacts have emerged as systems of paramount importance in the synthesis of high-quality and large-size patches of graphene and as vital components of nanotechnological devices. Herein, we study the accuracy of several density functional theory methods using van der Waals functionals or dispersive forces corrections when describing the attachment of graphene on Ni(111). Two different experimentally observed chemisorption states, top-fcc and bridge-top, were put under examination, together with the hcp-fcc physisorption state. Calculated geometric, energetic, and electronic properties were compared to experimental data. From the calculations, one finds that (i) predictions made by different methodologies differ significantly and (ii) optB86b-vdW functional and Grimme dispersion correction seem to provide the best balanced description of stability of physisorption and chemisorption states, the attachment strength of the latter on Ni(111) surface, the graphene-Ni(111) separation, and the bandstructure of chemisorbed graphene. The collation suggests that accurate and affordable theoretical studies on technologies based on graphene-metal contacts are already at hand.
20 January 2017 in Catalysis Science & Technology
Recent experimental studies showed evidence for C dissolution in Pt nanoparticles after CH4 decomposition, and the posterior low temperature segregation to form surface graphene, highlighting graphene growth from below. There are indications of an easier C transfer between surface and subsurface regions at Pt grain boundaries, although the ultimate atomistic mechanism remains unclear. A plausible explanation is provided here by exploring and comparing C incorporation in Ni, Pd, and Pt(111) surfaces by density functional (DF) calculations on slab models under a low coverage regime, evaluating the energetic stability and subsurface sinking kinetic feasibility. Four DF functionals have been used, avoiding possible biased results. All functionals showed that C atoms occupy octahedral subsurface (oss) sites in Ni(111), with high sinking energy barriers of 80–90 kJ mol−1, whereas both oss and tetrahedral subsurface (tss) sites can be occupied in Pd(111), with low sinking energy barriers of 20–50 kJ mol−1. The oss sites are strongly disfavoured on Pt(111), whereas the tss sites are found to be isoenergetic to surface sites, with low subsurface sinking energy barriers of 27–41 kJ mol−1. Calculations on Pt79 and Pt140 nanoparticle models reveal how tss sites are more stabilized at low-coordinated sites, where subsurface sinking energy barriers drop to values of ∼17 kJ mol−1. These results explain the experimentally observed C dissolution and segregation in Pt systems, more favoured at grain boundaries, as well as the graphene growth from below and the formation of double layer models. In addition, the present results open a gate for profiting from the small quantities of C placed at the subsurface region in order to tune the surface catalytic activity of Pt nanoparticle based catalysts.
1 October 2020 in Optical Materials
WCWeerapong Chewpraditkul