Student enrollment patterns have been studied during the COVID-19 pandemic, with many families seeking alternatives to traditional public schools. Less is known about teacher experiences in these alternatives. We explored predictors of teacher job satisfaction, burnout, and morale. Of particular interest was whether these presented differently across school types. We surveyed teachers nationwide (n = 798) in May 2022. Three linear regression models were tested. Results suggested that teacher autonomy and administrative support were significant predictors in each model. Private school teachers experienced greater job satisfaction and morale than traditional public school teachers; charter school teachers had greater levels of morale.
The aim of this empirical study was to develop a portrait of and investigate dance education programming in the New York City charter sector. Despite operating within an arts-focused, culturally rich metropolis, the state of arts and dance education in NYC charter schools has yet to receive the attention needed to flourish alongside traditional public and private schools. Data was collected quantitatively by administering electronic survey questionnaires to leadership teams of the 337 NYC-based charter schools authorized and operating during the 2018–2019 academic year. The survey questionnaire data suggested the existence of a variety of both curricular and extra-curricular dance offerings led primarily by full-time dance teachers. Trends emerged in leadership teams’ perceptions of the rewards of offering dance, while a lack of physical space and competing curricular programming emerged as the most commonly cited frustrations from schools already offering dance instruction and challenges from schools not offering dance, respectively.
The purpose of this exploratory multiple-case study was (1) to develop an understanding of how charter management organizations (CMOs) operating schools in New York City (NYC) during the 2021–2022 academic year developed, promoted, and sustained arts programming, and (2) to explore the role of the network-level arts director. Given the desire to understand network-level arts support provided by CMOs in detail and in the context of how that support functions contemporarily and in the real world, an exploratory multiple-case study method with an embedded design was situated as the preferred mode of inquiry. Within the research design, the quintain – or phenomenon studied across cases – was the support provided by CMOs at the network level to arts education programming at the school level. The embedded units of analysis for each case included a brief questionnaire completed by the network-level arts director, a semi-structured interview with the network-level arts director, and the documentation publicly available about arts education within the CMO (e.g. how the CMO’s website positioned arts education offerings within the network). Data was collected during March–May 2022 in NYC. The first theme from the cross-case analysis involved the strategic vision-setting and on-the-ground implementation, which highlighted the potential disconnects that could occur between what was supposed to be happening within arts education (in the vision) and what was actually happening within arts education (on the ground) regardless of whether arts were considered “core” or “noncore” in a given network. The importance of the balance between autonomy and prescription provided to teachers and expansion, capacity-building, and vertical alignment also emerged as themes. In addition to shedding light on network-level practices and policies that support arts programming in schools and network-level arts directors’ roles within this support, several specific implications are provided for theory, practice, and future research alike.