Existing global mean surface temperature reconstructions for the Holocene lack high-frequency variability that is essential for contextualising recent trends and extremes in the Earth’s climate system. Here, we isolate and recombine archive-specific climate signals to generate a frequency-optimised record of interannual to multi-millennial temperature changes for the past 12 000 years. Average temperatures before ∼8000 years BP and after ∼4000 years BP were 0.26 (±2.84) °C and 0.07 (±2.11) °C cooler than the long-term mean (0–12 000 years BP), while the Holocene Climate Optimum ∼7000–4000 years BP was 0.40 (±1.86) °C warmer. Biased towards Northern Hemisphere summer temperatures, our multi-proxy record captures the spectral properties of transient Earth system model simulations for the same spatial and season domain. The new frequency-optimised trajectory emphasises the importance and complex interplay of natural climate forcing factors throughout the Holocene, with an approximation of the full range of past temperature changes providing novel insights for policymakers addressing the risks of recent anthropogenic warming.
Recent scholarship argues for more research to resolve the ‘Holocene temperature conundrum’, an apparent discrepancy between decreasing proxy-reconstructed and increasing model-simulated long-term temperature trends during the late Holocene. Here, we argue that the observed proxy-model offset likely results from inappropriate comparisons of different seasonal and spatial signals in the reconstructed and simulated palaeo-data. Since proxy archives have been used to reconstruct global annual mean temperatures, they have been compared against model simulations of the same seasonal and spatial domains. However, we suggest that most of the proxy-based large-scale reconstructions are biased towards Northern Hemisphere summer temperatures, and as such model comparisons have predominantly focused on the wrong target data. Further to advancing our understanding of long-term temperature trends, we recommend prioritising the refinement of proxy networks and climate reconstructions to preserve the full spectrum of naturally forced, interannual to multi-millennial variations needed to contextualise recent anthropogenic changes against past Holocene ranges.
Blanket peat is widespread in maritime extra‐tropical environments. Prehistoric land‐use activity was traditionally invoked as the stimulus of blanket peat initiation in the British Isles, but recently, climate has been viewed as the driver of peat formation. Understanding of the timing and thus cause of blanket peat initiation is, however, confounded by uncertainties that primarily pertain to dating well‐humified peat deposits. Here, we seek to address challenges in dating blanket peat with a view to better understanding its initiation in Ireland. Through a study of blanket peat profiles from five sites in the Mourne Mountains, Northern Ireland, we show that radiocarbon ages from different peat fractions are younger than contemporaneous cryptotephra ages by several centuries, probably due to the translocation of humic acids and root material down sediment profiles. Peat initiation was, therefore, dated in the Mourne Mountains using tephrochronology, and reveals initiation centred on ~8700 BP, ~7900–6800 BP and ~3500 BP. Reanalysis of Irish basal peat ages emphasises climate as the driver of blanket peat from ~7500 BP, but highlights that its development was time‐transgressive at intra‐ and inter‐regional scales. We conclude that blanket peat is a natural feature of the Irish landscape and highlight the uncertainties of radiocarbon dating blanket peat deposits.
Context: Archaeological and historical evidence attest that transhumance was commonplace across Ireland during the last millennium. This largely involved the movement of people and their cows to upland pastures for the summer months to create space in the lowlands for arable farming. Significant gaps in understanding remain relating to the timing of and motivations for seasonal settlement, the activities that herders engaged in and the impact of land-use on the local environment. Objectives: Here, we use a palaeoecological approach to produce records of past land-use and settlement history that will resolve extant questions regarding the timing of transhumance, the activities of settlers and their impacts on the landscape. Methods: We collected blanket peat sequences from the immediate vicinity of two transhumant sites in the Mourne Mountains, County Down, Northern Ireland. We analysed sequences for pollen and non-pollen palynomorphs to understand the landscape history of both sites. Cryptotephra analysis was employed to robustly date these palaeoenvironmental records. Results: We date the commencement of land-use activity at occupation sites studied in the Mournes to the mid- to late twelfth century CE, and show that people grazed livestock and grew cereals in these localities. These findings question the long-held view that occupation reflects summer herding, and highlight that transhumance may have emerged from a longer tradition of permanent upland settlement. We also find that the impact of these activities was largely local, with no discernible impact on the surrounding heath-dominated landscape. Results place the demise of activity during the early nineteenth century CE, probably due to change in favoured stock type from cattle to sheep. Conclusions: Results shed new light on upland settlement in Ireland during the last millennium, showing that settlers took part in a more diverse array of farming activities than was previously believed. In addition, our results challenge current interpretations of the history of transhumance practices in Ireland finding that its origins may stem from the demise of permanent upland settlement, and demonstrate the resilience of past populations in what are today regarded as ‘marginal’ environments.
A long‐term perspective on landscape evolution is critical for understanding past land‐use activity, land cover–climate feedbacks and, notably, for establishing a factual basis for conservation. Fossil pollen analysis provides a means to achieve this. Biases pertaining to pollen productivity, pollination processes and basin size, however, mean there is not a one‐to‐one relationship between pollen and plant presence. Upland pollen recruitment is poorly understood, and existing studies of pollen dispersal have yielded conflicting results, making interpreting past landscape character challenging. Here, we report on the modern pollen rain of the Mourne Mountains, Northern Ireland, relative to local and regional vegetation to investigate the signal that upland pollen spectra capture. We find that long‐distance pollen transport is prevalent, comprising an average of 56% of total dryland pollen for sites where the local vegetation is open, and controlled by a positive relationship with elevation. An abundance of regionally sourced arboreal pollen and dominance of pollen from some locally growing taxa poses challenges for interpreting local landscape character as locally growing herbaceous taxa, isolated trees and extra‐local woodland are diminished in pollen spectra. We show that arboreal pollen abundance around 80% is indicative of locally growing, semi‐closed woodland, but this should be accompanied by low palynological richness and evenness to firmly ascribe this habitat type. Despite the complex signal that upland pollen spectra represent, we show vegetation can be reliably interpreted from pollen with careful consideration of a site's setting in the landscape. This study further highlights the importance of studying modern pollen rain samples with respect to local and regional vegetation and provides insights that aid interpretation of palaeoecological studies in upland areas globally.
The Cumbrian Wildlife Trust (CWT) is undertaking the most ambitious attempt to revive Britain’s lost temperate rainforest in Skiddaw, northern Lake District, over the next 100 years. This involves the restoration of native Atlantic tree and treeless communities, including peatland in the area. There are ongoing ecological surveys to map the current vegetation and assess peatland status to establish baseline for detailed framework to restore degraded bogs. In collaboration with the CWT, this study employs different lines of palaeoecological evidence to investigate Skiddaw bog’s ecological history, the degree of its degradation over time, and the role of climatic and anthropogenic factors in shaping the landscape. This long-term perspective complements ongoing ecological appraisals by establishing a comprehensive baseline to predict changes in the bog and develop robust restoration and conservation frameworks against future warming climates.