Recently, new emphasis was put on reducing waiting times in mental health services as there is an ongoing concern that longer waiting time for treatment leads to poorer health outcomes. However, little is known about delays within the mental health service system and its impact on patients. We explore the impact of waiting times on patient outcomes in the context of early intervention in psychosis (EIP) services in England from April 2012 to March 2015. We use the Mental Health Services Data Set and the routine outcome measure the Health of the Nation Outcome Scale. In a generalised linear regression model, we control for baseline outcomes, previous service use, and treatment intensity to account for possible endogeneity in waiting time. We find that longer waiting time is significantly associated with a deterioration in patient outcomes 12 months after acceptance for treatment for patients that are still in EIP care. Effects are strongest for waiting times longer than 3 months, and effect sizes are small to moderate. Patients with shorter treatment periods are not affected. The results suggest that policies should aim to reduce excessively long waits in order to improve outcomes for patients waiting for treatment for psychosis.
The importance of day surgery as a less costly alternative compared to conventional inpatient hospital stays is growing internationally. The rate of day surgery activities has increased across Europe. However, this trend has been heterogeneous across countries, and might still be below its potential. Since payment systems affect how providers offer care, they represent a policy instrument to further increase the rate of day surgeries. In this paper, we review international strategies to promote day surgery with a particular focus on payment models for 13 OECD countries (Australia, Austria, Canada, Denmark, England, Estonia, Finland, France, Germany, Netherlands, Norway, Sweden, Switzerland). We conduct a cross-country comparison based on an email survey of health policy experts and a comprehensive literature review of peer-reviewed papers and grey literature. Our research shows that all countries aim to strengthen day surgery activity to increase health system efficiency. Several countries used financial and non-financial policy measures to overcome misaligned incentive structures and promote day surgery activity. Financial incentives for day surgery can serve as a policy instrument to promote change. We recommend embedding these incentives in a comprehensive approach of restructuring health systems. In addition, we encourage countries to monitor and evaluate the effect of changes to payment systems on day surgeries to allow for more informed decision-making.
25 February 2020 in The European Journal of Health Economics
Objective: In April 2015, the English National Health Service started implementing the first waiting time targets in mental health care. This study aims to investigate the effect of the 14-day waiting time target for early intervention in psychosis (EIP) services after the first six months of its implementation.Study design: We analyse a cohort of first-episode psychosis patients from the English administrative Mental Health and Learning Disabilities Dataset 2011 to 2015. We compare patients being treated by EIP services (treatment) with those receiving care from standard community mental health services (control). We combine non-parametric matching with a difference-in-difference approach to account for observed and unobserved group differences. We analyse the probability of waiting below target and look at different percentiles of the waiting time distribution.Results: EIP patients had an 11.6–18.4 percentage point higher chance of waiting below target post-policy compared to standard care patients. However, post-policy trends at different percentiles of the waiting time distribution were not different between groups.Conclusions: Mental health providers seem to respond to waiting time targets in a similar way as physical health providers. The increased proportion waiting below target did not, however, result in an overall improvement across the waiting time distribution.
6 August 2025 in Research in Health Services & Regions
Background: Analyzing regional variations can help improve equity, efficiency, and quality in health care provision. The PopGrouper is a population-based classification system which classifies persons with similar health care needs into distinct groups. It exhibits a high degree of morbidity differentiation. We present an analytical framework to use the PopGrouper in examining regional variations across different outcomes and populations using routine patient-level data. Methods: We develop a two-step empirical strategy to examine the relative regional performance on a set of efficiency and quality outcomes (e.g., hospital bed days, cost of care, mortality). First, we propose PopGroup-standardized observed-to-expected ratios to compare regional performance. Second, we develop a multilevel regression model to separately estimate regional variation related to patient need measured by the PopGroup and variation related to regional characteristics. Results: We provide an analytical framework that demonstrates the PopGrouper’s application as a tool for morbidity adjustment in the assessment of relative regional performance in efficiency and quality outcomes and the regional characteristics that explain this performance. We provide suggestions for empirical notation, interpretation of results, and graphical analyses of findings. The developed framework will be applied in subsequent empirical papers. Conclusion: This paper sets the analytical foundations to be applied in regional comparative analyses using the PopGrouper allowing for conclusions about unexplained variations in quality and efficiency of health care.
17 December 2025 in Research in Health Services & Regions
Background: Diabetes-related hospitalizations and amputations serve as indicators of healthcare system performance, revealing regional disparities in diabetes management. This study examines regional variations in diabetes-related and all-cause outcomes among people with type 2 diabetes across Germany, adjusting for morbidity using the novel PopGrouper classification system. The paper aims to test the applicability of the PopGrouper for analyses of regional variations in health care. Methods: Based on claims data from the BARMER sickness fund, six outcomes (hospitalizations, emergency hospitalizations, amputations, hospital care costs, inpatient days, and mortality) were analyzed. For each outcome, the ratio of observed to expected outcomes was calculated based on each region’s PopGroup composition and compared to results based on age-sex composition. Finally, the analysis identified top- and bottom-performing regions based on PopGroup-adjusted performance and explored patterns of resource utilization in these regions. Results: The findings reveal the greatest regional variation for amputations and emergency hospitalizations, followed by hospitalizations, for both, age-sex-standardized and PopGroup-standardized ratios. The observed variation was slightly lower with PopGroup standardization than with age-sex standardization, except in the case of mortality. The top-performing regions had lower inpatient resource utilization, but higher outpatient resource utilization and participation in disease management programs in the year prior to the performance outcome measurement. Conclusion: Regional variations in hospitalizations and related outcomes for type 2 diabetes were observed. The PopGrouper enables straightforward risk-adjustment through indirect standardization and can make a significant contribution to controlling for morbidity-related care needs in regional comparative analyses.
9 June 2026 in Research in Health Services & Regions
Background: Depression is associated with a substantial health and economic burden and shows pronounced regional variation in Germany. While socioeconomic and urban–rural differences in depression prevalence and service use are well documented, less is known about how regional socioeconomic deprivation and urbanization relate to healthcare utilization after accounting for multimorbidity. Methods: We analyzed nationwide claims data from a large German sickness fund including adults with diagnosed depression ( N = 1,083,319). Healthcare utilization in 2023 was measured as healthcare costs, days of sickness absence, any outpatient mental health specialist contact, and outpatient psychotherapy use. Multilevel regression models with individuals nested within 96 spatial planning regions were estimated, adjusting for age, sex, and multimorbidity using the PopGrouper. Regional socioeconomic deprivation was measured using the German Index of Socioeconomic Deprivation, and urbanization was classified as urban, semi-urban, or rural. Proportional variance component analyses quantified explained regional heterogeneity. Results: Higher regional socioeconomic deprivation was significantly associated with more days of sickness absence (adjusted mean: 34.1 days in the least vs. 40.1 days in the most deprived regions) and a lower likelihood of receiving outpatient psychotherapy (17.9% vs. 16.3%). No significant associations were observed between deprivation and healthcare costs or mental health specialist contacts. Urban regions were associated with higher healthcare costs (2,284€ vs. 2,188€) and more frequent mental health specialist contacts (15.6% vs. 13.5%). Overall regional clustering was modest but most pronounced for mental health specialist contacts. Conclusion: Regional socioeconomic deprivation is linked to higher sickness absence due to depression. Regional inequalities in access to mental health services are small but largely unexplained by deprivation, urbanization, and multimorbidity.