This work presents a theoretical framework distinguishing the fluidity of “heteromorphic imagination” – where mental associations and episodic memories intermingle freely to proliferate atypical possibilities – and the crystallization of "creative imagination," marked by the emergence of compelling, constructible ideas. We propose that the pivot points, where emerging possibilities transform into articulable creativity, are significant metamorphic phenomenological gestures with profound existential implications. Heteromorphic imagination involves unconstrained, radically divergent play across real and unreal combinatory spaces, remembered impossibilities, and speculative blends. This manifests a timeless state balancing past, present, and future scenes as part of unconscious exploration. In contrast, creative imagination emerges from heteromorphic imagination when spontaneously recognized resonant patterns induce metacognitive focus, signifying ideas worth capturing and expressing. We define metamorphic gestures as pivotal phenomenological events where one mode transmutes to the other – heteromorphic into creative. Such gestures hold revelatory potential for tracing the origin of creativity’s spark, where novel patterns self-organize into meaningful ideation. Our methodological approach, blending brain-computer interface technology with qualitative phenomenological research, aims to trace the contours and impacts of these creative gestures. By capturing and analyzing subjective reports and neural signals, we seek to decode the transition points in creative ideation. This work is a continuing effort that holds special relevance given the rapid advances in procedural computational systems designed to automate facets of creativity. Illuminating the pivotal phenomenological gestures and their contours reasserts human elements that automated creativity may augment but likely cannot replicate.
This study investigates the flow of imagination in design practice through an ambiguous tactile interface that is intended to work as a catalyst for creative inspiration. Using a phenomenological lens and theoretical frameworks from Vygotsky's conception of imagination as cognitive process, Dewey's experiential learning theory, and Merleau-Ponty's phenomenology of perception and embodiment, this research evaluates the effectiveness of ambiguous tangible input. This type of ambiguous input aims to invite designers to linger in their imaginative flow through unstructured playful interaction, particularly focusing on pareidolia with digital visual stimuli. Through semi-structured interviews with 20 designers, we use phenomenological analysis to interpret and examine their lived experiences during the ambiguous interaction. The aim of this study is to advance the understanding of sustained immersion in inner imagination in the context of creativity in the design process.
Generative AI systems can enhance individual creative output while reducing the collective diversity of produced works. Current explanations for this paradox focus primarily on artifacts, model distributions, or design fixation. This paper proposes a complementary cognitive-phenomenological account grounded in the distinction between two modes of imaginative cogni-tion: heteromorphic imagination, characterized by pre-articulatory associative play across real and unreal com-binatory spaces, and creative imagination, in which emergent patterns achieve sufficient resonance to warrant articulation. We argue that prompt-based interaction imposes a demand for premature crystallization: a pressured translation from heteromorphic exploration into linguistically structured, model-interpretable expression. This demand can incentivize bypassing a cog-nitive phase that helps generate semantically remote, personally resonant, and meaning-bearing possibilities before they stabilize as concepts. Drawing on work on the Default Mode Network, divergent thinking, and dynamic switching between spontaneous and controlled cognition, we frame the neural component as a falsi-fiable hypothesis rather than an established effect. The resulting implication for computational creativity is that evaluation of human-AI co-creative systems should extend beyond outputs to upstream human cognitive processes and their possible long-term modification.