28 January 2025 in Respiratory Medicine
Pulmonary rehabilitation (PR) benefits individuals with chronic respiratory conditions beyond COPD; however, the quality of online resources has not been evaluated. The aims of this study were to assess the content, quality, and comprehensibility of YouTube videos that provide PR to individuals with chronic lung diseases other than COPD. A search was conducted on YouTube for videos related to PR on non-COPD conditions, with the first 350 videos screened for eligibility (2004-2024). Videos were assessed for content based on predefined scoring matrix derived from PR guidelines, evaluated for their quality using the modified DISCERN tool and Global Quality Scale (GQS), and assessed for their understandability and actionability using the Patient Education Materials and Assessment Tool. Engagement metrics including viewing rate and interaction index were also analyzed. Of the 59 videos included, there was significant heterogeneity in PR content (i.e. aerobic, strength training, flexibility, etc.). 83 % of the videos were published following the onset of COVID-19 pandemic (March 2020), and 85 % of the videos were not directed at specific disease states. Video quality was moderate, with median modified DISCERN and GQS of 3 IQR[3-4] and 3 IQR[2-4] out of 5, respectively. Mean understandability and actionability were above the 70 % threshold. Engagement metrics revealed that median video views were 2857 (IQR[637-10,729]), but engagement was low (1.4 % IQR[1.0-2.7]). The study highlights variability in PR content and moderate quality of videos, with reasonable comprehensibility. There is a need for more standardized and disease-specific PR online video resources for non-COPD states.
27 January 2025 in Respiratory Medicine
Inspiratory muscle training (IMT) is an effective rehabilitation modality for individuals with chronic lung disease. IMT can improve dyspnea, exercise capacity, and health-related quality of life. Online resources are common sources of health information for individuals. This study is the first to: 1) evaluate the content, reliability, quality, and comprehensibility of IMT-related videos and websites for individuals with chronic lung disease, and 2) determine the characteristics of these online resources. The search term "(respiratory muscle training) OR (inspiratory muscle training)" was used to evaluate the first 200 consecutive YouTube videos and 200 Google websites on IMT for chronic lung disease management. Online resources were evaluated using validated scoring metrics: modified DISCERN tool, Global Quality Scale (GQS), and Patient Education Materials Assessment Tools (PEMAT) understandability and actionability. Content comprising key IMT components was also scored. Forty videos and fourteen websites were included, with majority uploaded by for-profit organizations. Content scores (out of 25) were low (videos 7.7 ± 4.4; websites 11.4 ± 5.3, p = 0.01). Benefits of IMT were often highlighted, but safety considerations were infrequently mentioned. Resources scored poorly on modified DISCERN (videos 2/5 IQR[1.0-3.0]; websites 3.5/5 IQR[2.0-4.0], p = 0.001), and GQS scores (videos 2/5 IQR[2.0-3.0]; websites 3/5 IQR[2.8-3.3], p = 0.003). Online resources met the PEMAT threshold (>70 %) for understandability, but not actionability. Online IMT resources have mainly focused on the benefits of IMT and majority were developed by for-profit organizations. There is a need for high-quality, evidence-based online resources, as IMT is an important rehabilitation modality for chronic lung disease management.
26 March 2024 in Respiratory Medicine
Pulmonary inhaler therapy is a core treatment modality for >600 million individuals affected by obstructive airways disease globally. Poor inhaler technique is associated with reduced disease control and increased health care utilization; however, many patients rely on the internet as a technical resource. This study assesses the content and quality of online resources describing inhaler techniques. A Google search was conducted in April 2023 capturing the top 5 search results for 12 common inhaler devices. Websites were compared to product monographs for preparation/first use, inhalational technique, and post-usage/device care. They were also assessed using accepted quality metrics (GQS, DISCERN, JAMA Benchmark scores) and clinically relevant aspects based on the literature and consensus statements. Websites regularly excluded critical steps important for proper inhaler technique. They performed best on information related directly to inhalation technique (average median score 78%), whereas steps related to preparation/first use (58%) or post-usage/device care (50%) were less frequently addressed. Median GQS, DISCERN, and JAMA Benchmark scores were 3 [IQR 3-4], 3 [IQR 2-4], and 1 [IQR 1-3], respectively. Clinically relevant factors were only addressed in about one-fifth of websites with no websites addressing smoking cessation, environmental considerations, or risk factors for poor technique. This study highlights gaps in online resources describing inhaler technique, particularly related to preparation/first use and post-usage/device care steps. Clinically relevant factors were rarely addressed across websites. Improvements in these areas could lead to enhanced inhaler technique and clinical outcomes.