Lea-Sophie Bonde

Lea-Sophie Bonde

Auto-generated profile, based on publicly available information

Lea-Sophie Bonde

QUEST Center for Responsible Research, Berlin Institute of Health at Charité, Berlin, Germany

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

5Years (2022-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
20 January 2023 in BMJ Open
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
SWSarah Weschke
Sarah Weschke
DFDelwen L Franzen
Delwen L Franzen
ASAnna Karolina Sierawska
Anna Karolina Sierawska
LBLea-Sophie Bonde
Lea-Sophie Bonde
DSDaniel Strech
Daniel Strech
SSSusanne Gabriele Schorr
Susanne Gabriele Schorr
Objectives To evaluate the extent and quality of patient involvement reporting in examples of current practice in health research. Design Mixed-methods study. We used a targeted search strategy across three cohorts to identify health research publications that reported patient involvement: original research articles published in 2019 in the British Medical Journal (BMJ), articles listed in the Patient-Centered Outcomes Research Institute (PCORI) database (2019), and articles citing the GRIPP2 (Guidance for Reporting Involvement of Patients and Public) reporting checklist for patient involvement or a critical appraisal guideline for user involvement. Publications were coded according to three coding schemes: ‘phase of involvement’, the GRIPP2-Short Form (GRIPP2-SF) reporting checklist and the critical appraisal guideline. Outcome measures The phase of the study in which patients were actively involved. For the BMJ sample, the proportion of publications that reported patient involvement. The quality of reporting based on the GRIPP2-SF reporting guideline. The quality of patient involvement based on the critical appraisal guideline. Quantitative and qualitative results are reported. Results We included 86 publications that reported patient involvement. Patients were most frequently involved in study design (90% of publications, n=77), followed by study conduct (71%, n=61) and dissemination (42%, n=36). Reporting of patient involvement was often incomplete, for example, only 40% of publications (n=34) reported the aim of patient involvement. While the methods (57%, n=49) and results (59%, n=51) of involvement were reported more frequently, reporting was often unspecific and the influence of patients’ input remained vague. Therefore, a systematic assessment of the quality and impact of patient involvement according to the critical appraisal guideline was not feasible across samples. Conclusions As patient involvement is increasingly seen as an integral part of the research process and requested by funding bodies, it is essential that researchers receive specific guidance on how to report patient involvement activities. Complete reporting builds the foundation for assessing the quality of patient involvement and its impact on research.

21 April 2022 in medRxiv
Verified
Preprint
Open access
PDF file
SWSarah Weschke
Sarah Weschke
DFDelwen L Franzen
Delwen L Franzen
ASAnna Karolina Sierawska
Anna Karolina Sierawska
LBLea-Sophie Bonde
Lea-Sophie Bonde
DSDaniel Strech
Daniel Strech
SSSusanne Gabriele Schorr
Susanne Gabriele Schorr
Objectives: To evaluate the extent and quality of patient involvement reporting in examples of current practice in health research. Design: Mixed-methods study. We used a targeted search strategy across three cohorts to identify health research publications that reported patient involvement: publications published in The BMJ , publications listed in the PCORI database, and publications citing the GRIPP2 reporting checklist for patient involvement or a critical appraisal guideline for user involvement. Publications were coded according to three coding schemes: “Phase of involvement”, the GRIPP2-SF reporting checklist, and the critical appraisal guideline. Outcome measures: The phase of the study in which patients were actively involved. For the BMJ sample, the proportion of publications that reported patient involvement. The quality of reporting based on the GRIPP2 short form reporting guideline. The quality of patient involvement based on the critical appraisal guideline. Quantitative and qualitative results are reported. Results: We included 87 publications that reported patient involvement. Patients were most frequently involved in study design (90% of publications, n=78), followed by study conduct (70%, n=61), and dissemination (40%, n=35). Reporting of patient involvement was often incomplete, e.g., only 39% of publications (n=34) reported the aim of patient involvement. While the methods (56%, n=49) and results (59%, n=51) of involvement were reported more frequently, qualitative analyses showed that reporting was often unspecific and the influence of patients’ input remained vague. Therefore, a systematic assessment of the quality and impact of patient involvement according to the critical appraisal guideline was not feasible across samples. Conclusions: As patient involvement is increasingly seen as an integral part of the research process and requested by funding bodies, it is essential that researchers receive specific guidance on how to report patient involvement activities. Complete reporting builds the foundation for assessing the quality of patient involvement and its impact on research. PROTOCOL: The protocol was published on the Open Science Framework: https://osf.io/vntgu/ STRENGTHS AND LIMITATIONS: A targeted search strategy was used to identify examples of patient involvement reporting in a variety of publication types and study designs in health research A mixed-methods approach allowed for an analysis of both the completeness and quality of patient involvement reporting In this study, we coded statements reporting on patient involvement in 87 health research publications that may be adapted for further use Reporting of patient involvement was insufficiently detailed to allow for a systematic assessment of the quality of patient involvement