This study aimed to compare fertility-sparing interventions and hysterectomy among women with placenta accreta spectrum disorder (PAS) who underwent caesarean deliveries. We retrospectively reviewed the data, and classified 148 patients as follows: group B: Bakri balloon without resection (n = 83); group R: segmental uterine resection (n = 23); and group H: hysterectomy (n = 42). The groups differed significantly with respect to operative time, transfused blood products, and post-operative intensive care unit and hospital stays. Morbidity was the highest in group H. The aforementioned parameters did not differ between Groups B and R. Groups R and H differed regarding the operative time, post-operative hospital stay, and transfused blood products. Although the treatment modality and PAS severity differed between the groups of patients with preserved fertility, the surgical outcome parameters did not differ. Hence, the effectiveness of these approaches may be similar without foregoing patient safety.