19 March 2022 in Cognition
Numerical illusions may provide a powerful window into the mechanisms that give rise to our visual number sense. Recent research has shown that similarly oriented elements appear more numerous than randomly oriented elements in an array. Here we examine whether the orientation coherence illusion is a more general byproduct of the effect of entropy on numerical information-processing. Participants engaged in an ordinal numerical comparison task where the color entropy of arrays was manipulated. We found that arrays with low color entropy were perceived as more numerous than arrays with high color entropy (Experiments 1 and 2), suggesting that the coherence illusion on numerosity perception is not specific to a particular visual property (e.g., orientation) but instead that the entropy of visual arrays more generally affects numerical processing. In Experiment 3, we explored the developmental trajectory of the color entropy effect in children aged 5 to 17 and found that the strength of the coherence illusion increases into adulthood, raising intriguing questions as to how perceptual experiences influence the progression of this numerosity illusion. We consider a recently proposed resource-rational model as a framework for understanding the entropy effect on numerosity perception under an information-theoretic perspective.
1 July 2021 in Journal of Experimental Child Psychology
Prior work indicates that children have an untrained ability to approximately calculate using their approximate number system (ANS). For example, children can mentally double or halve a large array of discrete objects. Here, we asked whether children can perform a true multiplication operation, flexibly attending to both the multiplier and multiplicand, prior to formal multiplication instruction. We presented 5- to 8-year-olds with nonsymbolic multiplicands (dot arrays) or symbolic multiplicands (Arabic numerals) ranging from 2 to 12 and with nonsymbolic multipliers ranging from 2 to 8. Children compared each imagined product with a visible comparison quantity. Children performed with above-chance accuracy on both nonsymbolic and symbolic approximate multiplication, and their performance was dependent on the ratio between the imagined product and the comparison target. Children who could not solve any single-digit symbolic multiplication equations (e.g., 2 x 3) on a basic math test were nevertheless successful on both our approximate multiplication tasks, indicating that children have an intuitive sense of multiplication that emerges independent of formal instruction about symbolic multiplication. Nonsymbolic multiplication performance mediated the relation between children?s Weber fraction and symbolic math abilities, suggesting a pathway by which the ANS contributes to children?s emerging symbolic math competence. These findings may inform future educational interventions that allow children to use their basic arithmetic intuition as a scaffold to facilitate symbolic math learning. (c) 2021 The Authors. Published by Elsevier Inc. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
1 August 2024 in Journal of Experimental Psychology: General
Number perception emerges from multiple stages of visual processing. Understanding how systematic biases in number perception occur within a hierarchy of increasingly complex feature representations helps uncover the multistage processing underlying our visual number sense. Recent work demonstrated that reducing coherence of low-level visual attributes, such as color and orientation, systematically reduces perceived number. Here, we ask when in the visual processing hierarchy coherence affects numerosity perception and specifically whether the coherence effect is exclusive to low-level visual features or instead whether it can be driven by contextual or semantic relationships. We tested adults in an ordinal numerical comparison task with contextual coherence mathematically manipulated using a statistical model of visual object co-occurrence. Across several experiments, we found that arrays with high contextual coherence were perceived as numerically larger than arrays with low contextual coherence. This contextual coherence effect was not attenuated even when we reduced objects to texforms (unrecognizable images that preserve midlevel visual features) or removed semantic content from the images through box scrambling and diffeomorphic warping. Together, these results suggest that visual coherence derived from natural statistics of object co-occurrence systematically alters perceived numerosity at low-level visual processing, even before later stages at which items can be explicitly categorized and identified. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2024 APA, all rights reserved).
12 June 2024 in Cognition
19 December 2025 in Journal of Numerical Cognition
Understanding how non-numerical visual features systematically distort numerosity perception holds promise for unveiling the processes that give rise to our visual number sense. Recent studies show that increasing visual coherence systematically increases perceived numerosity, with this effect strengthening over development (DeWind et al., 2020; Qu, Bonner, et al., 2024; Qu et al., 2022). Here, we investigate the cognitive mechanisms underlying the coherence illusion from a view of perceptual decision processes. Specifically, we applied a drift diffusion model (DDM) to a previously described dataset from participants aged 5-30 tested in an ordinal numerical comparison task with color entropy systematically manipulated (Qu et al., 2022). By jointly modeling choice data and response times, we decomposed numerical discrimination performance into distinct decision components: the speed of numerical evidence accumulation (drift rate), the amount of evidence required for a decision (boundary separation), and the response bias reflecting a prior tendency of selecting one side over the other. We found that color coherence affected only the drift rate but not response bias or boundary separation, demonstrating that color coherence distorts numerical calculation through biased accumulation of evidence of quantity. Moreover, the impact of coherence on the drift rate coefficient increased with age as quantitative information is accumulated more efficiently over development. Our results offer a framework for understanding how numerical illusions arise from perceptual decision-making dynamics.