Nayha Sethi

Nayha Sethi

Auto-generated profile, based on publicly available information

Nayha Sethi

Usher Institute, University of Edinburgh, United Kingdom

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

11Years (2016-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
21 June 2016 in JMIR Medical Informatics
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
NLNathan Christopher Lea
Nathan Christopher Lea
JNJacqueline Nicholls
Jacqueline Nicholls
CDChristine Dobbs
Christine Dobbs
NSNayha Sethi
Nayha Sethi
JCJames Cunningham
James Cunningham
DKDipak Kalra
Dipak Kalra
In parallel with the advances in big data-driven clinical research, the data safe haven concept has evolved over the last decade. It has led to the development of a framework to support the secure handling of health care information used for clinical research that balances compliance with legal and regulatory controls and ethical requirements while engaging with the public as a partner in its governance. We describe the evolution of 4 separately developed clinical research platforms into services throughout the United Kingdom-wide Farr Institute and their common deployment features in practice. The Farr Institute is a case study from which we propose a common definition of data safe havens as trusted platforms for clinical academic research. We use this common definition to discuss the challenges and dilemmas faced by the clinical academic research community, to help promote a consistent understanding of them and how they might best be handled in practice. We conclude by questioning whether the common definition represents a safe and trustworthy model for conducting clinical research that can stand the test of time and ongoing technical advances while paying heed to evolving public and professional concerns.

3 July 2021 in Javnost - The Public
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
SEStephen Elstub
Stephen Elstub
RTRachel Thompson
Rachel Thompson
OEOliver Escobar
Oliver Escobar
JHJoe Hollinghurst
Joe Hollinghurst
DGDuncan Grimes
Duncan Grimes
NSNayha Sethi
Nayha Sethi
Quality deliberation is essential for societies to address the challenges presented by the coronavirus pandemic effectively and legitimately. Critics of deliberative and participatory democracy are highly skeptical that most citizens can engage with such complex issues in good circumstances and these are far from ideal circumstances. The need for rapid action and decision-making is a challenge for inclusivity and quality of deliberation. Additionally, policy responses to the virus need to be even more co-ordinated than usual, which intensifies their complexity. The digitalisation of the public sphere may be seen as a further challenge to deliberating. Furthermore, these are stressful and emotional times, making a considered judgement on these issues potentially challenging. We employ a modified version of the Discourse Quality Index to assess the deliberative quality in two facilitated synchronous digital platforms to consider aspects of data use in light of COVID 19. Our study is the first to perform a comprehensive, systematic and in-depth analysis of the deliberative capacity of citizens in a pandemic. Our evidence indicates that deliberation can be resilient in a crisis. The findings will have relevance to those interested in pandemic democracy, deliberative democracy in a crisis, data use and digital public spheres.

26 May 2020 in Wellcome Open Research
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
AGAgomoni Ganguli-Mitra
Agomoni Ganguli-Mitra
IYIngrid Young
Ingrid Young
LELukas Engelmann
Lukas Engelmann
IHIan Harper
Ian Harper
DMDonna McCormack
Donna McCormack
MTMarlee Tichenor
Marlee Tichenor
On the 5th of May 2020, a group of modellers, epidemiologists and biomedical scientists from the University of Edinburgh proposed a “segmenting and shielding” approach to easing the lockdown in the UK over the coming months. Their proposal, which has been submitted to the government and since been discussed in the media, offers what appears to be a pragmatic solution out of the current lockdown. The approach identifies segments of the population as at-risk groups and outlines ways in which these remain shielded, while ‘healthy’ segments would be allowed to return to some kind of normality, gradually, over several weeks. This proposal highlights how narrowly conceived scientific responses may result in unintended consequences and repeat harmful public health practices. As an interdisciplinary group of researchers from the humanities and social sciences at the University of Edinburgh, we respond to this proposal and highlight how ethics, history, medical sociology and anthropology - as well as disability studies and decolonial approaches - offer critical engagement with such responses, and call for more creative and inclusive responses to public health crises.

11 July 2023
Verified
Conference Paper
Open access
LHLouise Hatherall
Louise Hatherall
DKDilara Keküllüoğlu
Dilara Keküllüoğlu
NKNadin Kokciyan
Nadin Kokciyan
MRMichael Rovatsos
Michael Rovatsos
NSNayha Sethi
Nayha Sethi
SVShannon Vallor
Shannon Vallor

9 January 2025 in Journal of Responsible Technology
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
LHLouise Hatherall
Louise Hatherall
NSNayha Sethi
Nayha Sethi

31 January 2022
Verified
Book Chapter
Open access
SCSharon Cowan
Sharon Cowan
EPEmily Postan
Emily Postan
NSNayha Sethi
Nayha Sethi
EDEdward S. Dove
Edward S. Dove
NSNiamh Nic Shuibhne
Niamh Nic Shuibhne
Law and Legacy in Medical Jurisprudence - January 2022