1 May 2022 in Psychology, Public Policy, and Law
1 August 2020 in Psychology, Public Policy, and Law
21 January 2023 in Journal of Police and Criminal Psychology
10 January 2020 in Journal of Experimental Criminology
6 January 2020 in Journal of Experimental Criminology
15 November 2025 in Journal of Experimental Criminology
Objectives: We tested the behavioral effects of theoretically coercive plea negotiation scenarios on mock defendant decision-making and perceptions using a novel paradigm. Methods: We conducted an experimental plea negotiation study to address how the theoretically coercive elements of constraints, conditional offers, and conditional threats impact plea decision-making of guilty and innocent defendants. Community member participants ( N = 316) acted as mock defendants and negotiated a plea deal with trained confederate prosecutors and defense attorneys. Results: We found that conditional offers and guilt status significantly increased plea acceptance. Guilty participants were over 16 times more likely to accept a plea than innocent ones. Notably, 32.9% of innocent participants accepted a plea when a conditional offer was present, compared to 5.0% when absent. Conclusions: This research advances our understanding of which plea tactics and elements may place innocent defendants at the greatest risk for involuntary and false guilty pleas.