In this chapter we aim to present two of the main contributions that feminist epistemologies have developed for gendering science. The first is Sandra Harding's ‘standpoint theory’, while the second is Donna Haraway's ‘situated knowledges’. In doing so we will embody both theories in two key figurations which will inspire two lines of flight: Lise Meitner and Lynn Margulis. The aim is twofold: firstly, to explain how women and marginalised subjectivities have always found their strategy of resistance in science; secondly, to demonstrate that the original and innovative contribution of such a non-canonical perspective is crucial in the science-making process.
This chapter examines the impact of neoliberal reforms on universities, focusing on the construction and implications of the concepts of merit and excellence. These reforms, aimed at increasing academic performance and efficiency, shape academic recruitment and career progression. The chapter critiques the supposed neutrality of merit and excellence, highlighting how they often justify inequalities and perpetuate gender biases. Drawing on data from interviews with 68 academics from the University of Turin (UNITO) (Italy) and Jagiellonian University (UJ) (Poland), the chapter explores how merit and excellence are perceived by different genders, career stages, and disciplines (SSH vs. STEM). It examines how these concepts are defined, evaluated and applied in selection and promotion processes, and discusses the challenges and critical perspectives of neoliberal models of academic success. The chapter also explores the gendered implications of these models, particularly in terms of academic recognition and advancement.