We construct an updated extended compilation of distinct (but possibly correlated) redshift space distortion (RSD) data published between 2006 and 2018. It consists of 63 datapoints and is significantly larger than previously used similar data sets. After fiducial model correction we obtain the best fit parameters and show that they are at a tension with the corresponding values. Introducing a nontrivial covariance matrix correlating randomly 20% of the RSD datapoints has no significant effect on the above tension level. We show that the tension disappears (becomes less than ) when a subsample of the 20 most recently published data is used. A partial cause for this reduced tension is the fact that more recent data tend to probe higher redshifts (with higher errorbars) where there is degeneracy among different models due to matter domination. Allowing for a nontrivial evolution of the effective Newton’s constant as ( is a parameter) and fixing a background we find from the full data set while the 20 earliest and 20 latest datapoints imply and respectively. Thus, the more recent data appear to favor GR in contrast to earlier data. Finally, we show that the parametrization provides an excellent fit to the solution of the growth equation for both GR () and modified gravity ().
Phantom dark energy () can produce amplified cosmic acceleration at late times, thus increasing the value of favored by CMB data and releasing the tension with local measurements of . We show that the best fit value of in the context of the CMB power spectrum is degenerate with a constant equation-of-state parameter , in accordance with the approximate effective linear equation ( in ). This equation is derived by assuming that both and remain constant (for an invariant CMB spectrum) and equal to their best fit Planck/ values as , , and vary. For , this linear degeneracy equation leads to the best fit as expected. For , the corresponding predicted CMB best fit Hubble constant is , which is identical with the value obtained by local-distance ladder measurements, while the best fit matter density parameter is predicted to decrease, since is fixed. We verify the above degeneracy equation by fitting a model with fixed values of to the Planck TT spectrum, showing also that the quality of fit () is similar to that of . However, when including SnIa, baryon acoustic oscillation, or growth data, the quality of fit becomes worse than when . Finally, we generalize the degeneracy equation for the parametrization and identify analytically the full parameter region (straight line) that leads to a best fit in the context of the Planck CMB spectrum. This exploitation of degeneracy can lead to immediate identification of all parameter values of a given parametrization that can potentially resolve the tension.
A rapid phantom transition of the dark energy equation of state parameter at a transition redshift of the form with can lead to a higher value of the Hubble constant while closely mimicking a form of the comoving distance for . Such a transition however would imply a significantly lower value of the SnIa absolute magnitude than the value imposed by local Cepheid calibrators at . Thus, in order to resolve the tension it would need to be accompanied by a similar transition in the value of the SnIa absolute magnitude as with . This is a late phantom transition (). It may be achieved by a sudden reduction of the value of the normalized effective Newton constant by about 6% assuming that the absolute luminosity of SnIa is proportional to the Chandrasekhar mass which varies as . We demonstrate that such an ultra low abrupt feature of provides a better fit to cosmological data compared to smooth late time deformations of that also address the Hubble tension. For we find , . This model also addresses the growth tension due to the predicted lower value of at . A prior of (no transition) can still resolve the tension with a larger amplitude transition with at . This implies a larger reduction of for (about 12%). The can be generically induced by a scalar field nonminimally coupled to gravity with no need of a screening mechanism since in this model at .
A redshift tomography of the Pantheon type Ia supernovae (SnIa) data focusing on the best fit value of the absolute magnitude and/or Hubble constant in the context of indicates a local variation () at level, with respect to the best fit of the full dataset. If this variation is not due to a statistical fluctuation, it can be interpreted as a locally higher value of by about 2%, corresponding to a local matter underdensity . It can also be interpreted as a time variation of Newton’s constant which implies an evolving Chandrasekhar mass and thus an evolving absolute luminosity and absolute magnitude of low SnIa. The local void scenario would predict a degree of anisotropy in the best fit value of since it is unlikely that we are located at the center of a local spherical underdensity. Using a hemisphere comparison method, we find an anisotropy level that is consistent with simulated isotropic Pantheon-like datasets. We show however, that the anisotropic sky distribution of the Pantheon SnIa data induces a preferred range of directions even in simulated Pantheon data obtained in the context of isotropic . We thus construct a more isotropically distributed subset of the Pantheon SnIa and show that the preferred range of directions disappears. Using this more isotropically distributed subset we again find no evidence for statistically significant anisotropy using either the hemisphere comparison method or the dipole fit method. In the context of the modified gravity scenario, we allow for an evolving normalized Newton’s constant consistent with general relativity (GR) at early and late times and fit for the parameter assuming . For indicated by some previous studies we find which is more than away from the GR value of . This weak hint for weaker gravity at low coming from SnIa is consistent with similar evidence from growth and weak lensing cosmological data.
Gravitational transitions at low redshifts () have been recently proposed as a solution to the Hubble and growth tensions. Such transitions would naturally lead to a transition in the absolute magnitude of type Ia supernovae (SNIa) at (late transitions—) and possibly in the dark energy equation of state parameter (late transitions). Here, we compare the quality of fit of this class of models to cosmological data, with the corresponding quality of fit of the cosmological constant model () and some of the best smooth deformation models [ (cold dark matter), Chevallier-Polarski-Linder, phenomenologically emergent dark energy]. We also perform model selection via the Akaike information criterion (AIC) and the Bayes factor. We use the full cosmic microwave background temperature anisotropy spectrum data, the baryon acoustic oscillations data, the Pantheon SNIa data, the SNIa absolute magnitude as determined by Cepheid calibrators and the value of the Hubble constant as determined by local SNIa calibrated using Cepheids. We find that smooth deformation models perform worse than transition models for the following reasons: (1) they have a worse fit to low- geometric probes (baryon acoustic oscillations and SNIa data); (2) they favor values of the SNIa absolute magnitude that are lower as compared to the value obtained with local Cepheid calibrators at ; (3) They tend to worsen the growth tension. We also find that the transition model does not provide a better quality of fit to cosmological data than a pure transition model (), where is fixed to the value at all redshifts. We conclude that the model has significant statistical advantages over smooth late-time deformation models in addressing the Hubble crisis.
2 May 2022 in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
We study a parametrization of the deceleration parameter in a tilted universe, namely a cosmological model equipped with two families of observers. The first family follows the smooth Hubble flow, while the second is the real observers residing in a typical galaxy inside a bulk flow and moving relative to the smooth Hubble expansion with finite peculiar velocity. We use the compilation of Type Ia supernovae (SNe Ia) data, as described in the Pantheon data set, to find the quality of fit to the data and study the redshift evolution of the deceleration parameter. In so doing, we consider two alternative scenarios, assuming that the bulk-flow observers live in the ΛCDM and in the Einstein-de Sitter universe. We show that a tilted Einstein-de Sitter model can reproduce the recent acceleration history of the universe, without the need of a cosmological constant or dark energy, by simply taking into account linear effects of peculiar motions. By means of a Markov chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) method, we also constrain the magnitude and the uncertainties of the parameters of the two models. From our statistical analysis, we find that the tilted Einstein-de Sitter model, equipped with one or two additional parameters that describe the assumed large-scale velocity flows, performs similar to the standard ΛCDM paradigm in the context of model selection criteria (Akaike information criterion and Bayesian information criterion).