Scholars have explained many of the differences within the American Catholic population in terms of political division or polarization. Although Catholics are becoming increasingly politically bifurcated, to focus only on the political misses the specifically religious differences that also distinguish Catholics from one another. There have been substantial changes in the staffing of Catholic campus ministry in the last 20 years. To better understand these shifts and their implications for ministry, the Catholic bishops commissioned a survey of Catholic campus ministers in the United States. The survey answered some questions but raised others. A qualitative study that more deeply explored these questions was recommended. Using three “windows”—vocation, prayer and spirituality, and mission—this article explores the overlap and differences in frames of Catholicity among two types of Catholic campus ministers. Forty-five campus ministers from three geographic regions of the country were interviewed. Ten of these forty-five interviewees are “missionaries,” meaning they are recent college graduates who have obtained a several-week training from their missionary organization and are contracted to serve as a campus missionary for two years. Thirty-one of these are “professional ministers,” meaning they have a graduate degree in ministry and intend to have a long-term career in this field. Missionaries’ understandings of vocation, prayer and spirituality, and mission reveal that missionary-formed campus ministers operate out of a frame that emphasizes an individualist Catholicism. The professional ministers employ a frame that amplifies the communal aspects of Catholicism. These findings contribute theoretically to ideas in the framing literature, specifically in the fields of politics, emotions and identity. The way these frames might have an impact on ministry offerings and student formation are also discussed.
Background: Limited information exists on whether virtual training is equivalent to traditional in-person training in supporting the development of clinical providers. Methods: A multi-site evaluation using survey methods was conducted with a multidisciplinary group of health professions trainees and supervisors within the Veterans Health Administration to assess the equivalence of two supervision modalities – exclusively in-person supervision and supervision incorporating at least some virtual supervision – on trainee clinical competency development, trainee preparedness to respond to patient emergencies, and effective trainee/supervisor working relationships. Results: Trainees who experienced some virtual supervision rated their clinical competency levels as higher than trainees with only in-person supervision on competencies related to patient care, knowledge for practice, interpersonal and communication skills, practice-based learning and improvement, and systems-based practice. This trainee group also rated their level of preparation to respond to patient emergencies and several aspects of their supervisory working relationship more highly than in-person only trainees. Compared to those providing only in-person supervision, supervisors conducting some virtual supervision also rated their trainees as having higher levels of clinical competency on patient care, practice-based learning and improvement, and systems-based practice, as well as higher preparedness to respond to patient emergencies. Challenges and benefits to virtual supervision were also noted, though most trainees and supervisors who had participated in virtual supervision held a positive view of this modality. Conclusions: These data constitute the first evaluation of the equivalency of some virtual and in-person only supervision in supporting trainee skill development and supervisory working relationships based on feedback from trainees and supervisors across multiple clinical disciplines. Trial registration: Not applicable.
25 September 2025 in Journal of Medical Education and Curricular Development
Objectives: The COVID-19 pandemic led to a rapid adoption of telehealth technologies, particularly in terms of treatment delivery and trainee education. Prior work has found that virtual training (in which supervisors and trainees are not co-located and interact via virtual communication platforms) is well-received and supports effective supervisor/trainee working relationships. However, there is limited assessment of the effectiveness of virtual training in supporting clinical skill development or working relationships. Given the growing adoption of telehealth in health professional education, an evaluation was conducted in collaboration with the Clinical Resource Hubs (CRH), a national telehealth program within the Veterans Health Administration (VHA) offering clinical training opportunities within a virtual work environment. Methods: Survey instruments were developed and administered to CRH trainees and supervisors. Information was collected related to trainee and supervisor demographics, CRH training experiences, perceived quality of training and supervision, supervisor/trainee relationships, and perspectives on virtual training. Results: Trainees and supervisors perceived virtual supervisor/trainee interactions to be equivalent or superior to in-person interactions in supporting the development of clinical competencies and experienced effective supervisory working relationships in a virtual environment. Trainees and supervisors differed in their preferences for virtual versus in-person training and views on the ideal combination of these modalities to support skill development. Conclusion: Results suggest that virtual supervisor/trainee interactions can effectively support trainee clinical skill development and effective supervisor/trainee relationships. For many aspects of training, virtual training for health profession trainees within large healthcare settings can provide an effective experience that is an acceptable and viable alternative to in-person training.
1 September 2017 in Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion
Background: The US Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) has prioritized efforts to understand the influence of COVID-19 on VA clinicians and the overall VA system of care. Given the importance of health professions trainee (HPT) contributions to clinical and research activities, it is important to understand HPT contributions to VA’s work during the COVID-19 pandemic. Objective: This study evaluated the influence of the COVID-19 pandemic on VA HPTs and the contributions of HPTs to VA’s pandemic response. Design: Across selected VA sites, semi-structured interviews were used to gather perspectives from three participant groups: (1) HPTs across three disciplines at different levels of training, (2) service chiefs representing the disciplines in which the HPTs received training, and (3) educational leadership. Interviews were conducted in 2021. Participants: Stratified sampling was used to identify 10 VA medical sites, from which 83 participants were purposefully sampled. Approach: Descriptive content analysis was used to iteratively analyze collected data. Key Results: HPTs reported decreased learning opportunities and increased safety concerns related to COVID-19 during their training placements. HPTs were seen as providing important contributions to multiple aspects of VA’s efforts to respond to challenges related to COVID-19, including providing needed clinical care, supporting VA’s shift to telehealth, providing informational and emotional support to Veterans, helping with COVID planning and decision-making, and fostering a positive work environment. Conclusions: Although COVID-19 presented limitations to HPT involvement in VA activities, HPTs made meaningful contributions to care delivery and brought skills to support VA’s transition to virtual care delivery. HPTs are an important group to be included in future emergency response planning within VA. NIH Trial Registry Number: Not applicable.