1 January 2015 in Energy and Buildings
31 March 2016 in Building Research & Information
What are the patterns and influences on the lifespan of the building stock? This paper presents (1) the reconstitution of an urban building stock composed of more than 60 000 buildings, (2) the analysis of the development of this stock over a period of 180 years (constructions and demolitions), and (3) the analysis of building mortality patterns and reasons for demolition resulting from historic decisions and regimes. A method to reconstitute the stock from different data sources is presented. The mortality models take into account not only the present demolition rates and the age distribution of the ‘survivors' but also the disappeared buildings. The main results are new insights into the lifespan behaviour of buildings according to their period of construction (cohorts) as well as the reasons for demolition. The demolitions do not show specific explanation patterns, but changing influences of the construction activities over time. The average demolition age of all buildings in Zurich, Switzerland, decreased from over 200 years to fewer than 70 years. A total of 18 000 buildings have been demolished over the 180-year period. The presented methods and results can be integrated in multidimensional geographical information systems (GIS) as comprehensive planning, scenario and regulatory tools.
31 March 2016 in Building Research & Information
Research is presented on the estimation of the lifespan of cohorts of buildings and building stocks. This is based on the analysis of extensive longitudinal data of the 55 000 buildings in the City of Zurich from 1832 and 2010. The survival probability from different perspectives considers age, construction periods, and demolition periods for both existing and demolished buildings. Survival probability is established using a Kaplan–Meier estimator. A more in-depth approach to the mortality of buildings is then determined by differentiating building age, use, size and geographical situation (district). The use of a common geographical information system (GIS) allows longitudinal building data to be linked to a geographical hierarchy of three levels of analysis (city, district and building) accounting for the different granularity on each level (neighbourhoods, quarters, building parts). A comparison of the two methods indicates that the choice of the observed time periods can lead to very different results. The analysis of the three levels shows the possibilities and limits of combined statistical and historical approaches. Mortality analysis is a promising approach to inform policy and practice; it could become a new link between long-term scenario planning, construction policies and institutional regimes.
4 May 2022 in Disability & Society
Erythropoietic protoporphyria (EPP) is an ultra-rare genetic disorder characterised by intolerance to visible light. Starting in early childhood, people with EPP suffer from social isolation, impaired educational and occupational opportunities, and low quality of life. Afamelanotide is the only effective and approved therapy for EPP. In England, its cost-effectiveness is currently assessed by the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE), which in 2018 issued a negative recommendation for funding. Stakeholder organisations, including our patient organisation, submitted appeals against the recommendation, which were upheld in all possible grounds. Moreover, the appeal panel expressed concerns about whether the evaluating committee discriminated against people with EPP and suggested that it seek guidance regarding the Equality Act 2010. However, three years later, the identified issues have not been addressed and patients in England remain without treatment. Afamelanotide represents another example for the trend towards a loss of fairness in NICE decisions.