Social workers are considered key members of community mental health teams, yet difficulties in interprofessional collaboration between social workers and health care professionals, particularly psychiatrists and nurses, have been reported. This paper examines some sources of these difficulties in terms of perceived differences in models of mental illness, attitudes and values, including stereotyping, professional identification and role clarity. Interprofessional education (IPE) may diminish negative stereotypes and promote multidisciplinary teamwork. A theoretical framework is described and findings from the evaluation of a 1-year programme of interprofessional education for community mental health are presented. These findings suggest that attitudes and values concerning community care for people with mental health problems are largely shared by different professions, but they do confirm the existence of interprofessional stereotypes and of perceived status differences. In contrast to previous research, there was no evidence of changes in stereotypes. These findings are discussed in terms of the theoretical framework and the design of the programme.
1 October 2011 in The British Journal of Social Work
There are long-standing concerns in many developed countries about high workforce turnover within social work and the associated negative impact on service users and agencies. While much research has focused on establishing the antecedents to turnover and retention, less attention has been given to establishing the effectiveness of interventions designed to reduce undesirable turnover. A systematic review of research in social work, teaching and nursing identified and appraised the evidence. Of the 699 unique references identified, fifteen studies were included in this review (all but one from the USA); the lack of consistency in definitions and outcome measurement precluded meta-analysis, but twelve studies were deemed to be of sufficient quality for narrative synthesis. In general, interventions addressing organisational and administrative factors (rather than individual employee factors) produced stronger effects, reinforcing current policies in England and previous research into the determinants of turnover.
1 December 2003 in The British Journal of Social Work
This study investigated the relationships between the organization of community mental health services and professional and team identification, team functioning and the psychological well-being and job satisfaction of staff working in multidisciplinary community mental health teams (CMHTs). Staff in four districts in the North of England completed anonymous questionnaires on two occasions, twelve months apart. There were systematic differences in team functioning, favouring teams in districts where mental health and social care services were integrated. However, service organization had no evident impact on professional or team identification or on outcomes for staff in terms of stress or job satisfaction. There were differences between social workers (n = 31) and health service professionals (n = 82) indicating that social workers had poorer perceptions of team functioning and experienced higher levels of role conflict. Controlling for other factors including the study districts, role conflict was a significant predictor of stress and of job dissatisfaction, while role clarity promoted job satisfaction. We conclude that support and supervision aimed at ensuring a social work contribution to multidisciplinary working should be provided in the course of establishing CMHTs and integrated health and social care services.
This review considers how the outcomes of social work education can be identified with reference to Kirkpatrick's framework of levels of outcomes and Kraiger et al.’s general model of learning outcomes. It presents examples of different approaches to the measurement of outcomes and to the use of research designs in social work education and interprofessional education involving social workers and social work students. These examples are drawn from a search of the English language literature (1997–2010). Three-quarters of the studies (23 out of 31) found measured changes in attitudes and/or knowledge and skills only. Seven measured changes in social workers’ behaviour and only one measured the impact on service users’ lives. Three-quarters employed pre–post one group designs. The advantages and disadvantages of alternative research designs are discussed. Finally some practicalities regarding the development of an outcomes-based culture in university-based education are considered.
19 June 2013 in The British Journal of Social Work
A measure of self-efficacy was used to assess the development of competence and confidence for participants in a one-year national programme of supervision and support for newly qualified child and family social workers (NQSWs) in England. The study also explored the associations between self-efficacy, demographic variables and role clarity, role conflict, job satisfaction and stress. Method: A longitudinal repeated measures design with three cohorts of NQSWs participating in the programme (2008–12) (N = 2,019); in 2008–09, comparison was made with a ‘contrast group’ of NQSWs (N = 47) in non-participating agencies. Findings: Self-efficacy ratings showed substantial and statistically significant increases between the beginning and end of the programme for all three cohorts. The proportion of ‘confident’ NQSWs increased from a half to three-quarters of respondents. However, interim retrospective ratings indicated overestimation of self-efficacy at baseline. Self-efficacy ratings at the end of the year favoured the programme group versus the contrast group. High self-efficacy was predicted statistically by age, role clarity and intrinsic (but not extrinsic) job satisfaction. It was unexpectedly associated with high role conflict and was not related to stress. Findings supported a developmental process model for the accumulation of professional expertise. Implications: An Assessed and Supported Year in Employment (ASYE) based on the programme has been established for all NQSWs in England.