Chair of Public Health and Health Services Research, Institute for Medical Information Processing, Biometry, and Epidemiology (IBE), Faculty of Medicine, LMU Munich, Munich, Germany
Auto-generated profile, based on publicly available information
Julia Bauer
Chair of Public Health and Health Services Research, Institute for Medical Information Processing, Biometry, and Epidemiology (IBE), Faculty of Medicine, LMU Munich, Munich, Germany
Background: Logic models are valuable tools when evaluating complex interventions in public health. They can improve the understanding of how an intervention works and interacts with its system, and facilitate clear communication regarding the intervention with stakeholders. There are different approaches to developing logic models. However, experiences with logic model development in practice, and the advantages or challenges associated with different approaches are rarely reported. This study describes and reflects on the staged development process of a logic model for the municipal public health intervention Präventionskette Freiham in Munich, Germany. Specifically, we aim to identify advantages and challenges associated with this process, and deduce lessons learnt for staged logic model development and logic model development in general. Methods: For the staged logic model development process, a first draft of the logic model was developed at the start of the evaluation. We then defined a priori milestones at which the model was to be revised. It was revisited and updated: (i) after the process evaluation, (ii) after a workshop with stakeholders, and (iii) at the end of preparations for long-term outcome evaluation. We discussed the advantages and challenges associated with the staged development process in a workshop within the research team, and obtained feedback on the usefulness of the logic model during a workshop with municipal stakeholders. Results: The logic model changed in multiple aspects during the different stages of development, mostly due to evidence obtained during the evaluation and as a result of feedback from discussions within the research team and with stakeholders. In the workshop with the research team, we found the staged process to be useful for facilitating reflection, for increasing plannability of logic model development, for integrating multiple perspectives and for increasing the validity of the logic model. Challenges were the need for rigorous documentation and flexibility in the process, as well as the management of resources. In the stakeholder workshop on the usefulness of the logic model, participants stated that the graphical visualization made it easier to handle complexity, and wished for the logic model to be re-used for future interventions. Conclusions: Developing a logic model in a staged process over the course of the evaluation of an intervention is a useful approach for stimulating reflection and obtaining a more realistic depiction of the intervention.
Background: Reducing health inequities for children from a disadvantaged background is an important task in public health. While intersectoral partnerships are a promising way to achieve this, few studies have examined the factors influencing the success of these interventions. In this study, we conducted a process evaluation of the integrated community-based intervention Präventionskette Freiham that the city of Munich, Germany, has implemented in a new residential development area. The aim was to investigate the implementation process as well as barriers and facilitators. Methods: Following a mixed methods approach, we collected data from different core groups making up Präventionskette Freiham from April 2020 to August 2022, exploring their perspective on the implementation process. We conducted repeated qualitative interviews with the network coordinators and eleven local professionals from institutions engaged with or relevant for the intervention. We also undertook a focus group with four members of the advisory group representing the three municipal departments guiding the intervention. Ego-centered network maps were drawn by the network coordinators to chart the development of the network. Subsequently, we also conducted an online survey with local network members. Results: At the early stage of the implementation process, the intervention was able to integrate actors from different sectors, serving as a platform for mutual exchange. However, the network produced limited output. According to the interviews, this may be mainly attributable to the early development status of the area. We identified seven topics that may act as facilitators or barriers to implementation of Präventionskette Freiham: (1) availability of resources, (2) political and administrative support, (3) the network coordinators, (4) network-internal processes, (5) trans-institutional cooperation, (6) perceived benefits of engagement, and (7) the output of the network. Conclusions: The early development status of the area was a challenge for the intervention. This emphasizes the need to carefully consider context when planning and implementing integrated community-based public health interventions in new residential development areas.
Worldwide, the number and proportion of people living in cities continue to grow. Building new districts creates opportunities for designing urban environments that promote the health of their residents from the get-go. In this study, we used the photovoice methodology to explore the perspectives of adolescents on health and well-being in a new urban development area in Munich, Germany. Eleven adolescents aged 13-19 years were recruited in the new residential development area of Freiham on the Southwestern outskirts of Munich. Participants were given ten days to take photographs in the study area, focusing on objects or sceneries they considered to be important for their health. We then conducted qualitative interviews related to these photographs. Interviews were transcribed verbatim and analyzed using thematic analysis. We identified eight recurring themes: emotional well-being, meeting peers, being physically active, growing as a person, safety, waste, development of the urban environment, aesthetics of the urban environment. Adolescents highlighted aspects of mental and social health when assessing the urban environment. Interacting with other young people was an important reason for our participants to visit public places. Public health professionals and urban planners should consider the specific needs of this age group when building new urban areas, and especially provide safe and clean public spaces that adolescents can use for recreation and social interactions.