21 June 2014 in Journal of Archaeological Method and Theory
24 January 2013 in Journal of Archaeological Research
1 February 2015 in Cambridge Archaeological Journal
André Leroi-Gourhan's work is usually considered a paradigmatic example of the application of structuralist ideas to the study of Palaeolithic art. The association between Leroi-Gourhan and structuralism is, however, problematic. Leroi-Gourhan explicitly distinguished his approach from that of Lévi-Strauss. Furthermore, he developed an explanatory model for the analysis of cave and portable art based on a number of postulates that were not necessarily connected to structuralism. We examine Leroi-Gourhan's understanding of Palaeolithic art in order to determine the influence of structuralism upon his work. This examination will help us to consider some alternative perspectives on the so-called structural analysis of Palaeolithic art. Moreover, Leroi-Gourhan's case will allow us to reflect on how archaeologists appropriate theory from other disciplines and how intellectual production in archaeology works.
8 July 2020 in Journal of Archaeological Method and Theory
1 September 2012 in World Art
MMManuel R. González Morales
Manuel R. González Morales
This article examines the impact of ‘naturalism’ upon the understanding of Paleolithic cave art during the last 150 years. In art history, the term ‘naturalism’ is commonly used to define the mode of representation seeking to imitate nature as faithfully and truthfully as possible. This ‘naturalistic’ ideal influenced traditional interpretations of cave images in a number of fundamental ways. In particular, during the greater part of the twentieth century, archaeologists, anthropologists and art historians focused on ‘realistic’ representations and overlooked ‘non-naturalistic’ images. This ‘naturalistic’ interpretation of cave images remained unchallenged until the last 30 years, when the favored position of realistic images has been questioned by a number of theoretical and empirical developments.
19 August 2010 in History of the Human Sciences
Considering the case of Juan de Vilanova y Piera, often celebrated as the first scientist to accept the prehistoric antiquity of palaeolithic paintings, we explore some of the problems related to the concept of ‘precursor’ in the field of the history of science. In the first section, we propose a brief history of this notion focusing on those authors who have reflected critically on the meaning of predecessors. In the second section, the example of Vilanova illustrates the ways in which historians of science have created precursors. From the vantage of modern science, precursors have traditionally been defined as those who first indicated or announced ideas or theories later accepted by the scientific community. As a result, they have been represented as ‘heroes’ struggling hard to defeat the ignorance of their time. As the case of Juan de Vilanova illustrates, this traditional view is unsatisfactory in many ways. For this reason we consider in the third section a number of methodological strategies to promote a more adequate approach to pioneers. In particular, we suggest that the best way to surmount hagiographical approaches to past scientists is to put them in their own intellectual and historical contexts.