This study explored an innovative coaching model termed video-based online video coaching. The innovation builds from affordances of robot-enabled videorecording of lessons, accompanied by built-in uploading and annotation features. While in-person coaching has proven effective for providing sustained support for teachers to take up challenging instructional practices, there are constraints. Both logistical and human capacity constraints make in-person coaching difficult to implement, particularly in rural contexts. As part of an NSF-funded project, we studied nine mathematics coaches over four years as they engaged in video-based coaching with teachers from geographically distant, rural contexts. We adapted a content-focused coaching model that involved a collaborative plan-teach-reflection cycle with synchronous and asynchronous components. The planning and debriefing sessions were done synchronously via Zoom, while the teaching and initial video reflection on teaching via annotations were done asynchronously. We focused on the coaches’ practices in each part of the coaching cycle by analyzing interviews, surveys, annotations of the video, and transcripts of the planning and debriefing sessions. We found that: features of the online environment enabled the coach-teacher pairs to collaboratively discuss the mathematics and how students engaged with the mathematics; the coach used video and annotations to help teachers reflect on specific aspects of their practice; and the coach-teacher pairs formed trusting and productive relationships despite not having met in-person during the duration of their work together. Our findings showed that the online platform is not only an effective implementation for coaching, but also affords new opportunities for teacher reflection and evidence-based discussions.
We explored how three coaches following a content-focused-coaching [CFC] model conducted lesson planning meetings with teachers. We used the lens of obligations to study how the coaches navigated two obligations central to the CFC model. The first obligation, the instrumental obligation, refers to the obligation to produce a lesson plan, which we attribute to the institutional and personal obligations described by Herbst and Chazan (ZDM 44:601–12, 2012). The second obligation, the learning obligation, refers to the obligation to push teachers’ thinking with respect to learning disciplinary content, which we attribute to disciplinary and interpersonal obligations described by Herbst and Chazan (ZDM 44:601–12, 2012). We studied the interplay between these two obligations, with a particular emphasis on how this interplay influenced how the participants resolved divergent perspectives that emerged during the planning conversations. We used a collective case study Stake (in: Denzin (ed) Handbook of qualitative research. Sage, 2000) of three coaches who were involved in a larger project; the three cases were selected due to the relatively strong emphasis on the learning obligation. The implications of our study are that coaches following the CFC model should anticipate which divergent perspectives are likely to emerge and make tentative plans for how to address them in the conversation.