Purpose: This research centers on islander crisis experiences, unveiling five interconnected layers of water injustice, each contributing to the systemic vulnerabilities. Design/methodology/approach: Qualitative analysis of interviews, field observations and reviews of official reports from 2016–2023 conducted under an expedited review approved by the Institutional Review Board. The research adopts a political ecology approach, incorporating a layered analysis of the intersection of water justice, technological advancements and social inequalities. Findings: Desalination in San Andrés exacerbates existing social inequalities, creating multiple layers of water injustice. These injustices include the prioritization of water for tourism, spatial inequities in plant locations, lack of community participation in water management, marginalization of traditional water practices and disparities in water quality and access. Research limitations/implications: The focus on San Andrés Island may not fully represent the diversity of water crises and justice issues in other regions. Future research should include comparative studies across multiple islands and use multiple methods for a more comprehensive understanding of water injustices. Practical implications: A decentralized desalination management approach and inclusive water management practices are necessary. Social implications: Recognizing the socio-political dynamics hindering their water access underscores corporate social responsibility in managing environmental issues, especially in tourism-driven economies. Originality/value: The research offers a comprehensive analysis of the multi-layered injustices in desalted water management on San Andrés Island that intersect and reinforce one another, creating a cyclical pattern that amplifies vulnerabilities over time. It exemplifies emerging realities of water scarcity in a technological era.
1 May 2026 in International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction
Climate Change (CC) is a global phenomenon with differentiated impacts. Its effects are felt in marine and terrestrial ecosystems and organisms, and in the most vulnerable economies and societies. CC is altering the ocean’s chemistry, initiating cascading socioenvironmental impacts. The fisheries sector is the most affected. In the Western Caribbean’s Archipelago of San Andrés, Providencia, and Santa Catalina, identified as having the highest climatic risk, these impacts are pronounced. This study comprehensively reviews existing knowledge on climate change effects on fishery resources and incorporates fishers’ perceptions through two rounds of surveys in 2019 and 2022. The findings reveal significant consequences for fishery resources, including alterations in biological properties and species distribution, loss of critical coastal fish breeding habitats, reduced fisheries productivity, and increased local and cross-border conflicts over fish resources. Especially, after the destructive impact of Hurricane Iota (2020), fishers shifted their hazard perception, elevating hurricanes as a significant threat alongside drought. These evolving perceptions emphasize the need for comprehensive policy strategies to address multiple hazards and their interactions, aligning with fishers’ priorities and enhancing the resilience of the fishing sector. This research underscores the urgency of ecosystem-based and co-management policies, alternatives for artisanal fishers, and heightened climate risk perception.
Storm surge is one of the most destructive coastal hazards associated with tropical cyclones, yet detailed assessments remain scarce for small Caribbean islands. This study assesses hurricane storm surge flood risk in the Archipelago of San Andrés, Providencia, and Santa Catalina, Colombia, under near-past climate conditions (1980-2010) for 100- and 500-year return periods. Storm surge was simulated from a synthetic tropical cyclone dataset of 1,078 tracks; a composite risk index was then constructed by combining the hazard with a vulnerability index based on elevation, proximity to drainage and coastline, land-use, and population density. Exposed elements were identified and classified as residential, economic, functional, or ecological. Under the 500-year return period, risk affects 3.7% of San Andrés (247 elements; 178.9 ha) and 3.3% of Providencia and Santa Catalina (185 elements; 36.9 ha), with risk concentrated along the eastern and northeastern coast of San Andrés and the northern coast and inter-island isthmus of Providencia and Santa Catalina. Economic and residential elements dominate exposed assets by count (49.8% and 38.1% in San Andrés), while ecological elements, predominantly mangroves, dominate by area (89.1% in San Andrés; 80.1% in Providencia and Santa Catalina) and account for 95% of the high-risk area in Providencia and Santa Catalina. Block-level outputs (50 and 57 affected city blocks, respectively) can support coastal and the land-use planning in defining setback zones and prioritizing mangrove restoration. This study highlights the need for integrated coastal management that link community, technical modeling, spatial planning, and ecosystem preservation.
Storm surge is one of the most destructive coastal hazards associated with tropical cyclones, yet detailed assessments remain scarce for small Caribbean islands. This study assesses hurricane storm surge flood risk in the Archipelago of San Andrés, Providencia, and Santa Catalina, Colombia, under near-past climate conditions (1980-2010) for 100- and 500-year return periods. Storm surge was simulated from a synthetic tropical cyclone dataset of 1,078 tracks; a composite risk index was then constructed by combining the hazard with a vulnerability index based on elevation, proximity to drainage and coastline, land-use, and population density. Exposed elements were identified and classified as residential, economic, functional, or ecological. Under the 500-year return period, risk affects 3.7% of San Andrés (247 elements; 178.9 ha) and 3.3% of Providencia and Santa Catalina (185 elements; 36.9 ha), with risk concentrated along the eastern and northeastern coast of San Andrés and the northern coast and inter-island isthmus of Providencia and Santa Catalina. Economic and residential elements dominate exposed assets by count (49.8% and 38.1% in San Andrés), while ecological elements, predominantly mangroves, dominate by area (89.1% in San Andrés; 80.1% in Providencia and Santa Catalina) and account for 95% of the high-risk area in Providencia and Santa Catalina. Block-level outputs (50 and 57 affected city blocks, respectively) can support coastal and the land-use planning in defining setback zones and prioritizing mangrove restoration. This study highlights the need for integrated coastal management that link community, technical modeling, spatial planning, and ecosystem preservation.