Annabel Crum

Annabel Crum

Auto-generated profile, based on publicly available information

Annabel Crum

School of Health and Related Research, University of Sheffield, Sheffield, UK

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

9Years (2018-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
1 May 2018 in Health Services and Delivery Research
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
AOAlicia O’cAthain
Alicia O’cAthain
EKEmma Knowles
Emma Knowles
LBLindsey Bishop-Edwards
Lindsey Bishop-Edwards
JCJoanne Coster
Joanne Coster
ACAnnabel Crum
Annabel Crum
JWJulia Williams
Julia Williams
Background: In England in 2015/16, ambulance services responded to nearly 11 million calls. Ambulance Quality Indicators show that half of the patients receiving a response by telephone or face to face were not conveyed to an emergency department. A total of 11% of patients received telephone advice only. A total of 38% of patients were sent an ambulance but were not conveyed to an emergency department. For the 10 large ambulance services in England, rates of calls ending in telephone advice varied between 5% and 17%. Rates of patients who were sent an ambulance but not conveyed to an emergency department varied between 23% and 51%. Overall non-conveyance rates varied between 40% and 68%.Objective: To explain variation in non-conveyance rates between ambulance services.Design: A sequential mixed methods study with five work packages.Setting: Ten of the 11 ambulance services serving > 99% of the population of England.Methods: (1) A qualitative interview study of managers and paramedics from each ambulance service, as well as ambulance commissioners (totalling 49 interviews undertaken in 2015). (2) An analysis of 1 month of routine data from each ambulance service (November 2014). (3) A qualitative study in three ambulance services with different published rates of calls ending in telephone advice (120 hours of observation and 20 interviews undertaken in 2016). (4) An analysis of routine data from one ambulance service linked to emergency department attendance, hospital admission and mortality data (6 months of 2013). (5) A substudy of non-conveyance for people calling 999 with breathing problems.Results: Interviewees in the qualitative study identified factors that they perceived to affect non-conveyance rates. Where possible, these perceptions were tested using routine data. Some variation in non-conveyance rates between ambulance services was likely to be due to differences in the way rates were calculated by individual services, particularly in relation to telephone advice. Rates for the number of patients sent an ambulance but not conveyed to an emergency department were associated with patient-level factors: age, sex, deprivation, time of call, reason for call, urgency level and skill level of attending crew. However, variation between ambulance services remained after adjustment for patient-level factors. Variation was explained by ambulance service-level factors after adjustment for patient-level factors: the percentage of calls attended by advanced paramedics [odds ratio 1.05, 95% confidence interval (CI) 1.04 to 1.07], the perception of ambulance service staff and commissioners that advanced paramedics were established and valued within the workforce of an ambulance service (odds ratio 1.84, 95% CI 1.45 to 2.33), and the perception of ambulance service staff and commissioners that senior management was risk averse regarding non-conveyance within an ambulance service (odds ratio 0.78, 95% CI 0.63 to 0.98).Limitations: Routine data from ambulance services are complex and not consistently collected or analysed by ambulance services, thus limiting the utility of comparative analyses.Conclusions: Variation in non-conveyance rates between ambulance services in England could be reduced by addressing variation in the types of paramedics attending calls, variation in how advanced paramedics are used and variation in perceptions of the risk associated with non-conveyance within ambulance service management. Linking routine ambulance data with emergency department attendance, hospital admission and mortality data for all ambulance services in the UK would allow comparison of the safety and appropriateness of their different non-conveyance rates.Funding: The National Institute for Health Research Health Services and Delivery Research programme.

7 January 2019 in Prehospital Emergency Care
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
JCJoanne Coster
Joanne Coster
AOAlicia O'CAthain
Alicia O'CAthain
RJRichard Jacques
Richard Jacques
ACAnnabel Crum
Annabel Crum
ASA. Niroshan Siriwardena
A. Niroshan Siriwardena
JTJanette Turner
Janette Turner
Objectives Emergency ambulance services do not transport all patients to hospital. International literature reports non-transport rates ranging from 3.7%-93.7%. In 2017, 38% of the 11 million calls received by ambulance services in England were attended by ambulance but not transported to an Emergency Department (ED). A further 10% received clinical advice over the telephone. Little is known about what happens to patients following a non-transport decision. We aimed to investigate what happens to patients following an emergency ambulance telephone call that resulted in a non-transport decision, using a linked routine data-set. Methods Six-months individual patient level data from one ambulance service in England, linked with Hospital Episode Statistics and national mortality data, were used to identify subsequent health events (ambulance re-contact, ED attendance, hospital admission, death) within three days (primary analysis) and 7 days (secondary analysis) of an ambulance call ending in non-transport to hospital. Non-clinical staff used a priority dispatch system e.g. Medical Priority Dispatch System to prioritize calls for ambulance dispatch. Non-transport to ED was determined by ambulance crew members at scene or clinicians at the emergency operating center when an ambulance was not dispatched (telephone advice). Results The data linkage rate was 85% for patients who were discharged at scene (43,108/50,894). After removal of deaths associated with end of life care (N = 312), 9% (3,861/42,796) re-contacted the ambulance service, 12.6% (5,412/42,796) attended ED, 6.3% (2,694/42,796) were admitted to hospital, and 0.3% (129/42,796) died within three days of the call. Rates were higher for events occurring within 7 days. For example, 12% re-contacted the ambulance service, 16.1% attended ED, 9.3% were admitted to hospital and 0.5% died. The linkage rate for telephone advice calls was low because ambulance services record less information about these patients (24% 2,514/10,634). A sensitivity analysis identified a range of subsequent event rates: 2.5%- 10.5% of patients were admitted to hospital and 0.06%-0.24% of patient died within 3 days of the call. Conclusions Most non-transported patients did not have subsequent health events. Deaths after non-transport are an infrequent event that could be selected for more detailed review of individual cases, to facilitate learning and improvement.

1 April 2019 in Programme Grants for Applied Research
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
JTJanette Turner
Janette Turner
ANAloysius Niroshan
Aloysius Niroshan
JCJoanne Coster
Joanne Coster
RJRichard Jacques
Richard Jacques
AIAndy Irving
Andy Irving
OAO'Cathain A
O'Cathain A
Background: Ambulance service quality measures have focused on response times and a small number of emergency conditions, such as cardiac arrest. These quality measures do not reflect the care for the wide range of problems that ambulance services respond to and the Prehospital Outcomes for Evidence Based Evaluation (PhOEBE) programme sought to address this.Objectives: The aim was to develop new ways of measuring the impact of ambulance service care by reviewing and synthesising literature on prehospital ambulance outcome measures and using consensus methods to identify measures for further development; creating a data set linking routinely collected ambulance service, hospital and mortality data; and using the linked data to explore the development of case-mix adjustment models to assess differences or changes in processes and outcomes resulting from ambulance service care.Design: A mixed-methods study using a systematic review and synthesis of performance and outcome measures reported in policy and research literature; qualitative interviews with ambulance service users; a three-stage consensus process to identify candidate indicators; the creation of a data set linking ambulance, hospital and mortality data; and statistical modelling of the linked data set to produce novel case-mix adjustment measures of ambulance service quality.Setting: East Midlands and Yorkshire, England.Participants: Ambulance services, patients, public, emergency care clinical academics, commissioners and policy-makers between 2011 and 2015.Interventions: None.Main outcome measures: Ambulance performance and quality measures.Data sources: Ambulance call-and-dispatch and electronic patient report forms, Hospital Episode Statistics, accident and emergency and inpatient data, and Office for National Statistics mortality data.Results: Seventy-two candidate measures were generated from systematic reviews in four categories: (1) ambulance service operations (n = 14), (2) clinical management of patients (n = 20), (3) impact of care on patients (n = 9) and (4) time measures (n = 29). The most common operations measures were call triage accuracy; clinical management was adherence to care protocols, and for patient outcome it was survival measures. Excluding time measures, nine measures were highly prioritised by participants taking part in the consensus event, including measures relating to pain, patient experience, accuracy of dispatch decisions and patient safety. Twenty experts participated in two Delphi rounds to refine and prioritise measures and 20 measures scored ≥ 8/9 points, which indicated good consensus. Eighteen patient and public representatives attending a consensus workshop identified six measures as important: time to definitive care, response time, reduction in pain score, calls correctly prioritised to appropriate levels of response, proportion of patients with a specific condition who are treated in accordance with established guidelines, and survival to hospital discharge for treatable emergency conditions. From this we developed six new potential indicators using the linked data set, of which five were constructed using case-mix-adjusted predictive models: (1) mean change in pain score; (2) proportion of serious emergency conditions correctly identified at the time of the 999 call; (3) response time (unadjusted); (4) proportion of decisions to leave a patient at scene that were potentially inappropriate; (5) proportion of patients transported to the emergency department by 999 emergency ambulance who did not require treatment or investigation(s); and (6) proportion of ambulance patients with a serious emergency condition who survive to admission, and to 7 days post admission. Two indicators (pain score and response times) did not need case-mix adjustment. Among the four adjusted indicators, we found that accuracy of call triage was 61%, rate of potentially inappropriate decisions to leave at home was 5–10%, unnecessary transport to hospital was 1.7–19.2% and survival to hospital admission was 89.5–96.4% depending on Clinical Commissioning Group area. We were unable to complete a fourth objective to test the indicators in use because of delays in obtaining data. An economic analysis using indicators (4) and (5) showed that incorrect decisions resulted in higher costs.Limitations: Creation of a linked data set was complex and time-consuming and data quality was variable. Construction of the indicators was also complex and revealed the effects of other services on outcome, which limits comparisons between services.Conclusions: We identified and prioritised, through consensus processes, a set of potential ambulance service quality measures that reflected preferences of services and users. Together, these encompass a broad range of domains relevant to the population using the emergency ambulance service. The quality measures can be used to compare ambulance services or regions or measure performance over time if there are improvements in mechanisms for linking data across services.Future work: The new measures can be used to assess different dimensions of ambulance service delivery but current data challenges prohibit routine use. There are opportunities to improve data linkage processes and to further develop, validate and simplify these measures.Funding: The National Institute for Health Research Programme Grants for Applied Research programme.

1 May 2022 in Health Technology Assessment
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
PDF file
MTMartin H Thornhill
Martin H Thornhill
ACAnnabel Crum
Annabel Crum
SRSaleema Rex
Saleema Rex
RCRichard Campbell
Richard Campbell
TSTony Stone
Tony Stone
JNJon Nicholl
Jon Nicholl
Background: Infective endocarditis is a heart infection with a first-year mortality rate of ≈ 30%. It has long been thought that infective endocarditis is causally associated with bloodstream seeding with oral bacteria in ≈ 40–45% of cases. This theorem led guideline committees to recommend that individuals at increased risk of infective endocarditis should receive antibiotic prophylaxis before undergoing invasive dental procedures. However, to the best of our knowledge, there has never been a clinical trial to prove the efficacy of antibiotic prophylaxis and there is no good-quality evidence to link invasive dental procedures with infective endocarditis. Many contend that oral bacteria-related infective endocarditis is more likely to result from daily activities (e.g. tooth brushing, flossing and chewing), particularly in those with poor oral hygiene. Objective: The aim of this study was to determine if there is a temporal association between invasive dental procedures and subsequent infective endocarditis, particularly in those at high risk of infective endocarditis. Design: This was a self-controlled, case-crossover design study comparing the number of invasive dental procedures in the 3 months immediately before an infective endocarditis-related hospital admission with that in the preceding 12-month control period. Setting: The study took place in the English NHS. Participants: All individuals admitted to hospital with infective endocarditis between 1 April 2010 and 31 March 2016 were eligible to participate. Interventions: This was an observational study; therefore, there was no intervention. Main outcome measure: The outcome measure was the number of invasive and non-invasive dental procedures in the months before infective endocarditis-related hospital admission. Data sources: NHS Digital provided infective endocarditis-related hospital admissions data and dental procedure data were obtained from the NHS Business Services Authority. Results: The incidence rate of invasive dental procedures decreased in the 3 months before infective endocarditis-related hospital admission (incidence rate ratio 1.34, 95% confidence interval 1.13 to 1.58). Further analysis showed that this was due to loss of dental procedure data in the 2–3 weeks before any infective endocarditis-related hospital admission. Limitations: We found that urgent hospital admissions were a common cause of incomplete courses of dental treatment and, because there is no requirement to record dental procedure data for incomplete courses, this resulted in a significant loss of dental procedure data in the 2–3 weeks before infective endocarditis-related hospital admissions. The data set was also reduced because of the NHS Business Services Authority’s 10-year data destruction policy, reducing the power of the study. The main consequence was a loss of dental procedure data in the critical 3-month case period of the case-crossover analysis (immediately before infective endocarditis-related hospital admission), which did not occur in earlier control periods. Part of the decline in the rate of invasive dental procedures may also be the result of the onset of illness prior to infective endocarditis-related hospital admission, and part may be due to other undefined causes. Conclusions: The loss of dental procedure data in the critical case period immediately before infective endocarditis-related hospital admission makes interpretation of the data difficult and raises uncertainty over any conclusions that can be drawn from this study. Future work: We suggest repeating this study elsewhere using data that are unafflicted by loss of dental procedure data in the critical case period. Trial registration: This trial is registered as ISRCTN11684416. Funding: This project was funded by the National Institute for Health and Care Research (NIHR) Health Technology Assessment programme and will be published in full in Health Technology Assessment; Vol. 26, No. 28. See the NIHR Journals Library website for further project information.

1 April 2025 in Health Technology Assessment
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
JPJoanne M Patterson
Joanne M Patterson
CMCatriona R Mayland
Catriona R Mayland
PBPeter Bath
Peter Bath
MLMichelle Lawton
Michelle Lawton
VBValerie Bryant
Valerie Bryant
LSLinda Sharp
Linda Sharp
Background: Patients with incurable head and neck cancer have considerable unmet needs and complex symptom burden, with evidence of substantial geographical and/or socioeconomic inequalities. Accurate information on healthcare needs, resource utilisation and service provision in the last year of life is lacking. This places limits on service delivery planning and the development and testing of interventions to better meet needs. Our partnership spans three regions, which nationally have some of the highest rates of incurable head and neck cancer. Aims: The overall aims were to (1) establish a palliative head and neck cancer partnership, (2) identify and evaluate routine incurable head and neck cancer data sources and utilise these to develop and address research priorities. Objectives: O1. Develop a palliative head and neck cancer network within the North of England, representing a geographical area with high incidence of incurable head and neck cancer and palliative care needs. O2. Develop and refine research questions and priorities. O3. Engage with data providers to identify relevant data sets and specific data fields to understand the potential quality and utility of these to inform research priorities. Methods: There were three interconnected work packages: WP1: A ‘snowballing’ approach to establish a network of clinicians, researchers, patient and public representatives, data architects and key stakeholders with an interest in head and neck cancer palliative care. WP2: A Delphi consensus process to develop and refine research questions and priorities, based on national guidance and systematic reviews of evidence gaps. WP3: Identification of national and local data sets and exploration of the potential data quality and utility, and associated information governance processes for access. Results: WP1: A diverse network was established, encompassing members from a wide range of professions and patient/carer groups. WP2: The Delphi consisted of two rounds involving up to 66 participants. Consensus was reached on 12 research questions representing 4 key areas of prioritisation: service provision, symptom management, psychosocial support and information provision and communication. WP3: A range of national and local data sources were identified as having the potential to address the research priorities. A directory of data sources was developed. Working in an iterative way, data sets and relevant data fields were mapped to the 12 potential research priority areas to assess the applicability of using routine data to address these priorities. Limitations: Approximately, one-third of participants in the Delphi process dropped out in round 2. Despite attempts to be flexible in our approach, retaining participants, particularly for patients and their families on a palliative care pathway, is challenging. Future work: The established network and consensus exercise form the basis for future service evaluations and collaborative research. These will be based on gaps and priorities agreed by patients, their families and a range of other stakeholders. Conclusions: The network has established a cross-sectoral collaboration for improving incurable head and neck cancer and a platform to identify 12 research priority areas. Utilising routine data to address these priorities remains a challenging area, and a range of methodological research approaches will be required to take this forward. Funding: This article presents independent research funded by the National Institute for Health and Care Research (NIHR) Health Technology Assessment programme as award number NIHR135361.

20 May 2026 in medRxiv
Verified
Preprint
Open access
PDF file
JCJames Cussens
James Cussens
KDKelly Do
Kelly Do
ECEmily V Chambers
Emily V Chambers
ACAnnabel Crum
Annabel Crum
CBChristopher Burton
Christopher Burton
CBChris Burton
Chris Burton
Background High Intensity Use of urgent medical services by patients is widely recognised in urgent and emergency care. Studies of high intensity use of the emergency department have consistently shown features of complex systems behaviour in addition to highly heterogeneous individual patient characteristics. There have been no comparable studies of prehospital care use. Methods We examined the use of prehospital urgent and emergency services (NHS 111 and ambulance dispatch) using routinely collected data from regional service in the UK (population 5 million). We used a complex systems perspective, to examine (1) distribution of contacts per individual; (2) the temporal stability of service use by individuals and at the whole-system level (3) the distribution of bursts of contacts. Results We analysed data from 847555 individuals who contacted NHS111 and 389550 who contacted the ambulance dispatch service. 35120 (4.2%) individuals who contacted NHS111 had 5 or more contacts with the service over the two-year period and accounted for 290625 (20.1%) of contacts. 16755 (4.3%) individuals had 5 or more ambulance dispatch contact days and accounted for 169085 (25.8%) of contacts. The distribution of contacts per individual showed a monotonic distribution between 5 and over 100 contacts that was heavy tailed and compatible with a power law distribution. At any level of use, patients with one or more mental health related contacts had a greater likelihood of further contact than those without. Conclusion Prehospital emergency service use shows multiple statistical features typical of a complex system. Interventions to manage demand need to consider both individual high intensity users (particularly in relation to their mental health) and the behaviour of the whole system.