Background: Traditionally, patients are seen by an ear, nose and throat (ENT) surgeon prior to allied health referral for treatment of swallowing, voice, hearing and dizziness. Wait‐times for ENT consultations often exceed those clinically recommended. We evaluated the service impact of five allied health primary contact clinics (AHPC‐ENT) on wait‐times and access to treatment.Setting: A metropolitan Australian University Hospital Outpatient ENT Department.Participants: We created five AHPC‐ENT pathways (dysphonia, dysphagia, vestibular, adult and paediatric audiology) for low‐acuity patients referred to ENT with symptoms of dysphonia, dysphagia, dizziness and hearing loss.Main outcome measures: Using multiple regression analysis, we compared waiting times in the 24‐month pre‐ and 12‐month post‐implementation of the AHPC‐ENT service. In addition, we measured the number of patients requiring specialist ENT intervention after assessment in the AHPC‐ENT, adverse events and evaluation of service delivery costs.Results: Seven hundred and thirty‐eight patients were seen in the AHPC‐ENT over the first 12 months of implementation (dysphagia, 66; dysphonia, 153; vestibular, 151; retro‐cochlear, 60; and paediatric glue ear, 308). All pathways significantly reduced the waiting times for patients by an average of 277 days, compared with usual care. The majority of patients were able to be discharged without ongoing ENT intervention (72% dysphagia; 81% dysphonia; 74% vestibular; 53% retro‐cochlear; and 32% paediatric glue ear). No adverse events were recorded.Conclusions: The AHPC‐ENT improved waiting times for assessment and access to treatment. Future research on cost‐effectiveness and diagnostic agreement between AHPs and ENT clinicians would provide further confidence in the model.
Objective: Determine the effects of a vertigo/dizziness emergency department (ED) clinical pathway incorporating vestibular physiotherapy on quality and efficiency of care.Study Design: A multisite retrospective study investigated differences between cohorts before and after a vertigo clinical pathway and cohorts who did and did not receive vestibular physiotherapy assessment.Setting: Adults presenting to 2 Australian EDs with symptoms clinically consistent with vestibular disorder were captured via ED diagnostic code screening and subsequent medical record review.Methods: Medical record audits obtained quality of care indicators: diagnosis, HINTS (head impulse–nystagmus–test of skew), and vestibular physiotherapy management. Linked hospital administrative data sets provided efficiency measures: time from ED presentation to assessments, hospital admission rates, and ED and total hospital length of stay.Results: Postpathway cohorts (n = 329) showed greater use of HINTS (by 27%; 95% CI, 21%‐33%), more frequent vestibular physiotherapy assessment (by 27%; 95% CI, 20%‐33%), reduced wait time to assessment (25.0 to 4.6 hours; 95% CI, −27.1 to −14.1), and reduced ED length of stay (3.9 to 3.2 hours; 95% CI, −0.3 to −1.0) as compared with prepathway cohorts (n = 214). When compared with those not receiving vestibular physiotherapy assessment, patients assessed by a vestibular physiotherapist (n = 150) received a specific diagnosis more frequently (65% vs 34%; 95% CI, 22%‐40%) but were admitted more often (79% vs 49%; 95% CI, 22%‐38%) with longer total hospital length of stay (13.0 vs 5.0 hours; 95% CI, 6.1‐10.6).Conclusion: An ED vertigo clinical pathway was associated with improved quality and efficiency of care, including reduced ED time. Vestibular physiotherapist assessment was associated with greater diagnostic specificity but higher hospital admissions.
Background: Ear, Nose and Throat (ENT) primary contact models of care use audiologists as the first triage point for children referred to ENT for middle ear and hearing concerns; and have shown reduced waiting time, improved ENT surgical conversion rates and increased service capacity. This study aimed to investigate ‘safety and quality’ of the model by looking at agreement between audiologists’ and an ENT’s clinical decisions. Methods: We performed an inter-rater agreement study on diagnosis and management decisions made by audiologists and an ENT for 50 children seen in an Australian hospital’s ENT primary contact service, and examined the nature and patterns of disagreements. Results: Professionals agreed on at least one site-of-lesion diagnosis for all children (100%) and on the primary management for 74% (Gwet’s AC1 = 0.67). Management disagreements clustered around i) providing ‘watchful waiting’ versus sooner medical opinion (18%), and ii) providing monitoring versus discharge for children with no current symptoms (8%). There were no cases where the audiologist recommended discharge when the ENT recommended further medical opinion. Conclusions: Our novel research provides further evidence that Audiologist-led primary contact models for children with middle ear and hearing concerns are safe as well as efficient.
Dizziness and vertigo are common referrals to Ear Nose Throat (ENT) outpatient services however these services have long waitlists for assessment. Primary contact physiotherapy-led vestibular clinics are recognized as improving access to care. This pilot study investigated agreement between physiotherapists and an ENT medical practitioner for diagnostic and management decisions in patients attending a primary contact physiotherapy-led vestibular clinic. Prospective blinded inter-rater agreement study undertaken in an ENT primary contact physiotherapy-led vestibular clinic. Participants were adults referred to ENT from general practitioners, triaged (Category 2 or 3) to the primary contact physiotherapy-led vestibular clinic with clinical symptoms consistent with vestibular disorder. Primary outcome measures included agreement of diagnoses and management decisions made by an ENT medical practitioner and Physiotherapist based on a vestibular physiotherapy assessment. Adverse events were reviewed 11 months post data collection. Gwet’s first order agreement co-efficient (AC1) calculated inter-rater reliability between physiotherapy and ENT. Fifty-one participants were recruited consecutively from the primary contact physiotherapy-led vestibular clinic. Physiotherapy and ENT had a substantial agreement (AC1 0.613) on diagnosis. AC1 between physiotherapy and ENT for recommending Magnetic resonance imaging (0.810) and computerized tomography (0.935) both indicated near perfect agreement. There was moderate to near-perfect agreement regarding management recommendations between physiotherapy and ENT. Substantial agreement (AC1 0.720) was found for recommendations for ENT input, near perfect agreement (AC1 0.933) for neurology input and moderate agreement (AC1 0.574) for physiotherapy input. There were no adverse events from physiotherapist’s management decision, based on final recommendations undertaken 11-months post data collection. Physiotherapists and ENT medical practitioner made comparable diagnostic and management decisions, based on physiotherapy and audiology hearing assessment, for adults with signs of vestibular dysfunction, within an ENT primary contact physiotherapy-led vestibular clinic. This study provides support for this type of Physiotherapy-led service in managing patients referred to an ENT service with vestibular dysfunction. 1. This is the first study investigating interprofessional agreement between physiotherapists and an ENT medical practitioner in the diagnosis and management of patients within an ENT primary contact physiotherapy-led vestibular clinic (recommendations were based on a vestibular physiotherapy assessment as participants were not directly assessed by ENT). 2. Physiotherapists and ENT agreement on diagnosis was substantial. 3. Agreement between physiotherapy and ENT on requesting MRI brain and CT head were near perfect; and agreement between physiotherapy and ENT for onward management to ENT, neurology or physiotherapy was moderate to near perfect. 4. There were no adverse events from physiotherapy’s management decision, based on the final recommendations. 5. This paper provides support for the competency of physiotherapists in managing patients referred to ENT with vestibular dysfunction and the safety of ENT primary contact physiotherapy-led vestibular clinics, albeit the presence of bias given the recommendations were based on a vestibular physiotherapy assessment only.