1 January 2010 in Revue d'anthropologie des connaissances
Dans la vie quotidienne les situations de confrontation aux traces de nos activités se banalisent, à travers des technologies indiquant notre état physique ou les effets de nos comportements. Nos « écologies informationnelles » sont de plus en plus réflexives, ce qui produit des effets performatifs, via un retour sur soi et une dialectique sujet-objet productives de transformations. C’est le cas par exemple des carnets de diabétiques grâce auxquels les patients développent une maitrise de leur pathologie, ou d’un nouveau dispositif de détection automatique des crises épileptiques qui amène différents acteurs à confronter leurs points de vue sur les signaux pertinents. Par ailleurs l’autoconfrontation, ou confrontation aux traces vidéo/audio/écrites de sa propre activité, est un dispositif fortement réflexif, mis en place cette fois par le chercheur. Les traces de l’activité réelle médiatisent le rapport à l’expérience, pour aider à se rappeler et décrire finement l’activité réalisée ou pour la réélaborer, et ainsi développer des connaissances pour agir et des connaissances sur l’action. On distingue deux types de visées : (1) faire décrire finement l’expérience phénoménologique pour comprendre l’activité (e.g. musicien-compositeur, arbitres de rugby) ; (2) susciter une élaboration analytique et l’émergence de controverses pour le développement des compétences et de l’activité (e.g. ouvriers du bâtiment).
14 April 2023 in ACM Transactions on Human-Robot Interaction
The very first moments of co-presence, during which a robot appears to a participant for the first time, are often “off-the-record” in the data collected from human-robot experiments (video recordings, motion tracking, methodology sections, etc.). Yet, this “pre-beginning” phase, well documented in the case of human-human interactions, is not an interactional vacuum: It is where interactional work from participants can take place so the production of a first speaking turn (like greeting the robot) becomes relevant and expected. We base our analysis on an experiment that replicated the interaction opening delays sometimes observed in laboratory or “in-the-wild” human-robot interaction studies—where robots can require time before springing to life after they are in co-presence with a human. Using an ethnomethodological and multimodal conversation analytic methodology (EMCA), we identify which properties of the robot's behavior were oriented to by participants as creating the adequate conditions to produce a first greeting. Our findings highlight the importance of the state in which the robot originally appears to participants: as an immobile object or, instead, as an entity already involved in preexisting activity. Participants’ orientations to the very first behaviors manifested by the robot during this “pre-beginning” phase produced a priori unpredictable sequential trajectories, which configured the timing and the manner in which the robot emerged as a social agent. We suggest that these first instants of co-presence are not peripheral issues with respect to human-robot experiments but should be thought about and designed as an integral part of those.
1 February 1995 in Applied Surface Science
1 January 2010 in Revue d'anthropologie des connaissances
In everyday life, situations involving confrontation with the traces of our activities are becoming commonplace, through technologies that objectivate and make available our experiences and conduct. Our "informational ecologies" are increasingly reflexive, which elicits performative effects and a mediated return to self, or a dialectic between subject and object which produces transformations. This is the case, for example, with diabetic diaries, through which patients develop a mastery of their pathology, or with a new automatic epileptic seizure detection device that leads different actors to confront their points of view on the relevant experiential data and inscriptions. In addition, self-confrontation, or confrontation with video/audio/written traces of one's own activity, is a powerful reflexive device, this time set up by the researcher. The observable video traces of the lived activity mediate experiences, to help subjects to remember and to describe in detail the activity carried out or to re-elaborate it, and thus to develop knowledge to act and knowledge about the action. There are two types of objectives here: (1) to describe subjet’s experiences in phenomenological detail in order to gain an elaborate understanding of the activity at hand (e.g. musician-composer, rugby referees); (2) to provoke an analytical and collective elaboration and the emergence of controversies for the development of skills and activity (e.g. construction workers).
1 January 2011 in Droit et Cultures