9 September 2024 in Conservation Biology
The surge in internet accessibility has transformed wildlife trade by facilitating the acquisition of wildlife through online platforms. This scenario presents unique ethical challenges for researchers, as traditional ethical frameworks for in‐person research cannot be readily applied to the online realm. Currently, there is a lack of clearly defined guidelines for appropriate ethical procedures when conducting online wildlife trade (OWT) research. In response to this, we consulted the scientific literature on ethical considerations in online research and examined existing guidelines established by professional societies and ethical boards. Based on these documents, we present a set of recommendations that can inform the development of ethically responsible OWT research. Key ethical challenges in designing and executing OWT research include the violation of privacy rights, defining subjects and illegality, and the risk of misinterpretation or posing risks to participants when sharing data. Potential solutions include considering participants’ expectations of privacy, defining when participants are authors versus subjects, understanding the legal and cultural context, minimizing data collection, ensuring anonymization, and removing metadata. Best practices also involve being culturally sensitive when analyzing and reporting findings. Adhering to these guidelines can help mitigate potential pitfalls and provides valuable insights to editors, researchers, and ethical review boards, enabling them to conduct scientifically rigorous and ethically responsible OWT research to advance this growing field.
24 December 2021 in Ecology and Evolution
The global pet trade is a major pathway for the introduction of invasive alien species. The composition of species selected for transport is driven by market demands, which may be influenced by a combination of both historical and cultural factors. We compared Eastern (Taiwan) and Western (Australia and the Iberian Peninsula) bird markets to explore factors associated with the species composition and geographic origin of the birds for sale. We used a bespoke randomization test to compare species composition, geographic origins, and species overlap at different taxonomic levels among bird markets across countries. Alien species identified in the study accounted for more than 10% of the world's bird species. Parrots and songbirds were the most common alien bird taxa traded across all markets. In both Iberian and Australian markets, there was a strong bias toward parrots, waxbills, gamebirds, and finches. In Taiwan, species traded more than expected were parrots, waxbills, starlings, and leafbirds. Neotropical species were the most traded group in the three markets. Afrotropical species were also traded more than expected in Iberian and Australian markets, while the Taiwanese traded more alien species from neighboring Asian regions. The bird trade focuses on the same few bird groups worldwide. The composition and origin of species preferred in the Western markets may be influenced by colonial histories, cultural similarity, and strict regulations on wildlife importation, while species preferences in Eastern markets are strongly influenced by regional culture and proximity. Propagule pressure is a dominant factor influencing the success of biological invasions; it is important to recognize differences in the composition of bird markets among regions because they can translate into different invasion risks, among other factors.
24 March 2022 in Conservation Science and Practice
Unsustainable global wildlife trade impacts biodiversity and threatens national and global security, but many aspects of this trade remain opaque. Our study is a novel investigation of the alleged links between the trade in wildlife products and in donkey skins. The global donkey skin trade is a newly prevalent and lucrative business, largely driven by Chinese demand for E‐Jiao, a traditional medicine derived from donkey skins. Records of donkey skins being seized alongside other wildlife products lead us to hypothesize that there is a link between these two trades. We identified all donkey skin dealers on seven business‐to‐business e‐commerce websites and obtained 14,949 data points. These were used in a network analysis to demonstrate the structure of the network and reveal the connection between the products, including wild animal and plant products offered alongside donkey skins. We identified at least 13 groups of CITES‐listed species in the densely connected donkey skin product network, demonstrated an association between the online trade in wildlife products and donkey skins, and discuss the implications of this overlap—including the potential to shed light on potential novel trade pathways in legal and illegal domestic animal and wildlife trade.
24 October 2026 in Conservation Science and Practice
LKLin‐Ernni Mikégraba Kaboumba
Lin‐Ernni Mikégraba Kaboumba
ACAbiola Sylvestre Chaffra
Wildlife trade poses a significant threat to global biodiversity and continues to escalate in regions such as West Africa. We investigated birds for sale in the Akodessewa Fetish Market (for belief‐based use) in Lomé, Togo—reported to be among the largest in West Africa—by conducting market surveys and trader interviews during four visits from 2022 to 2024. We used generalized linear mixed‐effects models (GLMMs) to analyze factors influencing species presence and relative abundance in the market. Our findings reveal a >200% increase in market volume and >400% increase in the diversity of birds for sale compared to previous surveys. The market featured 82 species from 38 avian families, including seven globally threatened or near threatened species, and 25 Convention of International Trade in Endangered Species (CITES)‐listed species. At least one‐third of traded species are known to have declining populations. Larger‐bodied species and those with higher estimated abundance were more likely to be offered for sale and in greater quantities. In contrast, species with latitudinal distribution midpoints farther from the market were less likely to be present and, when present, were offered in lower numbers. CITES‐listing was associated with the likelihood of species occurrence, while IUCN conservation status was negatively associated with the number of individuals for sale. Trade likelihood varied among taxonomic families, with hornbills (Bucerotidae) showing the highest probability of appearing in trade, whereas owls (Tytonidae and Strigidae) had the highest number of individuals for sale. All traders in the market originated from neighboring Benin, indicating cross‐border trade operations. Species occurrence and abundance in markets were associated primarily with availability, accessibility, and body size rather than conservation status, with CITES‐listed and threatened species appearing in trade despite nominal regulatory protection. We recommend that policy and legal interventions address regional wildlife trade networks operating as global markets rather than as local traditional practices.