Materials and resources are key enablers of the energy and industrial transition, yet their role and associated sustainability risks remain insufficiently understood. Current debates mainly concentrate on energy technologies and policies, whereas the transition also requires materials. At the same time, increasing demand, constrained supply, and environmental and justice issue create complex and interconnected sustainability risks. However, there is a discrepancy between these real-world pressures and their consideration in policy and research, which remain fragmented and lack an interdisciplinary perspective. Therefore, the aim of the paper is to explore the role of materials and science in the transition by advancing the understanding of “sustainability risks of materials” through bringing together different disciplines. As a method, we combine a conceptual and exploratory case study approach consisting of two parts. In the first part, we develop a framework of three material categories and key characteristics. In part two, we operationalize this framework through three quantitative spotlights, which shed light on sustainability risks and synergies of materials. As a result, we identify three material categories, namely (1) fossil energy resources, (2) base or mass materials, and (3) critical raw materials, and define key characteristics, including function, future demand, substitutability, and transition-related risks. The three empirical spotlights on (i) future material demand, (ii) sustainability impact of mining, and (iii) advanced steel, demonstrate the value added of interdisciplinary approaches. They show that material-related sustainability risks are dynamic, interconnected, and shaped by trade-offs across categories and along the value chain. We discuss key findings; limitations related to the interdisciplinary and exploratory nature of the study and related future research directions. In conclusion, material-related sustainability risks are dynamic and interconnected, requiring integrated and interdisciplinary approaches to effectively support the transition.