Polygenic traits are expected to show high genetic redundancy and therefore low repeatability in the genomic response to selection. We tested this prediction by selecting for large body size in the black soldier fly ( Hermetia illucens ). Over three replicate experiments selected for large body size, we found a strong and repeatable phenotypic response, with a mean 15% increase in body size. Selected lines also increased in larval growth rate (+19%) and average protein content (+14%), suggesting that selection on large body size does not result in strong trade-offs. In contrast to the predictability of the phenotypic response across replicates, whole genome sequencing identified a highly polygenic and non-repeatable genomic response. We identified 120, 301 and 157 outlier genomic regions in the three replicates, but high redundancy with only four shared regions. Among 12 candidate genes found in these regions, the insulin-like receptor gene ( HiInR ) was confirmed as regulating larval growth using a CRISPR knockout experiment. In summary, polygenic quantitative traits show high genetic redundancy, even where the phenotypic response to selection is highly repeatable.
Structural variants such as chromosomal rearrangements and gene duplications can play an important role in the adaptation and diversification of organisms. Here, we used comparative genomics to study the functional implications of structural variants across two families of flies. We compared the reference genomes of eight Asilidae species and six Stratiomyidae species, including the black soldier fly ( Hermetia illucens ), a species with an ability to convert organic waste into biomass and a recently expanded global range. Our results show that the genomes of Stratiomyidae are generally larger than Asilidae and contain a higher proportion of transposable elements, many of which are recently expanded. Gene families showing more gene duplications are enriched for life history related functions such as metabolism in Stratiomyidae which are known to be active decomposers, and longevity in Asilidae which are predators and have generally longer lifespan than Stratiomyidae. Gene families showing more gene duplications that are specific to H. illucens are mostly related to olfactory and immune responses, while across the Stratiomyidae there is enrichment of digestive and metabolic functions such as proteolysis, providing an explanation for the higher decomposing efficiency and adaptive ability of H. illucens compared to other Stratiomyidae species in decomposing environments. Together, our results shed light on the contribution of structural variants to functional adaptation and gene family expansions that have likely played a role in the ecological success of the black soldier fly.
Structural variants such as chromosomal rearrangements and gene duplications can play an important role in the adaptation and diversification of organisms. Here, we used comparative genomics to study the functional implications of structural variants across two families of flies. We compared the reference genomes of eight Asilidae species and six Stratiomyidae species, including the black soldier fly ( Hermetia illucens ), a species with an ability to convert organic waste into biomass and a recently expanded global range. The genomes of Stratiomyidae are generally larger than Asilidae and contain a higher proportion of transposable elements, many of which are recently expanded. Gene families showing more gene duplications are enriched for life history related functions such as metabolism in Stratiomyidae and proteolysis and longevity in Asilidae. Gene families showing more gene duplications that are specific to H. illucens are mostly related to olfactory and immune responses, while across the Stratiomyidae there is enrichment of digestive and metabolic functions such as proteolysis. Together, our results shed light on gene family expansions that have likely played a role in the ecological success of the black soldier fly.