Samantha Halliday

Samantha Halliday

Auto-generated profile, based on publicly available information

Samantha Halliday

Durham Law School, Durham University , Durham, DH1 3LE

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

4Years (2023-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
30 May 2023 in Medical Law Review
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
SHSamantha Halliday
Samantha Halliday
ERElizabeth Chloe Romanis
Elizabeth Chloe Romanis
LPLien de Proost
Lien de Proost
EVE. J. T. (Joanne) Verweij
E. J. T. (Joanne) Verweij
Time plays a fundamental role in abortion regulation. In this article, we compare the regulatory frameworks in England and Wales and the Netherlands as examples of the centrality accorded to viability in the determination of the parameters of non-criminal abortion, demonstrating that the use of viability as a threshold renders the law uncertain. We assess the role played by the concept of viability, analysing its impact upon the continued criminalization of abortion and categorization of abortion as a medical matter, rather than a reproductive choice. We conclude that viability is misconceived in its application to abortion and that neonatal viability (relating to treatment of the premature infant) and fetal viability (related to the capacity to survive birth) must be distinguished to better reflect the social context within which the law and practice of abortion operate. We show how viability thresholds endanger pregnant people.

25 December 2023 in Medical Law International
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
SHSamantha Halliday
Samantha Halliday
Choice is a central tenet of maternity care; its importance is emphasised in policy documents, clinical guidelines, and the law. However, the lived experience is often rather different and that is particularly the case in the context of pregnant women with a severe mental illness (SMI). The biomedical discourse is powerful and has successfully constructed pregnancy and birth as risky, as a procedure to be managed by experts using technology to ensure that nothing goes wrong. Within that already risky process, women with SMI are constructed as risky, rather than at risk, posing a risk to themselves and the foetus they carry, as well as to the healthcare professionals who care for them. It is not merely their treatment decisions that are questioned, but their very ability to make those decisions. The consequence of this is reduced choice for women with SMI who are cautioned to act responsibly, but where they fail to acquiesce and comply with medical advice, making the ‘wrong’ choice, their capacity is called into question and, if found to lack capacity, decisions about mode and place of delivery will be determined by someone else on the basis of that third party’s evaluation of her best interests, giving scant regard to her wishes. This article reviews the recent obstetric intervention case law, interrogating the discrepancy between the minimal weight attributed to the birth choices of pregnant women with SMI within the best interests assessment in comparison to the significance accorded to the wishes of non-pregnant individuals in other treatment contexts. It challenges the pregnancy exceptionalism evident in the case law and proposes the use of advance decisions as a tool for women to make birth decisions at a time when their capacity is undiminished, ensuring that their own choices, albeit expressed as refusals of treatment, determine maternity care.

14 July 2025 in Medical Law Review
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
SHSamantha Halliday
Samantha Halliday
JMJean V McHale
Jean V McHale
The Mental Capacity Act 2005 enables individuals to make advance decisions to refuse medical treatment once they lose mental capacity. However, scant attention has been given to the limit imposed by the Code of Practice upon the ability of an individual to refuse care, as opposed to treatment in an advance decision. This article examines the different meanings of ‘basic care’. It interrogates the genesis of the exclusion within the Code of Practice. The article examines the problems created by the exclusion, both in definitional terms and in relation to the conflict created with respect for precedent autonomy. It argues that while such an exclusion could be justified on the basis of public policy at the turn of the 21st century, the evolution of greater respect for patient-centred decision-making and respect for human dignity require its re-evaluation. The article challenges the continued relevance of the exception in the light of shifts in public policy and the case law, proposing that the ability to make an advance decision about basic care as well as treatment is an essential element in the toolkit designed to ensure individualized care at the end of life.

18 July 2025
Verified
Book Chapter
Closed access
PDF file
SHSamantha Halliday
Samantha Halliday
This chapter considers the way in which risk is assessed in the context of pregnancy and birth, focusing upon the location, rather than mode of delivery. It analyses the manner in which reproductive subjects are rendered invisible within court proceedings, reduced to (expectant) mothers, with little consideration of their wishes and feelings about where to give birth, particularly when their choices are regarded as risky. It challenges the pregnancy exceptionalism evident in the case law and calls for a realignment between the narratives of consent propounded in policy documentation and professional guidance on the one hand and practice on the other. In this way it sets the agenda for realigning the relationship between reproductive subjects and their carers, arguing for a holistic approach to risk assessment which takes account not only of potential risk to the foetus but also the pregnant person’s own well-being, making the argument for care that allows pregnant individuals to make their own decisions about mode and location of delivery. <!----> <!----> <!----> <!---->

18 July 2025
Verified
Book Chapter
Closed access
PDF file
RBRebecca Brione
Rebecca Brione
SHSamantha Halliday
Samantha Halliday
JNJacqueline Nicholls
Jacqueline Nicholls
This chapter interrogates the interface between law, medicine and ethics by exploring the contours of consent and the framing of individuals in the context of reproduction. It engages with reproductive justice by focussing upon the way in which individuals are othered, treated differently due to their skin colour, their genetic makeup, the fact that they have a serious mental illness, etc. In each case their ‘choice’, their ‘consent’, is devalued, afforded less significance by societal structures, healthcare professionals and indeed the law. It considers the ways in which reproductive subjects are invisibilised, evaluating the shift that occurs in the centrality and meaning of consent in the context of reproduction. Finally, this chapter illuminates the discrepancies between law, professional guidance and health policy on the one hand and the lived experience of reproductive subjects on the other, demonstrating that all too often the dominant narratives of consent and choice are not reflected in practice. <!----> <!----> <!----> <!---->

18 July 2025
Verified
Book
Closed access
SHSamantha Halliday
Samantha Halliday
RBRebecca Brione
Rebecca Brione
JNJacqueline Nicholls
Jacqueline Nicholls
Consent is the golden principle that determines the legality of most medical treatment. However, whilst choice is the much-vaunted central tenet of maternity care, its importance emphasised in policy documents, the lived experience is often rather different, particularly in the case of individuals constructed as ‘other’. This collection brings together a range of researchers from multiple disciplines to address the issue of choice in the context of reproduction, focussing upon narratives of consent as they pertain to reproductive subjects who all too often are rendered invisible by the law, by the healthcare professionals treating them, or by society. It explores the contours of consent in England and Wales, engaging with reproductive justice by focussing upon the way in which reproductive subjects are othered, treated differently due to their skin colour, their genetic makeup, the fact that they have a serious mental illness or even those who do not want to be mothers. It presents original research, bringing together multiple perspectives in examining the way in which individuals are rendered invisible in the context of reproductive healthcare. The book will be essential reading for academics and professionals in law, nursing, medicine, midwifery, sociology, ethics and anthropology. <!----> <!----> <!----> <!---->