14 July 2023 in Legal Bulletin
The article analyzes individual issues of the influence of artificial intelligence as information technologies, with the application of which it is possible to carry out complex tasks by using a system of scientific research methods and information processing algorithms, which have a significant impact on the implementation of human and citizen rights and freedoms in Ukraine. The current state of regulatory support for the indicated problem in Ukraine, as well as issues that require the separate legal regulation, are analyzed. It is noted that the use of artificial intelligence technologies affects all spheres of social life, in particular, it is a component of ensuring information and cyber security in Ukraine. It was found that the following rights and freedoms are under particular threat due to the influence of AI: the right to respect for private and family life, freedom of expression, non-discrimination, the right to freedom of movement, the right to freedom and fair elections, the right to a fair trial. Ukraine does not stand aside from the processes of improving the legal regulation of artificial intelligence technologies and expresses its desire to occupy a significant segment of the world market of artificial intelligence technologies, leading positions in international rankings. Artificial intelligence technologies are expected to contribute to the transformation of the economy, the labor market, government institutions and society in general. Their application will provide an opportunity to reduce costs and increase production efficiency, as well as the quality of goods and services. The use of AI technologies must first of all protect the human right to dignity as a basic and fundamental human right, primordial for all other rights and freedoms, and the violation of any human rights in this way can be considered a violation of the right to human dignity. The emergence of threats to human rights in one form or another when using AI requires finding ways to overcome risks and threats to human rights and the proper functioning of the human rights protection and rights restoration mechanism.
14 July 2023 in Legal Bulletin
In the proposed article, the authors continue to consider the issue of artificial intelligence in relation to the protection of human rights and freedoms during the election process. It has been established that the use of artificial intelligence technologies is aimed at protecting human rights to dignity as a basic and fundamental right of a person, primordial for all other rights and freedoms, and the violation of any rights in this way can be considered a violation of the right to human dignity. It is justified that the occurrence of threats to human rights in one form or another when using artificial intelligence requires finding ways to overcome risks and threats to human rights and the proper functioning of the human rights protection and rights restoration mechanism. The work thoroughly covers the impact of artificial intelligence on the implementation of the right to vote in Ukraine and foreign countries. A system of scientific research methods and information processing algorithms is used, which have a significant impact on the realization of human and citizen rights and freedoms in Ukraine. The current state of legal protection of human rights and freedoms in Ukraine has been analyzed, normative documents that need to be revised have been established. It has been proven that the following rights and freedoms are under particular threat due to the influence of artificial intelligence, in particular, freedom of expression, the right to freedom of movement, the right to freedom and fair elections, the right to a fair trial, and the right to respect for private and family life. It was noted that Ukraine does not stand aside from the processes of improving the legal regulation of artificial intelligence technologies and expresses its desire to occupy a significant segment of the world market of artificial intelligence technologies, leading positions in international rankings. Artificial intelligence technologies are expected to contribute to the transformation of the economy, the labor market, government institutions and society in general. Their application will provide an opportunity to reduce costs and increase production efficiency, quality of goods and services. It has been proven that according to the preamble to the "Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms" dated March 20, 1952, basic human rights and freedoms are best ensured "through effective political democracy." Articles of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights were analyzed, where every citizen without any discrimination and without unreasonable restrictions should have the right and opportunity to participate in public affairs both directly and through elected representatives. It is proven that the voting process and the process of automatic counting of votes is provided exclusively with the help of electronic devices and special software.
28 May 2026 in Криміналістичний вісник
The article examines the legal aspects of the use of artificial intelligence technologies in criminal justice in the context of European integration processes in Ukraine. The regulatory framework for regulating the scope of application of artificial intelligence in criminal justice is developed, indicating the provisions of the Constitution of Ukraine and the Criminal Procedure Code of Ukraine. Scientific approaches to understanding the role and significance of artificial intelligence technologies in the field of criminal justice are outlined, indicating possible risks associated with the violation of the right of an individual to privacy and other human rights. The internal relationships between the structural elements of the holistic mechanism of artificial intelligence technology are identified, on the basis of which the emphasis is placed on the features of the application of its tools in criminal justice. The features of the functioning of the social prerequisites for the use of artificial intelligence are revealed, its role as an auxiliary mechanism in the implementation of justice tasks is determined. The main risks of using artificial intelligence in criminal proceedings are highlighted, including algorithmic bias, opacity of algorithms, and potential violation of the right of participants to a fair trial. The scientific novelty of the article lies in substantiating the need to form a comprehensive legal model of using artificial intelligence in criminal proceedings in Ukraine in accordance with European standards of justice. In addition, the author’s analysis of the risks of using artificial intelligence in criminal proceedings and directions for minimizing unlawful interference by artificial intelligence tools in the activities of the court during decision-making are proposed. The regulatory approaches of the European Union to regulating the use of artificial intelligence are analyzed, in particular the provisions of the European Union Act on Artificial Intelligence. Particular attention is paid to compliance with the principles of transparency, non-discrimination, protection of personal data, and ensuring human control over algorithmic decisions. The position is defended on the priority of ensuring the legal standards of the European Union for the formation of algorithmic models of individual justice institutions in Ukraine.
28 February 2020 in Fundamental and applied researches in practice of leading scientific schools
Іn this paper the object of the research is unilateral deals from the point of view of their content interpretation. The authors study the contents and features of the interpretation of unilateral deals. Identify existing methods and rules of interpretation of unilateral deals. Analyzed the jurisprudence concerning the interpretation application of certain provisions of the civil law in relation to unilateral deals. In general, the legislation of Ukraine in the studied aspect is slightly different from the legislation of other countries. It can even be recognized that the domestic system has a greater degree of unification of legal rules, which contains uniform rules of interpretation for virtually all types of deals. Due to this fact the mechanism of interpretation is more transparent, eliminates the diversity of interpretations of the same type of deals. Thus, the interpretation mechanism as a whole in the civilistic field is formed, but some of its elements require clarification, concretization, improvement, taking into account the peculiarities of different types of deals interpretation, including unilateral ones.
1 January 2021 in Almanac of Law
The proposed paper outlines the main approaches to understanding of the scientific and legal doctrine and its constitutive features, as well as the influence on the law interpretation processes. The authors note that the scientific and legal doctrine not only defines the toolkit and approaches to the interpretation of legal texts, but forms the definitions, categories, conceptions, constructions which are used by legislators in creating regulations and by subjects of law which have to understand the true meaning of norms contained in such legal acts and implement in practice. The main provisions concerning the peculiarities of the doctrinal sources usage while judicial interpretation in different legal families are highlighted. The characteristic features of doctrinal interpretation, forms of its objectification and interconnection with judicial interpretation are determined. Particular attention is paid to the usage of doctrinal provisions in the legal interpretation by the Constitutional Court of Ukraine and the Supreme Court. The main forms in which the results of doctrinal interpretation are used in judicial activity are outlined: the functioning of scientific advisory councils, whose members provide their opinions on complex legal issues; involvement of an expert in the field of law to the court proceedings in certain cases provided by the current legislation. It is noted that during the court hearing of the case while the formation of a legal position the possibility to refer to the opinion of authoritative Ukrainian legal scholars is not typical and acceptable for the domestic legal system. It is noted that many authoritative lawyers, scientists with academic degrees and titles, who are also engaged in scientific activity, have worked and still work as judges, especially of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine. This practice is especially valuable because a judge is able to apply the results of his/her scientific work in interpreting the law in the process of judicial activity and at the same time to use his/her practical experience in scientific research. The authors of the paper cover issues related to the use of «judicial doctrines» and the solution of «exceptional legal issues», which are relatively new to domestic jurisprudence. The interconnection of these concepts with legal doctrine is determined. It is established that although the current legislation provides for certain ways of using doctrinal provisions and the results of doctrinal interpretation in law enforcement practice, but this process is not developed enough and needs further clarification. Keywords: scientific-legal doctrine, legal interpretation, doctrinal interpretation, judicial doctrines, exceptional legal problem.