Anthony Chima Diala

Anthony Chima Diala

Auto-generated profile, based on publicly available information

Anthony Chima Diala

University of the Western Cape

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

16Years (2011-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
4 May 2017 in The Journal of Legal Pluralism and Unofficial Law
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
ADAnthony C. Diala
Anthony C. Diala
The concept of living customary law has been embraced by scholars and judges, especially in southern Africa. However, its acceptance has not benefitted from a detailed legal theoretical explanation. Indeed, the mainstream conceptualisation of living customary law may be accused of alarming ambiguity, which is evident in scholars’ failure to properly account for its flexibility and emergence. This article critiques this conceptualisation, arguing that a meaningful theoretical engagement with living customary law in postcolonial societies should involve two inter-connected approaches. The first is an interdisciplinary approach to law; the second is the perspective of legal pluralism, which plays a key role in the emergence of living customary law. The article proposes that living customary law is best perceived as a product of people's adaptation of customs to socio-economic changes and suggests that this approach is the stepping stone to a comprehensive theory of African law.

1 January 2021 in International Journal of Law, Policy and The Family
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
ADAnthony Chima Diala
Anthony Chima Diala
A notable aspect of Africa’s struggle with its colonial legacies is the co-existence of indigenous laws that emerged in agrarian settings with state laws that emerged in industrial settings. Given the dissonance in their origins, clashes frequently occur between traditionalists and change agents, especially over the property and succession rights of women, girls, and younger male children. Spurred by the judicial handling of these clashes, scholars categorise African customary laws into ‘official’ and ‘living’ versions. However, this categorisation does not account properly for the influence of globalisation on the normative behaviour of Africans. Based on multi-country field research, this article introduces adaptive legal pluralism as the framework for managing the co-existence of indigenous laws and state laws in sub-Saharan Africa. By explaining the influence of globalisation on the behaviour of people subject to indigenous laws, the article draws attention to the imitative character of normative interaction in this region. It presents adaptive legal pluralism as not only a crystal bowl for charting the future of indigenous family laws, but also the theoretical pathway to integrated state and indigenous laws.

2 September 2019 in The Journal of Legal Pluralism and Unofficial Law
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
ADAnthony C. Diala
Anthony C. Diala
Over the past 600 years, African states have been subjected to powerful influences of globalisation such as the slave trade, colonialism, transcultural exchange, and the law and development movement. These influences, which reflect in transplanted European laws masquerading as state laws, are steadily eroding the identity of indigenous African laws. So, to what extent do customary courts in Nigeria reflect indigenous law identity? This unexplored question is significant for scholarly and policy perceptions of legal pluralism in post-colonial states. These perceptions tend to favour conflict of laws, rather than the dialogue occurring between indigenous laws and state laws in intersectional social fields. Informed by case analysis, interviews, and archival searches, this article presents Nigerian customary courts as Anglicised courts pretending to be indigenous courts. It argues that customary courts illustrate indigenous law’s adaptation to socioeconomic changes. In exposing state laws as a key component of these changes, the article highlights the ways customary court actors engender behavioural changes that reveal the adaptive nature of normative interaction in post-colonial societies. It suggests that the adaptive interface of state laws and indigenous laws offers a theoretical platform for legal integration in sub-Saharan Africa.

1 January 2018 in African Human Rights Law Journal
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
ADAnthony C Diala
Anthony C Diala
Thus far, recent judgments on women's property rights delivered by the Nigerian Supreme Court have been perceived as a development of customary law. The article argues that these judgments mask the indifferent attitude of apex courts to women's matrimonial property rights under customary law. This indifference is evident from the Supreme Court's failure to address the preservative philosophy of property rights and the unsuitability of this philosophy to contemporary conditions. To bring this failure into critical focus, the article primarily uses case analyses to critique divorce and succession judgments delivered by the Supreme Court and the Court of Appeal. It finds that apex courts prefer the repugnancy test over the Bill of Rights, using a balancing act that shields the customary law of matrimonial property from constitutional scrutiny. Among other measures, the article suggests that customary law should be unequivocally subjected to the Bill of Rights, and legislation should be enacted to regulate customary laws of succession, marriage and divorce. Key words: customary law; matrimonial property rights; Southern Nigeria; Bill of Rights

1 January 2018 in African Human Rights Law Journal
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
ADAnthony C Diala
Anthony C Diala
Scholarly interest in the co-existence of normative orders in African social fields tends to focus on conflicts arising from the interaction of customary law with state law. This article takes a different path by revealing the normative influence of state law on actors involved in matrimonial property division outside the courts in Southern Nigeria. Based on individual interviews and focus group discussions with female divorcees, their parents, clergy, traditional leaders, NGOs and social welfare officials, it analyses inequalities in property division under customary law, arguing that these inequalities often lead to 'dignity takings'. It reveals how the Social Welfare Department, a government agency mandated to champion the interests of women and children, plays a prominent role in the privileging of gender, class and women's dignity. Spurred by statutes, this department increasingly orders men to divide matrimonial property and/ or to pay compensation to women. Its quasi-judicial orders on marriage gifts, properties bought by women, and child custody potentially contribute to 'dignity restoration' for women infantilised by the customary law of matrimonial property. By revealing the driving forces behind shifts in the traditional philosophy of matrimonial property, the article demonstrates how non-judicial dialogue between state law and customary law facilitates a living customary law of marital property division in Southern Nigeria. Key words: customary law divorce; dignity takings; matrimonial property; Social Welfare Department; Nigeria

20 December 2019 in Journal of African Law
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
PDF file
ADAnthony C Diala
Anthony C Diala
How the interface of state law and indigenous market laws contributes to peacebuilding in Nigeria is an unexplored question that demands attention. First, law, human security and peace are interrelated through the cultural ideas and norms that inform human behaviour. Second, the co-existence of normative orders in Africa favours a top-down approach that inadequately acknowledges indigenous law, neglects its economic, cultural and religious influences, and thereby affects human security. Based on key informant interviews, focus group discussions and observation of markets in southern Nigeria, this article finds that although indigenous market laws are much altered, their foundational values inform market union constitutions, bye-laws and dispute resolution mechanisms. Union officials draft these laws with the assistance of Western-trained legal practitioners and apply them in close co-operation with state organs, who recognize market tribunals as quasi-judicial bodies. The article urges policy attention on the manner people adapt indigenous market laws to socio-economic changes.