27 February 2025 in International Journal of Qualitative Methods
Artificially intelligent (AI) tools hold significant potential for researchers during the processes of qualitative literature review. Beyond only literature retrieval, some AI tools describe their use-value as being able to appraise and synthesise contrasting evidence within and across papers; work like ‘Spotify’ to cultivate a personalised ecosystem of research articles that evolves via algorithmic learning; and suggest new directions for research based on existing evidence about a topic and an assessment of knowledge gaps. It is critical to explore how the emergence and evolution of tools which apply artificial intelligence might nuance processes and possibilities for qualitive thinking and knowledge development. Our manuscript engages with this critical challenge by using multi-layered forms of reasoning to develop a critical imagination for qualitative researchers integrating novel forms of AI into their literature review methodology. We outline the roles and functions of ten AI tools that identify their role in supporting researchers map, synthesise, and appraise knowledge – using the citation environment (i.e., Citation Tree, Semantic Scholar, Open Knowledge, Connected Papers, Inciteful), article content (i.e., Litmaps, VosViewer), and those suggested capable of assessing the literature to summarise key terrain or suggest next steps for inquiry (i.e., SciteAI, Elicit, Research Rabbit). We situate our critical imagination reflexively within the intellectual and lived histories which contour qualitative thinking and theorisation. We further elucidate how the evolving social construction of knowledge as a cultural good, in which AI tools and qualitative research/ers are both imbricated, requires a critical consciousness capable of illuminating how AI might nuance knowledge systems in which the interpretive work of qualitative research is also enfolded. From this juncture, we discuss ethical implications of the uncritical use of AI tools during review of literature and delineate essential reflexive responsibilities for researchers who integrate AI tools into their methodology for qualitative literature review.
21 October 2023 in Methodological Innovations
Practice theory-based research has been established theoretically as an answer to health and social problems, but its use in empirical research is still emerging. We conducted a scoping review in accordance with JBI guidelines for evidence synthesis to identify methodological characteristics of practice theory-based research concerning parenting. A total of 2681 abstracts were identified, with 214 retained for full text screening. A total of 33 articles were included in the review. The included studies in the review focussed on a range of practices relating to parenting including meal preparation and cooking, mobility and transport, homework and school engagement. Major findings from this scoping review identified the use of multiple methods to draw on different aspects of practice and a high variety of time frames for data collection. The tailoring of practice theory approaches was highly varied, and some studies also combined practice theory with alternate theory and concepts. The results reveal significant diversity in the use of social practice theory, the range of methodological approaches used and the application of a high variety of methods. All studies used some form of interview to investigate practices and ethnography was a main methodological approach adopted. Across the studies there were recommendations for expanding sampling and recruitment strategies. Given the call to adopt new approaches to parenting and child development research, our review serves as a mapping of the multitude of ways practice theory-based research can provide can be used to examine parenting.
1 April 2025 in International Journal of Qualitative Methods
Social practice theory offers valuable insights for public health research, particularly in understanding how health inequalities are sustained through everyday practices. A recent increase in social practice theory scholarship has focused on the development of flexible methodologies which allow for empirical investigations of social practices. This paper introduces a flexible, practice-based approach designed to address methodological challenges in studying interconnected practices, which we call a “method menu”. The method menu allows for the adaptable selection of data collection methods, including practice-based interviews, observations of practice spaces, and explorations of material and digital elements. The approach we outline also allows flexibility for the participants, by offering choice and control over engagement within the data collection process, with considerations of their preferences, availability and consent. Using a metaphorical menu structure, participants can engage in the research project and choose to commit to only a single interview or commit to multiple courses of data collection (i.e. interviews and home visit). The method menu facilitates modification of participation over time to address barriers to research participation. The method menu was developed and tested through research examining early childhood oral health practices within naturally living families. Developed using a social practice theory perspective, it facilitates the investigation of both individual performance of practices and their relational dynamics, particularly in contexts where traditional ethnographic methods or prolonged investigations may be constrained. Even where traditional ethnographic approaches are feasible, the method menu can offer researchers a way to undertake data collection that grants participants greater agency in determining their level of research engagement. The method menu responds to calls for methodological innovation within SPT research while acknowledging the complexities researchers may encounter within broader research fields.
13 September 2024 in JDR Clinical & Translational Research
Background: Oral health continues to be one of the most common and costly diseases in early childhood, and there is a need for further, innovative research. Purpose: We explored the ways naturally living parents (those who embody the “natural” within their parenting ideology and behavior) navigated and perceived their children’s oral health. Methods: Twelve participants who identified as being “naturally living parents” participated in semistructured interviews. Data were thematically analyzed, and findings were aligned to an omissions and commissions framework to exhibit the complexity of parent decision-making. Results: Parents performed distinct omissions, including omitting fluoride, sugar, and “toxins” to maintain their children’s oral health. Parents talked about having a commitment to knowledge building to protect their children’s oral health (e.g., ingredient label reading and increasing knowledge of “safe” ingredients). Findings also provide insight into how parents consider and trust health information and health care providers and ways they gather information relating to oral health. Conclusions: Analysis indicated that although parents navigated both omissions and commissions, omissions were more overtly present. Compared to previous health research using this framework, omissions and commissions were not as clearly demarcated in relation to oral health. The results show that oral health is a complex interplay of omissions and commissions, and parents must navigate not only discrete elements that affect the oral health of their children but also how these are influenced by considerations including social well-being. Knowledge Transfer Statement: The study highlights the need for dentists and early childhood health professionals to consider the complex way some parents perceive, inform, and rationalize decisions regarding their children’s oral health. There is a need for nuance when considering children’s oral health and naturally living parenting, especially in relation to effectively communicating health information that fosters trust and is considerate of broader lifestyle and health factors.