Division of Innovations in Human Health & Life Sciences, Amsterdam Institute of Molecular and Life Sciences (AIMMS), Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam, Amsterdam, the Netherlands
Auto-generated profile, based on publicly available information
Mirella V. Jongsma
Division of Innovations in Human Health & Life Sciences, Amsterdam Institute of Molecular and Life Sciences (AIMMS), Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam, Amsterdam, the Netherlands
In recent years, the technical possibilities of educational technologies regarding online peer feedback have developed rapidly. However, the impact of online peer feedback activities compared to traditional offline variants has not specifically been meta-analyzed. Therefore, the aim of the current meta-analysis is to do an in-depth comparison between online versus offline peer feedback approaches. An earlier and broader meta-analysis focusing on technology-facilitated peer feedback in general, was used as a starting point. We synthesized 12 comparisons between online and offline peer feedback in higher education, from 10 different studies. Moreover, we reviewed student perceptions of online peer feedback when these were included in the studies. The results show that online peer feedback is more effective than offline peer feedback, with an effect size of 0.33. Moreover, online peer feedback is more effective when the outcome measure is competence rather than self-efficacy for skills. In addition, students are mostly positive towards online peer feedback but also list several downsides. Finally, implications for online peer feedback in teaching practice are discussed and leads are identified for further research on this topic.
With the emergence of new technologies, various methods for providing online peer feedback have become available. While the effects of online peer feedback on student perceptions and learning are often compared to those of offline peer feedback, there is a lack of research comparing different online feedback environments. This study focuses on how the structure of an online peer feedback platform influences the feedback given, student perceptions of it, and learning outcomes. Using an experimental crossover design with mixed methods, we compared two online peer feedback environments: a traditional approach utilizing Word and email, and a specialized online tool designed for feedback activities. Thirty-eight undergraduate students in pharmaceutical sciences were divided into two groups, each participating in two peer feedback activities—one using the online feedback tool and the other using the traditional approach. Results show that the type of feedback given varied significantly depending on the platform used. The structured online tool prompted more praise and local-level comments, while the traditional approach facilitated more revision-oriented and global-level feedback. However, the results did not support an effect of the platforms on student learning outcomes as assessed by teacher grades for the assignments. Students overwhelmingly preferred the structured online tool for its ease of use. These findings suggest that platform design can significantly shape the quality of peer feedback and student experiences. Our study emphasizes the significance of selecting the appropriate platform and software settings to align with specific feedback objectives, ultimately aiming to enhance both student engagement and the quality of feedback.