19 February 2024 in Heliyon
Accurate estimation of the reference evapotranspiration (ETo) is crucial for determining crop water requirements. However, the lack of appropriate weather stations representing croplands, particularly in drylands, may adversely influence the accuracy of ETo estimates. To overcome this issue, a promising approach is to use meteorological stations in cropland areas to collect weather data that are representative of actual conditions. However, the number of agrometeorological stations in these areas is limited. Therefore, this study aims to assess the effectiveness of three datasets, including ERA5 and ERA5-Land, and WaPOR (Water Productivity Open-access portal), for estimating ETo in cropland areas on a basin scale. The land use/land cover (LULC) of the European Space Agency (ESA) was used to identify the sites resembling agrometeorological stations. Data were collected from 2009 to 2022, and the FAO-Penman-Monteith method was used to estimate daily and monthly ETo. The accuracy and reliability of ETo estimates with the three datasets were evaluated by comparing them with ETo estimated by ground measurements. Statistical analysis metrics, normalized root mean squared error (nRMSE), and relative mean bias error (rMBE) were used to assess the performance of the datasets. This study highlights that ERA5 exhibited superior overall performance compared to other datasets in estimating ETo. However, WaPOR performed better at high-altitude stations with inhomogeneous topography than ECMWF reanalysis (i.e., ERA5 and ERA5-L). Thus, none of the datasets could provide accurate ETo estimates for all the stations within the basin. Therefore, applying the best-performing data source yielded better results than using a single dataset. These findings are valuable for improving irrigation scheduling and water management practices on a large scale, particularly in regions facing data scarcity challenges.
1 July 2020 in Journal of the Indian Society of Remote Sensing
3 August 2023 in International Journal of Remote Sensing
15 August 2024 in Heliyon
This study presents a comprehensive framework for analyzing water productivity products provided by the FAO Water Productivity Open-access portal (WaPOR), focusing on various crops cultivated in both rainfed and irrigated areas within a semi-arid basin in Iran. Two indices, namely Gross Water Productivity (GWP) and Net Water Productivity (NWP), were introduced to quantify water productivity across crop fields. However, these indices may mislead decision-makers, because they aggregate water productivity for all crops and exacerbate the challenges posed by water scarcity. Therefore, mapping crop types seems necessary to enhance the interpretation of these indices and develop a dimensionless index for comparing different crops. The results demonstrated a fundamental change when comparing dimensionless water productivity with GWP and NWP products. Surprisingly, some pixels initially exhibiting high water productivity ranked as low water-productive pixels based on the derived dimensionless index, and vice versa. Based on dimensionless indicators, rainfed crops, particularly rainfed cereals, ranked as the most water-productive crops. The areas with dimensionless values below 0.5 warrant heightened attention to curtail non-beneficial water consumption and elevate water productivity. This research emphasizes the significance of mapping cultivation types as supplementary layers to facilitate precise, data-driven decision-making and enable comparisons of crops based on dimensionless water productivity indices.
2 April 2026 in Journal of Hydrology: Regional Studies
18 January 2023 in Research Square
Appropriate determination of actual evapotranspiration (ETa) is crucial to improve crop water productivity and optimizing water resource consumption. Satellite data enables us to calculate ETa for a large spatial extent with higher granularity, but the temporal frequency of non-commercial satellite data is often a limitation. This research proposes a method that combines crop coefficients with satellite data to fill temporal data gaps and calculate ETa on a daily basis. The study was conducted on sugarcane crops in the Amirkabir Agro-industries area in the southern part of Khuzestan Province, southwestern Iran. First, Landsat-8 data with the 8- day temporal resolution is acquired to estimate Land Surface Temperature (LST) using Single-Channel Algorithm. The estimated LST is validated with the in-situ canopy temperature measurement via Infrared Thermometer (IRT). Then, the validated LST is used to predict the crop stress coefficient (Ks) based on its relationship with the crop water stress index (CWSI). The crop coefficient (Kc) is obtained from the Surface Energy Balance Algorithm for Land (SEBAL) algorithm. The predicted Ks and Kc with the 8-day temporal resolution are assumed to be constant during the eight days and are utilized to calculate daily ETa by multiplying by the daily reference evapotranspiration (ET0) obtained from local meteorological data. The calculated Ks based on the LST result showed that nRMSE ranged from 0.03 to 0.07 from April to September. The results indicate that the crop coefficients of sugarcane in the initial and mid-stage are 12% and 18%, respectively, higher than the proposed figures by the FAO56 guideline. The aggregated decadal and monthly ETa have shown remarkable similarity with the WaPOR datasets, represented by an RMSE of 8.7 and 1.93 mm, respectively. We think this naval approach can significantly overcome the challenge of remote sensing data availability with the desired higher temporal resolution.