This article reflects on the tensions I encountered as an insider researcher during a qualitative study exploring academics’ integration of educational technology in a South African higher education institution. While critical qualitative approaches acknowledge research participants’ vulnerability to the researcher’s interpretation and presentation of their experiences, this article reflects on researcher vulnerability engendered by my insider status. Through a critical ethnographic lens, I reflexively interrogate the shifting nuances of power, positionality and being in educational technology research with regard to: (1) the struggle to adopt a colonialist methodology in a context still reeling from colonial legacies; (2) sensitively negotiating conflicting role requirements as a researcher, an employee and a PhD student in the same institution; (3) reflecting on the ‘politics of the gaze’ and how my insider status influenced what data I collected and how I perceived it; and (4) grappling with the tensions inherent in attempting to represent the experiences of the Other through my own.
21 August 2023 in Innovations in Education and Teaching International
Learning design in higher education seeks to promote the development of learning experiences that enable students to meet the outcomes of a course while actively engaging in learning. The form that learning design takes should ideally differ depending on, among other reasons, who the learner is, the purpose of the course and where the learning will take place. In this chapter, I reflect on the development of a fully online Introduction to NVivo short course for postgraduate students at a university in South Africa. I draw on one of several distinguishing characteristics of postgraduate education – the knowledge-identity nexus – to frame the learning design of the course. My main argument is that postgraduate education poses a unique set of challenges for learning designers, and an awareness of these differences should ideally foreground learning design practices at this level.
This study presents an Autonomy-values framework for analysing, designing, and selecting AI academic advising systems. Through focus groups with advisors using Nominal Group Technique, we identified contextually specific values that were then generalised using Legitimation Code Theory's Autonomy lens. The resulting framework maps advising values across four positions: Student-Centred, Advisor-Centred, Institution-Centred, and Social-Centred. By combining values-sensitive design with LCT Autonomy, this work advances knowledge on human-centred approaches to AI implementation in academic advising and broader educational contexts.
To contribute to cracking the theoretical AI in education code, interviews with academic advisors at a European university were analysed using a dialogic-relational translation device to develop a sociomaterial framework for building EdTech and AIEd theory. The four personas (Consultant, Coach, Counsellor, Collaborator) emerging from the data analysis represent the mental models of academic advisors regarding using technology in their practice. These personas could be used to understand the underlying dynamic of the academic advising practice, for developing personalised training, or to design future human-centred AI-infused academic advising systems. The dialogic-relational framework could also be adapted to create translation devices to analyse and build EdTech and AIEd theory regarding other educational teaching-learning-assessment practices.
The role of supervisors has become more problematic since the rise of generative Artificial Intelligence (GenAI) in higher education and the disruption it has caused to teaching and research practices. This contribution employs a collaborative autoethnographic approach to articulate the various ways in which AI can act as a "precipitant" of challenges intrinsic to the position of PhD supervision in contemporary global academia, from the perspectives of four experienced supervisors based in the UK and South Africa. Drawing on their own experiences as PhD students, researchers, and supervisors of doctoral candidates, the authors shared possible answers and tensions using agreed-upon prompts to generate discussions that included the principles of academic integrity and ethical research practices that supervisors aim to cultivate in PhD students in the age of GenAI. Potential factors mitigating the misuse of the technology were discussed as part of this autoethnographic exploration, which coincidentally highlights the relational and chronological dimensions of the PhD, rather than the current hegemonic focus on "rushing to the end" and the final output.