Stuart Trent Guthrie

Stuart Trent Guthrie

Auto-generated profile, based on publicly available information

Stuart Trent Guthrie

Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Henry Ford Hospital , Detroit, MI

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

8Years (2019-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
1 March 2019 in JBJS Reviews
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
TJToufic R. Jildeh
Toufic R. Jildeh
KOKelechi R. Okoroha
Kelechi R. Okoroha
SGS. Trent Guthrie
S. Trent Guthrie
TPTheodore W. Parsons
Theodore W. Parsons
» There has been increasing use of social media in recent years by hospitals and health-care providers. Social media can provide an extension of the physician to an online presence and have potential practice-building implications. » Online social networks such as Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, and Snapchat are widely used and provide convenient opportunities for marketing, patient education, generation of referrals, professional development, and other career opportunities. Also, professional networks provide physicians with opportunities for collaboration, potentially improving care. » The benefits of social media use must be weighed against the potential risks, including potential liability, confidentiality breach, and risk to reputation. » This article reviews the current state of social media use for the orthopaedic surgeon, with focus on utilization of an online surgeon-patient relationship, compliance with ethical obligations, professionalism, and reputation.

2 January 2019 in Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
JLJane Liu
Jane Liu
KSKaran Srivastava
Karan Srivastava
TWTravis Washington
Travis Washington
JHJoseph Hoegler
Joseph Hoegler
SGS. Trent Guthrie
S. Trent Guthrie
VMVasilios Moutzouros
Vasilios Moutzouros
Background: While previous studies have shown higher union rates and a quicker return to work with operative treatment of substantially displaced clavicle fractures, there is disagreement whether operative treatment results in improved clinical outcomes. Patients who undergo operative treatment sometimes require additional surgery for implant removal. Nonoperative treatment may fail so that delayed surgical intervention is ultimately required. The duration for which the clinical benefits of operative treatment remain superior to those of nonoperative treatment has not been well established in the literature. Considering these uncertainties, surgeons are faced with a difficult decision regarding whether operative treatment of a midshaft clavicle fracture will be cost-effective. The purpose of this study was to identify the most cost-effective strategy by considering these uncertain parameters with use of decision-analysis techniques. Methods: An expected-value decision tree was built to estimate the quality-adjusted life years (QALYs) and costs for operative and nonoperative treatment of substantially displaced midshaft clavicle fractures. Values for parameters in the decision model were derived from the literature. Medical costs were obtained from the Medicare database. A Markov model was used to calculate the QALYs for the duration of life expectancy. The decision model was used to analyze the duration for which the clinical results of operative treatment were superior to those of nonoperative treatment during the first 5 years after the operation and during a lifetime. Sensitivity analysis was performed to determine which parameters have the most influence on cost-effectiveness. Results: Operative treatment was more cost-effective than nonoperative treatment in 54% and 68% of the Monte Carlo trials in the 5-year and lifetime analyses, respectively. The cost per QALY with operative management was <$38,000 and <$8,000 in the 5-year and lifetime analyses, respectively. This is below the willingness-to-pay threshold of $50,000 per QALY. For operative treatment to remain cost-effective, its clinical benefits must persist for at least 3 years. Conclusions: Operative treatment is more cost-effective than nonoperative treatment for substantially displaced midshaft clavicle fractures. The clinical benefits derived with operative treatment must persist for at least 3 years for operative treatment to remain cost-effective. This research should not be used to conclude that all clavicle fractures should be treated surgically. It is best that such a decision is made through a patient-surgeon shared decision-making process. Level of Evidence: Economic and Decision Analysis Level II. See Instructions for Authors for a complete description of levels of evidence.

1 April 2024 in JBJS Open Access
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
SGStuart Trent Guthrie
Stuart Trent Guthrie
TDTanios Dagher
Tanios Dagher
JEJodi Essey-Stapleton
Jodi Essey-Stapleton
TBTessa Balach
Tessa Balach
Introduction: The orthopaedic surgery match has experienced a consistent increase in both the number of applicants and applications submitted per applicant. Preference signaling was implemented during the 2022 to 2023 application cycle in part to curtail the rising application burden on both applicants and residency programs. Our aim was to explore the impact of the preference signaling system on applicant and residency program leader attitudes, behaviors, and outcomes. Methods: We distributed surveys to American Orthopaedic Association/Council of Orthopaedic Residency Directors member program leaders (program directors, assistant program directors, and program coordinators) and applicants registered for the Electronic Standardized Letter of Recommendation after Universal Interview Offer Day 2022 (Fall Survey) and Match Day 2023 (Spring Survey). The surveys contained multiple-choice and numeric response questions on attitudes, behaviors, and outcomes that were analyzed and reported as percentages and medians, respectively. Open-text responses were reviewed for dominant themes. Results: One hundred program leaders and 378 applicants (47%) completed the Fall Survey, and 146 program leaders and 290 applicants (36%) completed the Spring Survey. A majority of applicants (71%) and program leadership (91%) support the continued use of signaling. Applicants reported a 16% reduction in the number of programs to which they applied. Program directors largely used signaling as a tool for screening applications (75%), with few programs using signaling in the ranking process (20%). Applicants reported that 81% of their interviews were from programs they signaled. Slightly more than half of programs (53%) reported filling their last slot at a higher rank order position than the average of the previous 5 years. Qualitative analysis suggests a need for more transparency in the use of signals, consideration of application and/or interview caps, and reconsideration of the other components of the application. Conclusion: Preference signaling in the orthopaedic surgery match was met with positive feedback and led to a reduction in the number of applications. Future research will examine the continued impact of preference signaling and assess alterations for optimizing the match process.

1 January 2020 in JBJS Open Access
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
AAApril D. Armstrong
April D. Armstrong
JAJulie Agel
Julie Agel
MBMatthew D. Beal
Matthew D. Beal
MBMichael S. Bednar
Michael S. Bednar
MCMichelle S. Caird
Michelle S. Caird
AHAnn E. Van Heest
Ann E. Van Heest
Update: This article was updated on March 17, 2022, because of previous errors on pages 1, 4, 5, 6, and 7. In the Abstract, Results, and Discussion sections, the specificity of the ABOS Behavior Assessment Tool that had read “57%” and “57% (95% CI 52% to 62%)” now reads “51%” and “51% (95% CI 45% to 56%).” In the Abstract, “1,012 evaluators” now reads “1,016 evaluators” and “431 residents” now reads “428 residents.” In the Results section entitled “Evaluation Results per Resident,” the sentence that had read “The domain with the greatest number of residents exhibiting low scores was ethical behavior.” now reads “The domain with the greatest number of residents exhibiting low scores was interaction.” In the Discussion section on pages 6 and 7, the number of residents with low scores in at least one domain that had read “176” now reads “196.” In Table III, the title that had read “Behavior Evaluations Completed by Resident Year in Training Source” now reads “Behavior Evaluations Completed by Resident Year in Training.” In Table VII, the column head that had read “No. of Residents with >2 Low Scores within the Same Domain” now reads “No. of Residents with ≥2 Low Scores within the Same Domain.” Also in Table VII, in columns 2 and 3, the values that had read “26 (6%), 23 (5%), 19 (4%), 18 (4%), and 20 (5%)” now read “32 (8%), 61 (14%), 63 (15%), 57 (13%), and 59 (14%).” In Table VIII, the column head that had read “No. of Baseline Professionalism PD Assessment Low Score Residents (N = 32) Also with Low Scores on the Behavior Tool by at least 2 Evaluators” now reads “No. of Baseline Professionalism PD Assessment Low Score Residents (N = 32) Also with Low Scores on the Behavior Tool.” In Table IX, the title that had read “Number of Low Domain Scores by at least 2 Evaluators for Low Baseline Professionalism PD Assessment Score Residents (n = 32)*” now reads “Number of Low Domain Scores for Low Baseline Professionalism PD Assessment Score Residents (n = 32)*”. Also, the values in the table that had read “6, 3, 2, 2, 6, 13” now read “7, 2, 1, 3, 5, 14.” In Table X, the title that had read “Specificity and Sensitivity of the ABOS Behavior Tool Compared with PD Baseline Assessment for All Participating Residents (n = 440)*” now reads “Specificity and Sensitivity of the ABOS Behavior Tool Compared with PD Baseline Assessment for All Participating Residents (n = 428)*.” Also in Table X, in the right column entitled “PD Baseline Assessment High Score (3 or 4),” the values that had read “176” and “232” now read “196” and “200,” respectively. Finally, a supplementary data file has now been included with the article that contains results that portray resident performance with at least two low scores in one domain by at least two different evaluators. An erratum has been published: JBJS Open Access. 2022 Mar 31;7(1):e20.00103ER. Background: The purpose of this study was to determine the feasibility and evaluate the effectiveness of the American Board of Orthopaedic Surgery Behavior Tool (ABOSBT) for measuring professionalism. Methods: Through collaboration between the American Board of Orthopaedic Surgery and American Orthopaedic Association's Council of Residency Directors, 18 residency programs piloted the use of the ABOSBT. Residents requested assessments from faculty at the end of their clinical rotations, and a 360° request was performed near the end of the academic year. Program Directors (PDs) rated individual resident professionalism (based on historical observation) at the outset of the study, for comparison to the ABOSBT results. Results: Nine thousand eight hundred ninety-two evaluations were completed using the ABOSBT for 449 different residents by 1,016 evaluators. 97.6% of all evaluations were scored level 4 or 5 (high levels of professional behavior) across all of the 5 domains. In total, 2.4% of all evaluations scored level 3 or below reflecting poorer performance. Of 428 residents, the ABOSBT identified 26 of 32 residents who were low performers (2 or more < level 3 scores in a domain) and who also scored “below expectations” by the PD at the start of the pilot project (81% sensitivity and 51% specificity), including 13 of these residents scoring poorly in all 5 domains. Evaluators found the ABOSBT was easy to use (96%) and that it was an effective tool to assess resident professional behavior (81%). Conclusions: The ABOSBT was able to identify 2.4% low score evaluations (<level 3) for all residents. The tool was concordant with the PD for 81% of the residents considered low performers or “outliers” for professional behavior. The 5-domain construct makes it an effective actionable tool that can be used to help develop performance improvement plans for residents. Level of Evidence: Level II

1 July 2023 in JBJS Open Access
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
SBStewart A. Bryant
Stewart A. Bryant
AJAchraf H. Jardaly
Achraf H. Jardaly
BPBrent A. Ponce
Brent A. Ponce
SGS. Trent Guthrie
S. Trent Guthrie
HSHarris Slone
Harris Slone
JBJeremy Bruce
Jeremy Bruce
Background: Few evidence-based suggestions are available to help applicants and mentors improve reapplication outcomes. We sought to provide program directors' (PDs) perspectives on actionable steps to improve reapplicants' chances for a match. Methods: The PDs were asked to rank positions unmatched applicants can pursue, steps these applicants can take for the next application cycle, and reasons why reapplicants do not match. Results: Responses from 66 of 123 PDs were received (53.6% response rate). Obtaining new recommendation letters and rotating with orthopaedics were the highest 20 ranked steps unmatched applicants can take. No curriculum vitae (CV) improvement, poor interview, and poor letters of recommendation were the most important reasons hindering applicants from matching when reapplying. Conclusions: Steps reapplicants could prioritize include obtaining new recommendation letters, rotating in orthopaedics, and producing new research items. CV strengthening and improving interview skills address the 2 main reasons why unmatched applicants failed in subsequent attempts. Level of Evidence: Level IV

4 September 2025 in Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
TBTessa Balach
Tessa Balach
SGStuart Trent Guthrie
Stuart Trent Guthrie
NSNicole Schroeder
Nicole Schroeder
ASAdrienne Socci
Adrienne Socci
The U.S. orthopaedic surgery residency match is among the most competitive in medicine; in 2024, 40% of applicants were unmatched. This drives applicants to differentiate themselves, while residency programs aim to evaluate candidates holistically. In order to understand the process that is used to select and educate the best surgeons, we examined medical student advising, the role of national organizations, and programmatic practices for resident selection. Effective career advising is essential for attracting and supporting highly qualified applicants. Exposure through preclinical courses, clerkships, and accessible mentorship enhances interest in orthopaedics among applicants with an array of experiences, skills, and backgrounds. National initiatives (e.g., the Orthopaedic Residency Information Network [ORIN]) provide centralized resources to address disparities in information access, although further standardization and consolidation are needed. Collaboration among national stakeholders is necessary to ensure fairness in the match process and to attract the best applicants. Initiatives like preference signaling have shown promise, increasing interview rates at preferred programs and better aligning applicants with residency opportunities. However, barriers such as limited access to research, costly away rotations, and expensive applications disproportionately affect underrepresented groups, highlighting the need for systemic changes. Resident selection practices must evolve to counter the inefficiencies and biases. Holistic review processes, structured interviews, and mission-driven scoring can improve alignment with program values. Programs must consider their setting and their population and also consider applicants who demonstrate an understanding of, and have an interest in caring for, that community. Improving orthopaedic residency selection requires collaborative efforts across organizations, advisors, and programs to refine processes and ensure the selection and training of those who will advance clinical orthopaedics and the science of orthopaedic surgery and also meet the needs of all patient populations.