Students enter school with a vast range of individual differences, resulting from the complex interplay between genetic dispositions and unequal environmental conditions. Schools thus face the challenge of organizing instruction and providing equal opportunities for students with diverse needs. Schools have traditionally managed student heterogeneity by sorting students both within and between schools according to their academic ability. However, empirical evidence suggests that such tracking approaches increase inequalities. In more recent years, driven largely by technological advances, there have been calls to embrace students’ individual differences in the classroom and to personalize students’ learning experiences. A central justification for personalized learning is its potential to improve educational equity. In this paper, we discuss whether and under which conditions personalized learning can indeed increase equity in K-12 education by bringing together empirical and theoretical insights from different fields, including the learning sciences, philosophy, psychology, and sociology. We distinguish between different conceptions of equity and argue that personalized learning is unlikely to result in “equality of outcomes” and, by definition, does not provide “equality of inputs”. However, if implemented in a high-quality way, personalized learning is in line with “adequacy” notions of equity, which aim to equip all students with the basic competencies to participate in society as active members and to live meaningful lives.
14 February 2014 in Zeitschrift für Erziehungswissenschaft
Studies have shown that teacher perceptions of student achievement influence teacher-student interactions, subsequently affecting student outcomes. However, teachers may also take note of and respond to the motivation and engagement of their students in a differential way, which could affect student outcomes as well. In the present study, we thus examined whether teacher perceptions of student motivation and engagement predict student achievement and self-reported motivation and engagement in reading and maths over several school years. Analysing longitudinal data from N = 2402 students and their teachers, we found that teacher perceptions of student motivation and engagement in Grade 5 were significantly related to student achievement in reading 1 year later and in maths 1, 2, and 3 years later. An association with student motivation and engagement was only found for maths 1 year later.
2 August 2018 in Zeitschrift für Erziehungswissenschaft
Der vorliegende Beitrag betrachtet den in Politik und Praxis populären Begriff der individuellen Förderung. Dazu wird zunächst erörtert, in welchen Kontexten und in welcher Form der Begriff bislang verwendet wurde. Anschließend werden im wissenschaftlichen Diskurs etablierte verwandte Konzepte von individueller Förderung und Erkenntnisse aus der kognitiven Lehr-Lern-Forschung und der Unterrichtsforschung dargestellt. Darauf aufbauend wird vorgeschlagen, individuelle Förderung im Sinne einer tiefgreifenden Gesamtunterrichtsstrategie zu verstehen, bei der die Lehrkraft den einzelnen Schülerinnen und Schülern ein an ihre spezifischen Lernvoraussetzungen angepasstes Lernangebot macht und das Ziel einer kontinuierlich zunehmenden Verantwortungsübernahme der Schülerinnen und Schüler für ihren eigenen Lernprozess verfolgt. Abschließend werden Implikationen dieser Konzeption für die Schulpraxis und die Bildungsforschung diskutiert. The present paper deals with the German concept “Individuelle Förderung”, which has been widely used in both policy and practice in recent years and may best be translated into “adaptive teaching” or “individualized instruction”. The paper first addresses the contexts and ways in which the term has been used. Several related concepts used in educational research and findings from research on learning and instruction are presented. Using these insights, the author proposes to conceptualize “Individuelle Förderung” as an overarching teaching concept in which teachers adapt their instruction to each student’s needs and aim to increase students’ responsibility for their own learning process. The paper closes with implications of this conceptualization for practice and research.